By Mel Yiasemide
In its opening sequences at a packed Directors Guild Theatre last Monday, Michael Moore's Sicko had the crowd laughing with disbelief as a dumbfoundingly boyish President Bush lamented that "too many OB/GYN's aren't able to practice their love with women all across the country."
The laughter, and the tears, continued throughout, as Sicko's overriding point, that the world's wealthiest country must provide free, universal health care to its citizens – with Britain, France and Cuba as chief examples – was delivered with a potent mix of searing truth and comedic revelation.
Post-screening, a black-clad, baseball-capped Michael Moore took to the stage for a Q&A after being introduced by director Ron Howard, the evening's MC.
"We just came back from San Pedro Street in front of the Rescue Mission," Moore explained. He had set up a giant screen at Skid Row and broadcast Sicko to the homeless people there. "Our big L.A. press conference is... tomorrow night. But I wanted to have the first showing at Skid Row. It was really something.
"I've been really bothered by the security camera footage when I first saw it," he continued, referring to a scene in Sicko that shows a disoriented old homeless woman circling L.A.'s Skid Row sidewalk after being
dropped off there from a nearby hospital.
When director Howard opened the floor up to questions, it was clear that most of the audience loved this movie and strongly backed its cause. "What do we do?" asked one man. "Support SB 840," Moore answered quickly, referring to the California Universal Healthcare Act authored by Senator Sheila Kuehl. "And HR 676," its nationwide counterpart.
"We spent two and a half months reading more than 25,000 e-mails," he said of the overwhelming public response to his call for health care horror stories when he was researching this film. That's when Sicko's goal became clear: "Saving ten lives isn't gonna do it. Don't chase one company, but the system. We have to talk about who we are as a people. I can't understand why a society does this, why it allows nine million kids to have no health insurance."
"What's your answer going to be when people bring up the inevitable issue of treating illegal immigrants?" another audience member asked.
Moore's reply was simple: If a person needs medical attention in this country, we can – and should – give it, no questions asked. If America can afford to spend trillions fighting a war in Iraq, and an embargoed, impoverished Cuba can provide citizens and noncitizens alike with some of the most renowned medical care in the world without charge, so can we. "Maybe we should ask ourselves, what would Jesus do?"
He talked about the time he staged a health care Olympics on his NBC show TV Nation: He had dispatched film crews to hospitals in Florida, Canada and Cuba, in a real-time experiment to see which country's medical team could fix a broken bone fastest and cheapest. "Bob Costas and Ahmad Rashad did a play-by-play. Cuba won. She set the bone correctly, charged nothing. Canada almost won, but she charged the guy $15 for crutches. She came in second. We got a call from standards and practices: 'Cuba can't win.' 'They did.' 'Not on NBC. We can't show it.' We actually switched it on the show – Canada won.
"I can't believe I actually took a boat to Cuba," said Moore, about the trip – documented in Sicko – in which he travels to the Communist state with three insured Americans whose own country has let them down in their search for adequate, affordable treatment of ailments they developed after volunteering at Ground Zero. "Now here I am in trouble with the government because I went to Cuba. I'm under some kind of investigation with criminal penalties for violating the embargo act or something."
Moore recalled the time a set worker at the 2003 Academy Awards called him an asshole, just after he'd won an Oscar for Bowling for Columbine, then denounced Bush for declaring war on Iraq, an act of unabashed honesty that got him booed off the stage. Years later, that same man ran into Moore again on a different film set. He approached Moore to tell him he was profusely sorry for what he had done, and for ruining his Oscar moment.
"It's okay, I told him. You believed your president. You should be able to believe your president."
Moore implored Republicans and Democrats to come together to build a universal health care plan that does away with insurance companies and other middlemen: "I really want to reach out to people who don't necessarily share my political views. All Americans should be able to see a doctor and not have to
worry about paying for it."
Sicko will undoubtedly build the kinds of bridges between America and other countries that so many U.S. films and media outlets have failed – or refused – to do.
Says Moore: "Fox News called it brilliant and uplifting last week, and I thought, 'Are they trying to ruin me?' "
Also read Ella Taylor's review of Sicko.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://mt.laweekly.com/mt-tb.cgi/35388
• Advertisement •
Comments
There are 2 comments posted for this article.
[...] LA Weekly's Ella Taylor recounts her experiences with private Health Maintenance Organizations that Michael Moore attacks in his new documentary Sicko (2007). Taylor concludes that despite her criticisims, "the movie is a great piece of populist outrage and a dangerously good comedy about a looming American tragedy." Also check out a review of Moore's Q&A with the Director's Guild of America here. [...]
Posted on June 29, 2007 2:06 AM by novus.liber » Blog Archive » Sicko's Bitter Pill
I have not seen the movie, but my wife is a independent insurance agent, and she helps anyone over age 65 that does not have the proper insurance plan or need assistance. The stories that she tells me is just sad. We have many minorities that are in pain , living with very serious problems. Not being able to get their teeth taken care of,only receiving about 400 to 700 dollars a month to live on, and must use a least half of that to pay for health coverage. Many things they must do with out. One man had not had glasses for over a year, she was able to reduce his cost over all and he finally got a pair of glasses.
A lot of older whites americans are just doing with out , filling to proud to switch plans and scared to change.Or if your a miniorty trying to help them , they just wont buy a great plan that would save them hundereds of dollars a month. Some feell like they are helping the government by continuing to paying the high cost, they dont wont to be in the governments pockets as if the government really cares about them.
Its very sad , the United States has let the American Citizens down. Its all about the wealthy and a few chosen ones. We all know that you cant take the money with you when you die, so why dont they see that everyone wants to live a normal life too.
P.S. Find some organizations that has a connection with the local people and donate money to the people that can help its citizens.
Posted on July 1, 2007 2:07 PM by C Mackey