Top

blog

Stories

 

Who Won Governor's Debate? Jerry Brown Or Meg Whitman?

Categories: Politics
jerry-brown.jpg
Jerry Brown
Jerry Brown and Meg Whitman just wrapped up a feisty debate, in which Brown felt compelled to opine on whether "whore" is as bad as the n-word and Whitman struggled to say nothing about Sarah Palin.

There was plenty of substance as well, including a question on the state of Los Angeles police and fire pensions, along with the climate change regulations, immigration, and the power of the California Teachers' Association.

Whitman, down slightly in the polls, went on the attack, going after Brown for appointing Rose Bird to the Supreme Court and taking him to task for being part of the "war on jobs in this state for 40 years."
Brown wasn't shy either, asking Whitman how much she stood to gain from her proposal to eliminate the capital gains tax.

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for whitmanpresserB.jpg
Meg Whitman
Watching Brown speak can be like watching a drunk guy cross an icy street, and he stumbled the most when trying to deal with the "whore" controversy. First, he took issue with Tom Brokaw's claim that "whore" is as bad a slur as the n-word.

"I don't agree with that comparison," he for some reason felt compelled to say. He then went on to offer some excuses -- it was a cell phone, it was garbled, it was five weeks ago -- before claiming it might be illegal to record a private conversation. (Of course, he's the one who recorded it by failing to hang up the phone.)  Finally, he got around to saying what he should have said up front: "It's unfortunate. I'm sorry. I apologize."

After asking about the "whore" remark, Brokaw must have decided he had to balance it out with a question about Nicky Diaz. His question was how Whitman could expect employers to crack down on illegal immigrants if she couldn't figure out that there was one in her own house.

"It broke my heart but I had to fire her," Whitman said.

Brown saw an opening to take a swipe at Whitman, saying "I don't want to get into that story. It's a sorry tale here. After nine years, she didn't get her a lawyer. That could have been done."

There was a lot of sparring on pensions, probably a lot of it totally inscrutable if you didn't know what they were talking about already. There was a bit of back-and-forth over Whitman's endorsement from the Los Angeles Police Protective League, and whether that was due to her exemption of police officers from her 401(k) proposal.

Also, it wasn't clear at the end of the night whether Brown is joined at the hip with the public employee unions, or if has the police chiefs in his back pocket. He got the last word, in which he made the case that he knows how to deal with the special interests and get things done.

"I've been in the kitchen," he said. "I've taken the heat. She's been in the bleachers."

So who won?
My Voice Nation Help
56 comments
colorado disability lawyer
colorado disability lawyer

 For certain exceptions you may be able to sue your employer. If your employer acted on purpose to cause your injury then he can of course be sued. If he does not carry worker's comp, depending on the state you may sue him directly or go through a state fund for uninsured injuries. Any injuries caused by a 3rd party's actions or negligence can also be sued. Examples are injuries from defective products or toxic substances.

MOLD TRUTH
MOLD TRUTH

Looks like the Insurance companies could not buy this election!!! The injured workers of Toyota of poway are a great example of what insurance companies have done to the workers compensation system. The game of shifting costs to the tax payor for injured workers is soon to end. The insurance companies have chased out over fifty percent of treating Doctors in the past few years. The ones that remain are beholden to these insurance companies in most cases. To view information on injured workers of Toyota visit www.moldtruth.wordpress.com The profits of these insurance companies have shot up while treatment and payments to injured workers have declined, with many cases draging on for years!!! Go Jerry Brown Go geting the taxpayors money back from these companies would be a great start

MOLD TRUTH
MOLD TRUTH

Looks like the Insurance companies could not buy this election!!! The injured workers of Toyota of poway are a great example of what insurance companies have done to the workers compensation system. The game of shifting costs to the tax payor for injured workers is soon to end. The insurance companies have chased out over fifty percent of treating Doctors in the past few years. The ones that remain are beholden to these insurance companies in most cases. To view information on injured workers of Toyota visit www.moldtruth.wordpress.com The profits of these insurance companies have shot up while treatment and payments to injured workers have declined, with many cases draging on for years!!! Go Jerry Brown Go geting the taxpayors money back from these companies would be a great start

Chris
Chris

Well okay, I see some sexist remarks on this page. There is no doubt that the male will win over the female in this election because most men are very sexist and believe that women should stay in the kitchen and shouldn't vote or lead. Sad world we live in. Give her a chance at least, Brown had his. Give the torch to a new generation.

Fresno_State_2014
Fresno_State_2014

Siva I agree with you completely on Meg Whitman. Our previous governor left our state in devastation and we do not need for it to repeat itself again. Both Meg Whitman and Jerry Brown came to Fresno State for a debate, and Meg did not leave anyone impressed at all. A great majority of the campus students are all in favor of Jerry Brown. I am excited for the results today I hope everything goes well =)

Brown shit
Brown shit

siva thats what the guy said in less words he just didnt want to make it an all day process and he. maybe instead of raising taxes we should just fire many of the people who work for the government or at least pay them less. Why do we want people to want to work for the government. we should pay them less than the average joe for working for the government. they pay people almost double to do things for them. thats whats wrong and stupid. Brown is getting old and you can tell by his debates that his brain is fried. at least on paper, meg wants to pay for the lost taxes by firing government workers and decreasing the strangle hold of the disease that the worst president in history plagued upon us. welfare. im not saying she is the best choice but she is the better choice of the two. in my opinion we should raise tariffs, eliminate minimum wage, destroy welfare, stop subsidizing "farmers", greatly lower taxes for our largest employers, only allow legitimate businesses to enter the stock market, make it virtually impossible to sue the government, punish those who lost a lawsuit they filed,destroy welfare, take the banking industry away from the private owners to give it to the government, and greatly decrease the power of unions to only be able to regulate worker and consumer safety. this is obviously a utopia that we will never see. government to stop fraud and privately owned businesses selling goods how could it get any better than that siva. this is my modest proposal.

siva
siva

Uh Angela,

You and everyone else who keeping tooting that you've lived in LA and therefore know Brown need to be educated before you start chanting someone else's opinion that this baseless.

First, you need to learn what prop 13 was and the effect it has had to this day. It was a roll back of property tax that:

1) made property tax to fund schools unconstitutional. This made schools then rely on state funding. Did you know CA schools used to rank nationally among the best? Now it's almost last. Cuz we have no money. So Brown had to raise taxes

2) disproportionately and unfairly gave commercial realstate owners an advantage over personal homeowners. commercial property owners have more money and prop 13 allowed them to hide behind their shell companies to avoid taxes.

3) increased incentive for homeowners from selling and thereby increased rent across the state

4) Negatively affected coastal cities like LA, San Diego and SF more - where more of the jobs are

5) increased local dependencies to state which meant we had to accept these block grants from state focused on welfare - yeah the same ones that attract illegal immigrants to the state/makes our state more accomodating them and the same one that gives free money to those who dont seek work

Have you noticed your library hours and other public svcs decrease during your childhood? I did, guess why. Prop 13.

6) Increased our sales tax. If the state doesnt have money, where can it get it? From raising sales tax

So why did prop 13 pass? Because of dummies like you who dont understand the residual impact of a law that on the surface sounds good - reducing taxes. Reducing property tax has a significant impact upfront to the homeowners. We were fine without prop 13 with the best schools, record growth and low unemployment because like the rich, greed takes precedence. Homeowners statistically having a higher voting record so they voted in droves.

So if you're a governor and suddenly see loss of funds you depended on in the past from property tax? What do you do if you now have to depend more on state funds and taxes from the rich? You raise taxes.

Now, come back to full circle. Meg wants to reduce another source of income for the state - taxes from the rich. Then where will she recoup? From you and your increased taxes.

bubble
bubble

Jerry Brown won. Meg Whitman was just dodging questions. At least Jerry Brown answered them honestly, eventually. Also, Who wants Big Business to run California? They are just going to make California more favorable for them, like repealing ab32 (environmental law) and the Capital Gains tax, which doesn't really affect a vast majority of Americans. Another thing for those religious people. "Separation of Church and State." We like that phrase in California and it's going to stay like that. We are the state that pulls the country forward (maybe not for religion), and we don't need a governor who is just set on making rich people more rich.

Angela M
Angela M

I lived in CA when Brown was Governor. He was (and is) a lying BSer. For those who don't remember: Prop 13 helped reduce taxes. Jerry Brown was against it.. and went on to raise taxes six out of the eight years he was was Governor. I don't 'get' the vitriole being aimed at Whitman. She sure as hell couldn't do worse. Maybe it's time for a change, an opportunity for CA to regain it's (long lost) dignity.

siva
siva

That's funny Brown shit, telling me I'm full of shit from someone whose name says it all.

Look moron, learn to read. My point is that Meg left Ebay when it was going to the 'shits'. It's easy to ride the wave when everything is hunky-dori. I worked at Ebay, you didn't. I know it far better than you ever will from reading it in the papers. The success of Ebay didnt come from 1 person nor 1 person's leadership. If you knew anything about Ebay, you'd understand what kind of people worked there and how hard they worked to make it into the company it is today. You'd also not give Meg the full credit for it. But you don't so just shut the f*%k up. She was a true bitch at the company. Sure she should get some credit for doing her job but she wont get any high marks for leaving the company when it got tough. The true test would have been for her to stay when it was difficult - like it is in California now.

Brown shit
Brown shit

Whitman joined eBay on March 1998, when it had 30 employees and revenues of approximately $4 million. During her time as CEO, the company grew to approximately 15,000 employees and $8 billion in annual revenue by 2008.THAT SAYS YOUR FULL OF BULLSHIT SIVA. I WANTED TO SEE IF YOUR FACTS WERE RIGHT AND MOST WERE NOT.

siva
siva

Did you know Meg left eBay when it got tough? California is in trouble. Do we really want someone who bails ship when it gets tough? She left email after its stocks took a plunge and after almost being sued for cussing out an employee and shoving her. If you dont believe me, read the article. I bet part of the deal with the employee was that she resign. Anyway, here's an excerpt:

"Ms. Whitman announced she was leaving eBay a few months after the mediation, in January 2008. She had said early in her time at eBay that she anticipated staying at the company for a decade. The company was under a variety of pressures at the time, as its stock sharply declined because of a stagnant auctions business and competitive advances from the likes of Amazon.com and Google."

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06...

siva
siva

Jim Peterman, I also don't really like either one of them but if left to pick the worst of the two, it's clear, it wouldnt be the ugly fat lady with the big wallet and fake smiles and recent botox job (yeah you should have seen her several yrs back). However, what we're aiming for here is someone will not make it worse. We certainly can't let Meg get other rich fat people of the state off the hook. They need to share the burden. We need their tax dollars. We can't also let Meg use the governorship as a personal stepping stone to a better 'career' or a form of self-aggrandizement. She's had 1 track record with 1 company that many think was a success but as I stated before, her record shows also questionable behavior and bailing out when it got tough.

Brown shit
Brown shit

To sivalowering employee benefits and reducing government employment is what California needs. California needs to be run more like a business not a charity. her illegal employee doesn't deserve to be helped because she broke the law. How can you defend her just deport her.

Brown shit
Brown shit

There are too many black people in Louisiana

Jim Peterman
Jim Peterman

Jerry Brown wasn't any good when he was Governor of CA before, so why would he be any good now? He is pro-abortion, (including partial birth, or, late-term abortion) he is PRO-HOMOSEXUAL 'MARRIAGE', (he wants homos to be able to legally 'MARRY') he is anti-religion, he is ANTI-CAPITAL PUNISHMENT, etc. And MEG WHITMAN? Well, she is nothing either, so it's really a LOSE-LOSE situation for CA, no matter which one 'WINS'. CA is a large state, and I find it hard to believe that the only (serious) candidates that was interested on being CA's governor was a doddering old man on the fringe of senility, and a fat woman with more money than brains. GOOD LUCK, CA!

siva
siva

I worked for ebay while meg was ceo. Personally, she's a bitch and unscrupulous.

Yes, she helped build ebay but the business model was already built by the time she joined. Most importantly, it's easy to ride a wave, especially when fueled by the Internet bubble than to keep it going after the bubble. Since the bubble, Ebay has been in decline and Meg not only slashed jobs in response but reduced employee benefits. She saw Ebay declining and has started looking for a new job - Governor of California. Do we really need someone who is:1) Just looking to make another name for herself and be in the history books - afterall, what more would a rich, famous and accomplished person seek next except more money? Legacy2) able to ride the wave during high times (at Ebay) but bail when it got tough and didnt see a rosy future? We need someone who can help california in it's worst of times. 3) Detached and aloof from the public. She lives in Atherton - look that up. Jerry Brown lives in Oakland. 4) willing to spend $120mm plus on her campaign but not thousands on her own maid5) inexperienced in politics - yeah you spend $120+ to have less committment to special interest groups but once you're governor, you still need to know how to deal with them. Has she ever? Dealing with special interest groups is not the same as dealing with the board of Ebay, Ebay HR or it's employees.

Don't be fooled by her apparent personal success. We need someone with political skills and who truly cares about people and who doesnt see people as simply as "resources". Jerry's lived among the people in a city Meg wouldn't set foot on. Sure he's raised taxes but it didnt drive california into the fiasco it is in now. Get with the facts, he raised taxes but they also contributed to the state SURPLUS.

Don't be fooled by Meg's spending her own money on the campaign. No one is free from interest groups. If you're not taking money from them, you're taking their votes. She's spending millions because she can afford it and wants to be governor. The question you need to ask ourselves is WHY? The answer is certainly not because she cares for california and it's people. If it was then she should've been involved in politics before and she never did until she decided to run for governor.

You would think that someone with as much money as her wouldn't think twice about spending more money to hire a legal employee in her own home but the fact is, she not only hired an illegal one but also when she got caught, she was quick to disassociate herself from 'Nicky' and wouldnt even hire legal counsel for her - After 9 yrs of service?

Meg Whitman Cant buy this elec
Meg Whitman Cant buy this elec

Meg Whitman showed her stupidity the best when she tried to dodge nearly every question and go back to past points Brown obviously won and anyone who thinks Meg Whitman is going to do any better than Jerry Brown should go somewhere like Louisiana.

Anonymous
Anonymous

to R. Martinez. Brown didn't even have any plans

Brown shit
Brown shit

Meg made her money she can spend it as she pleases

Robert
Robert

ILLEGAL MEANS IT'S AGAINST THE LAW...DOESN'T IT?

Robert
Robert

If Brown wins, CA is going down. The last time he was gov. he left CA with a defecit. CA already has a defecit! You will not do anything about the defecit until you solve the illegal immigration issue. They are here taking our jobs. For example, think about how many homeless persons we could focus on here in America and give them/train them for the jobs that illegals do. I cant take it anymore when they say we should treat illegals as "people". I cannot treat an illegal as an American. Illegal is illegal for a reason. Meg may not be the best choice, but she has a better idea than Brown. Brown wants a path to citizenship...I think I will hang myself right now. Vote for Meg if you want a real job.

R. Martinez
R. Martinez

I was struck as to how Whitman never gave any solid answers on any of her plans for California. Rather than giving a direct answer Whitman would launch into a TV type commercial mode which was unsettling and weird. Like it or not Brown was more forthcoming... Brown appeared to win the debate on shear honesty.

Frank
Frank

Jerry brown won by a tko! It wasn't close.

Diane Curry
Diane Curry

Only in America would people think that someone who built a billion doallar buiness from the ground up, who is willing to spend their own money ....not taxpayer ..should not be considered electable. In a time where the biggest issue is jobs, wouldn't you want someone who created jobs befor?

phishlee
phishlee

Watching Brown answer questions is like watching an old drunk cross an icy street. HA! Classic! Couldn't have come up with a better metaphor.

Ramon Sombrero
Ramon Sombrero

Meg Whitman has lost her mind. She is now up to 141.5 million bid. Is this the sort of fiscal restraint we can expect from Nut Meg as governor?BOYCOTT ARIZONA ; })-

Meg2010
Meg2010

Meg Whitman won easily.

Brown is so old that he forgot what he did when he was governor. I remember, and I won't let him do it again.

Stevenson
Stevenson

Jerry Brown has strong roots here, and is committed to California. His resume shows many years of public service to this state. When others were riding in limo's and executive jets, Jerry Brown rode in regular cars and flew regular commercial flights. People make fun of him because he is awkward appearing - but really he is simply an old hippy from berkeley who does not like the right wing bull that nixon, reagan, (even I liked reagan) bush put over on us. Specifically getting us into wars and getting us hated by the rest of the world by this "takeover what and who we want policy". In a speech for president in 1991 I personally watched Jerry explain "that we are spending 2 million dollars each for thousands and thousands of smart bombs that can be directed down the chimney of an enemies target" He went on to explain that our country could use a fraction of that money for much needed infrastructure works like, schools, job training, better police, and for the homeless and mentally challenged" He was speaking of the first Iraq war the Bush Dynasty got us into, a war that never needed to happen and was useless, like Viet Nam. It's very easy for the wealthy right wingers who benefit from these wars (they have stock in the companies that provide the weapons etc.. ie. haliburton) to side with the whitman's, and bush's, of the world. They all stand to lose big money if someone starts asking them why all the war, why all the conflicts. Brown seems to truly be into California for the long haul, he's a great lawyer, he's practical, he's decent, he's always had a big heart toward the have nots. Whitman sides with those who have. My friends most of this country and state consist of the have nots (the unlucky ones) Stop making the rich richer they have what they need - let em work for it. Spread the wealth through smart incentive programs to help people learn and get started on making their lives better (it's not politics, it's simply being human showing kindness to others) The world lacks that, let's lead by example.

Chaz
Chaz

All you Libs dont know your ass from your ankle. You guys are probably the people who collect unemployment for years on end and bleed this state dry."Lets send back imagrantsonly when they break the law"...GEE, im pretty sure crossing the boarder w/o a passport is illegal Jerry. If you vote for brown, this state assumes 90 million dollars more in debt because he Barrows all of his money from unuions. Meg owes nothing to anybody. Jerry brown is worse than a terd because at least a terd can float. You liberals keep closing your eyes and hope for the best while the rest of use take action. Keep following Obamaplan and be rewarded for DOING NOTHING.

JohnnyO
JohnnyO

Meg all the Way! The old fart has got to go.Seems a lot of Californians want the illegals. (this is NOT a Mexican issue) to take over there Jobs. Wow are you stupid? Are you not seeing what the illegals are doing now? hospitals jails ...etc. Wait till brown comes. Say good-bye to your job.

Better California
Better California

Whitman Won! There is no doubt about it.

The "back pocket" comment was hilarious...and telling. Brown did not apologize sincerely for the "Whore" comment which women should not let him off so easily. It is much worse than the maid thing and the press is been too easy on Brown. Way to go Tom B.

Brown is too old. California is the "Greece" of the US. People are nuts and deluded to think more of the same of what has brought California to the pit financially is what we need. Come on people! Wake up! Why do we want more of the same stupidity that has made California clown of the country. NO, is a good word!

Way to go Meg! You did awesome!

Anonymous
Anonymous

TO "Meg says:

Brown won, narrowly.

Did we learn anything from the last govenor? It takes more than a big ego and lots of money made in unrelated private industry to run a state."

I'm sorry, but there is a big difference between a movie star and a CEO of a Fortune 100 company. She knows how to run a business, and thats what California needs. The Governor is the CEO of California.

John Riedbalski
John Riedbalski

We MUST not let NUT MEG BUY and LIE her way into office. She's a liar. After six years of a a GOP Governor the state of California is in a hell of a mess and we need someone who knows what HE is doing to get it done RIGHT! Ahnold was a waste of our taxpayers money - money to hold a special election to elect a movie star, money to hold a special election to pass HIS four initiatives that all FAILED! WASTE, WASTE, WASTE. Before this is over Ms Whitman will have spent $140 Million of HER OWN MONEY to buy this election. She hires someone who barely speaks English - if she is SO RICH why not pay for someone who can at least speak English. Makes the woman work 30 hour weeks but only pays her for 15 hours a week. You can only do to that to a person who you know is here illegally - so, you can say, accept this or I report you. There are plenty worse names for women like Meg Whitman, and being called a whore is the tamest one in the book. She called the housekeeper FAMILY - and you may not like Gloria Allred, but you know she won't take a case on unless she has a winner! GO JERRY GO! If Meg is elected Governor I guarantee you the state of California will be LAST in EDUCATION and LAST in Jobs - Meg will destroy our state while making sure her and her foreign friends get our taxpayer money. She couldn't even get her hometown newspaper to endorse her!

Meg
Meg

Brown won, narrowly.

Did we learn anything from the last govenor? It takes more than a big ego and lots of money made in unrelated private industry to run a state.

Linda
Linda

Meg Whitman won. Jerry Brown kept trying to minimize his "whore remark" by stating it was a private conversation in which he was involved...and he made a major error by saying he had police chiefs "in his back..." then suddenly stopped realizing what he said. He tried to correct it by saying he had police chiefs backing him...but it was obvious he was intending to state he had police chiefs in his "back pocket." There was a lot of laughter over that...

Again, Brown came up with NO positive solutions to problems in the state nor did he state what he would do beside use his "charisma" to get people to do what he desired, LOL!

Whitman won, hands down!!!

Californian Losers
Californian Losers

I hope all you out of work uneducated losers vote for Jerry Brown to keep you in the crapper. You guys don't deserve anything better. You guys are too stupid.

vh
vh

Jerry Brown is not yet extinct?Stupid voters of CA will elect this Dinosaur as a governer. They deserve 25% unemployment that Jerry will bring them!!LOL

Patrick
Patrick

And to Ignorance is Bliss: I am a taxpayer, I was born and raised in California, and I remember quite well that Governor Jerry Brown was so frugal with tax dollars that he built up a $5 billion surplus. (Do you remember Johnny Carson joking about how "cheap" the governor was? I do.) Jerry Brown's budget surplus is what spurred Prop. 13. Ronald Reagan didn't achieve a surplus when he was governor (and in fact ran up a historic deficit as president), nor did Deukmejian, WIlson, or Schwarzenegger. Republicans talk a lot about fiscal responsibility but can never seem to deliver on their promises.

Brown shit
Brown shit

the whore thing was stupid to bring up their both whores and who cares. Lets not waste the whole middle half of he debate on it. Bron doesnt really say much when he talks as whitman pointed out when he was talking about the his cuts on the governor's budget which makes up a small fraction of the states budget. A fraction of a percent. Atleast she talks about things that really matter. Fuck welfare and the nigers, dirty mexicans and white trash who accept it. I also like the tax cuts for businesses because who cares what they do with the extra money. At least they will stay in California and give us jobs. This is a capitalist nation. At least it used to be before idiots got a say in the government. Unions

Afro Baby
Afro Baby

Meg Whitman is a Hobbit with money!

vkmo
vkmo

In addition to the illegal immigrant housekeeper's 9 yrs of employment with Whitman, Brokaw asked another question to make Whitman uncomfortable -- if Whitman was so eager to improve California politics by winning this election, why didn't she ever cast her own vote in previous California elections. Whitman looked stunned, and apologised- but I think it's too little & too late

Patrick
Patrick

Aside from refusing to answer questions and instead dodging to her talking points repeatedly, Whitman still declines to specify which 40,000 employees she'll lay off, where she'll find all these billions in waste and fraud she talks about (which Schwarzenegger also campaigned on but found to be bull when he got into office) or how she's going to forge working relationships with 120 legislators she says she owes nothing to.

Bob
Bob

Brown won easily. Whitman was flummoxed after the crowd booed her ridiculous assertion that it was a huge insult when Brown's aide used the word "whore," but it was "a totally different thing" when her own campaign manager used the word "whore."

Ignorance is Bliss
Ignorance is Bliss

Can we get a few more comments from the people who pay taxes! We ran Brown out of office in the 70's. If it is Brown, flush it down!

Rusty
Rusty

Dis here is some crazy ish mang. Jerry Brown be a degenerate chameleon.

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...