Having always thought fondly of Richard Linklater's underseen and underrated 1920s bank-heist comedy The Newton Boys, I've been eager to see the versatile, Austin-based director take another stab at directing a period film. Unfortunately, after catching up with Linklater's Me and Orson Welles here in Toronto, I wish he hadn't. Based on a 2005 young adult novel by Robert Kaplow, this is one of those whimsical historical films in which we see some storied event — in this case, Welles' landmark, 1937 staging of Julius Caesar — through the eyes of a minor background player. As Stephen Sondheim so memorably put it in his Pacific Overtures, "Without someone in a tree/Nothing happened here."
In Me and Orson Welles, that eyewitness to history is an eager-beaver high-school student named Richard Samuels (Zac Efron), who fast-talks his way into Welles' Mercury Theatre company and lands a bit part in Caesar as Lucius, the lute-playing servant boy who sings Brutus (played by Welles in the famous production) a gentle lullaby early on in Act IV. Naturally, the backstage drama at the Mercury rivals the Shakespearean text, as Welles (played with spot-on mimicry, but ultimately little nuance by British newcomer Christian McKay) postpones opening night, revises wildly on the spot, burns bridges and betrays friendships, all while somehow making everyone feel privileged to bask in his titanic genius. Those scenes are amusing up to a point, but given Linklater's considerable gifts as a keen observer of human behavior, they're curiously void of any real insight into Welles' creative process, a life in the theater, or anything else the movie thinks it's about. After a while, it starts to feel like we're watching a bunch of gesticulating lookalikes in a Broadway waxworks.
Still, better that than the hopelessly dopey, charmless flirtation between Richard and Welles' pert, upwardly mobile assistant (played in an atypically arch, fussy performance by Claire Danes). Together, they have all the romantic chemistry of two embalmed corpses, while Efron in particular is so markedly unconvincing as a Noel Coward-reading, Cole Porter-quoting bon vivant that Justin Timberlake would have been eminently preferable. The play's the thing here, with Linklater's climactic, lovingly detailed depiction of Caesar's opening night somewhat — but not nearly enough — redeeming what we've had to sit through to get there. I didn't go into Me and Orson Welles expecting another All About Eve exactly, but the folly of Linklater's film is that it make you think more kindly uponShakespeare in Love.
Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBacks (0)
Trackbacks
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://mt.laweekly.com/mt-tb.cgi/80194
Slideshows
Recent Posts
Archives
HeadLines
Most …
-
L.A. Opera’s $14 Million Imbroglio Superstar Plácido Domingo pushes the company closer to worldwide acclaim — and financial collapse
-
Rodney Alcala: The Fine Art of Killing One man’s murderous romp through polite society
-
Weed mags sprout across LOS ANGELES Publications reap windfall from pot ads
-
Living off the Grid When life takes you out of your house and into your car
-
Eli's Egoland? A billionaire twisted arms to use public land for luxury shops. Now Eli Broad wants to put his art there
CoverStory
NationalBlogs
-
Topless Robot
Mo' Lego Single Figures, Mo' Problems
02/09/10 4:31pm -
Heartless Doll
What Would Courtney Love Do? Valentine's Day
02/09/10 11:00am -
Joystick Division
Mass Effect 2: Cerberus Courtesy Weapon and Armor
02/09/10 1:00pm -
Daily Fork
McDonald's New Italian Burgers Actually Sound Delicious
02/09/10 11:30am -
True Crime Report
Susan Powell Disappearance: Her Parents Finally Turn on Husband Josh Powell
02/09/10 4:03pm -
Toke of the Town
Hawaii Marijuana Patients Want Dispensaries, More Plants
02/09/10 1:03pm -
Voice Film
Sundance Post-Mortem
02/02/10 3:06pm
SpecialIssues
BestOf
Top Stories
-
BONDAGE AND BURLESQUE
David Gueringer presents an erotically charged mix of... JOSH "CURIOUSJOSH" REISS
-
SUNDANCE'S REBEL YELL
The festival goes back to its roots — or does it? BY KARINA LONGWORTH
-
MONET'S BRISKETS: BLUDSO’S
At Compton BBQ joint, meat is high art. BY JONATHAN GOLD
-
L.A. WEEKLY WEB AWARDS
Full of so much win. BY ERIN BROADLEY
Daily Blogs »
- Residents Protest Massive Westside DevelopmentTue., Feb 9 '10 @ 12:57PM
- Credit Agencies Warn City On BudgetTue., Feb 9 '10 @ 11:32AM
- RZA Discusses Dressing Up Like George Washington:...Tue., Feb 9 '10 @ 1:45PM
- Passion of the Weiss Releases Ace Winter Mixtape [MP3]Tue., Feb 9 '10 @ 12:37PM
- Baking Whoopie: A New Whoopie Pie Online BakeryTue., Feb 9 '10 @ 1:48PM
- The McItaly: How Do You Say 'I'm NOT Loving It' in...Tue., Feb 9 '10 @ 12:38PM
- Ghost in the Shell vs. Sealab 2021 Mash-UpTue., Feb 9 '10 @ 7:28AM
- Five Steampunk Mice (And One Hideous Taxidermy...Tue., Feb 9 '10 @ 4:37AM
News »
Sending Trutanich to His Corner
by Gene Maddaus
Carmen Trutanich, the bulky and bullheaded city attorney, has been in office... More >>
-
Eli's Egoland?
So sorry, Santa Monica. Apologies, Beverly Hills. The jewel you have coveted and negotiated for — billionaire Eli Broad's proposed museum,... More >>
-
Public Unwelcome at Grand Avenue
Waiting for Los Angeles City Councilwoman Jan Perry to show up last week was like waiting for the glitzy Grand Avenue hotel-shop-condos project... More >>
-
VANS ARE NOT ALWAYS SNEAKERS
Last week's cover story on people living in their vehicles ("Living off the Grid: When life takes you out of your house and into your car," by... More >>
- Residents Protest Massive Westside DevelopmentTue Feb 9, @ 12:57PM
- Credit Agencies Warn City On BudgetTue Feb 9, @ 11:32AM
- 'Save the Peak:' Deal In Place To Preserve Land...Tue Feb 9, @ 6:00AM
Music »
Little Boxes
by David Cotner
Ten years ago, Nebraska expatriate and avant-minimalist composer Christiaan... More >>
-
The Nonsound of IAMSOUND
Only 26 when she launched the L.A.-based IAMSOUND label in 2006, Niki Robertson had been an A&R talent scout for U.K. label Parlophone and was... More >>
-
BOOM, BOOM, OW! SURVIVING GRAMMY...
View more photos in Lina Lecaro's "Nightranger Hits the Grammy Scene" slideshow. With a couple exceptions, "music's biggest night" was again... More >>
-
Rock Picks: Daedelus, Beth...
Friday/February/5Daedelus, Nosaj Thing, Jogger at the Echoplex We've heard rumors that Pasadena bass-head Nosaj Thing may be releasing his... More >>
- Passion of the Weiss Releases Ace Winter Mixtape [MP3]Tue Feb 9, @ 12:37PM
- IAMSOUND Launches 7-inch Series Ft. Nosaj Thing,...Tue Feb 9, @ 11:30AM
- Strange Boys Release New Video featuring Ex-Miko...Tue Feb 9, @ 9:44AM
Restaurants »
Monet's Briskets: Bludso’s
by Jonathan Gold
If the fires are burning high and you turn up at the right time of day, the... More >>
-
Lapp Trance
Dear Mr. Gold: A friend went back to Wisconsin for the holidays and returned with a bounty of cheesy treats. I was introduced to... More >>
-
W Is for Brasserie
When food people visit New York, they may check out what David Chang or Mario Batali are up to, contemplate a fancy French meal and swing by the... More >>
-
Lazy Ox Canteen: Where's bäco?
View more photos in Anne Fishbein's "Lazy Ox Canteen" photo gallery.If you are a man who enjoys a little Black Sabbath with his dinner, the new... More >>
- Baking Whoopie: A New Whoopie Pie Online BakeryTue Feb 9, @ 1:48PM
- The McItaly: How Do You Say 'I'm NOT Loving It' in...Tue Feb 9, @ 12:38PM
- Coming Soon to Brentwood: Spumoni Italian Cafe and...Tue Feb 9, @ 11:35AM
Film »
Sundance's Rebel Yell
by KARINA LONGWORTH
On a frigid Sunday night at the end of the Sundance Film Festival's first... More >>
-
Yippee Ki Yay, Fils de Putain
As personal assistant to the U.S. ambassador to France, James Reese (Jonathan Rhys Meyers) can keep himself in well-tailored suits and keep his... More >>
-
Czeching Out at the Silent Movie...
The further we get from it, the clearer it seems that the Age of the Waves — the '60s and '70s, roughly demarcated — was film... More >>
-
Rainy Sunday
The rain that sheets down in nearly every scene of Robert Hamer's 1947 It Always Rains on Sunday is as much a psychological phenomenon as a... More >>
- Sundance Post-MortemTue Feb 2, @ 3:06PM
- Catfish: the ultimate YouTube movieFri Jan 29, @ 6:51PM
- The Kids Are Alright -- and this gay marriage...Fri Jan 29, @ 1:49PM
Art »
A Paranoid in Reverse:...
by F.x. Feeney
If originality is, as Vladimir Nabokov suggests, the true measure of greatness... More >>
-
Matter's Most
Some people have it rough. Born into the East Coast cultural aristocracy in 1913, Mercedes Matter began life as a beloved and privileged... More >>
-
Tom LaDuke at Angles Gallery
Asking about the "seeming conflict, or antagonism, between painting's representational function and its self-reflection," the art historian and... More >>
-
The Bish, The Fish and The...
Ginny Bishton is an artist who defies expectations. Or rather, completely dismantles them, leaving their components arranged in neat rows. One... More >>
- Ghost in the Shell vs. Sealab 2021 Mash-UpTue Feb 9, @ 7:28AM
- Five Steampunk Mice (And One Hideous Taxidermy...Tue Feb 9, @ 4:37AM
- Stage Raw: Why Torture is WrongMon Feb 8, @ 3:14PM
The Ads »
All of our offline ads, online.
Ads, Special Issues, Flipbook
Special Issues
We present several issues where we highlight our premier clients. Here's the top providers of goods and services in your area.
- X-Games GuideFri, Apr 25 '08 12:41pm
- VH1 GuideMon, Jul 7 '08 12:05pm
- The Rolling Paper - Medical Marijuana Guide Wed, Feb 3 '10 2:08pm
LikeMe »
House of BluesWest Hollywood, CA |
The Magic CastleL.A., CA |
Urth CaffeBeverly Hills, CA |
Your Favorite Places
Even if you haven't been to them yet.
Sign up to discover tried and tested places to eat, drink, dance, shop and explore - in the city you live in, and the cities you visit.
Comments