L.A. City Councilmembers Eric Garcetti And Jose Huizar Take Firm Stance On Potholes; 10,000 To Be Filled By Sunday

Categories: City News

josehuizarericgarcetti.jpg
seiu721 via Flickr
King o' Potholes and L.A. City Council President Eric Garcetti (black suit left) backs up City Hall buddy Jose Huizar (black suit right) at a public plea for more road-primping funds
Updated after the jump: Final pothole fill-count exceeds Garcetti and Huizar's wildest dreams! Originally posted Jan. 7.

With three two short months left before ballot time, L.A. City Councilmembers Jose Huizar and Eric Garcetti are latching onto an issue we can all get excited about: these goddamn potholes.

Come on, what could be worse than potholes? They make the morning commute into a wooden rollercoaster ride, never not spilling scalding coffee all over our laps and no doubt killing our shocks for life.

Huizar and Garcetti, as usual, understand our pain. So they're demanding that City Administrative Officer Miguel Santana pour more money into the Bureau of Street Services in this dark, rutty time -- because "we owe it to the people of Los Angeles to fill potholes, resurface streets and remove fallen trees year-round," in the words of Huizar.

Here's the spiffy Web page that the Street Services worker union has devoted to the cause. It reads:

"Budget cuts and furloughs in the Street Services Bureau have led to increased emergency response times and a reduction of basic services. On Jan. 5, City Administrative Officer Miguel Santana announced additional furloughs that could mean hundreds of miles of roads go unpaved."

In attendance at this morning's "Keep L.A. Strong" announcement, backing up Huizar and the city workers, was Council President Garcetti -- surely resting a little easier than his associate, as his odd-numbered district seat is safe until the next election.

He has, however, stood equally firm on eradicating the wasteland of pesky road pimples that now lie before us. At the end of December -- another sign he's following Antonio Villaraigosa all the way to the throne -- Garcetti inherited the mayor's schtick as King of the Potholes, posing for photo ops in his neon working-man's vest and serving as official spokesman for "Operation Pothole." He told the LA Daily News this morning about its dashing success so far:

"We've had a great response," Garcetti said. "We went to the neighborhood councils and got lists [of potholes] from them. I've been hearing on Facebook and Twitter. I think we'll be able to do the 10,000."

Garcetti spent nearly six hours with a pothole crew to get a first-hand insight into the project.

"What's amazing is how fast these guys are able to work," Garcetti said.

Garcetti boasted today that the first major leg of the Operation will go down this weekend: 50 crews will save the city's streets from their post-rainpocalypse state of disaster by Sunday, filling up to 15,000 holes.

But don't be fooled by the numbers. Los Angeles is the second biggest city in America, and we'd be willing to bet that a good 80 percent of our surface area is straight-up street. L.A. consistently scores in the Top 2 for worst roads in America, with 63 percent of roadways in "poor condition," according to the Washington, D.C. non-profit TRIP.

Bill Robertson, director of the Bureau of Street Services, says that after the first big rain last year, Operation Pothole lasted for two weekends, instead of just the one weekend it will run this year.

"In 2010, we did over 350,000 potholes," he says. "This year, it will be about 250,000." He attributes the shrinkage to loss in personnel through the Early Retirement Incentive Program and furloughs, adding: "We've lost 351 authorized positions."

At the press conference this morning, Huizar came out in protest of those cuts. The motion, in his own words:

"... asks the CAO to study exempting Bureau of Street Service workers who are specially funded from furloughs, meaning those whose salaries are paid using outside sources and not from our General Fund. I'm also asking the CAO to identify additional special funds in order to expand cleaning up our streets and roadways and allow City workers to do the job we hired them to do."

Ironically, Huizar is in the middle of a politi-blog shitstorm set off by his unwillingness to disclose the spending history of a fund he oversees called CLARTS. It's a $1 million-per-year piggy bank designated to offset the downsides of the giant, foul-smelling Central Los Angeles Recycling & Transfer Station dump located in his district.

Citywatchers are accusing him of pumping hundreds of thousands of those dollars into projects that don't directly benefit the community. Many line items on the CLARTS report, which everyone finally located, say "Transfer to Council" or "Transfer to General City Purposes."

None of the charges are blatantly dishonorable, but a few really can't be argued into the category of physical neighborhood improvement to offset the garbage dump (Casa0101? Really?), and almost all transfers to the city's general fund can't be tracked much further than intent to go toward District 14 community amenities in the City Clerk records.

All the technical allocations are there in city paperwork, but the final hands into which the millions have fallen over the last couple years is completely unclear. The whole thing is vastly worsened by Huizar's inability to handle the criticism and his shady evasions of local press.

potholeimages.jpeg
Anyway, it's ironic that Huizar is begging the City Administrative Office for pothole and street-repair money when, by our calculations, the CLARTS fund appears to have tons of money left over. Huizar's put the cash toward Street Services, Public Works and CalTrans before, so why not now? And if it's not supposed to go toward road work in the first place, he's got a heap more explaining to do.

According to Tracie Morales, union spokeswoman for the Street Services workers, Huizar's motion today will "direct the Administrative Office to how we can allocate special funding in order to be able to provide crucial street services."

Robertson, head of Street Services, says there are plenty of funds -- just not enough employees on city contract to utilize them. However, he rules out the hiring of outside workers as an option.

"How do you do a contract with potholes?" he says. "It's something you just can't do. It needs to be managed in-house because it fluctuates so much."

L.A. City Administrative Officer Miguel Santana -- the guy Huizar hopes will bolster the Street Services worker pool -- is unavailable to talk at the moment, but we'll keep you updated as per his response.

Meanwhile, Operation Pothole is still in full swing. To be honest, complaining about L.A.'s pothole wasteland and getting air on the really juicy ones have always been some of our favorite ways to pass the winter months. However, Garcetti's user-friendly Operation leaves us little choice but to shut our whiny traps and report the devils to 311.

"What's really disturbing is people will hit a pothole for weeks and not call it in," says Robertson. "Just pick up the phone."

Update: Those potholes couldn't have known what was comin' to them. Councilman Jose Huizar made the big announcement this morning: Street Services filled 16,100 potholes last weekend.

Of course, even a snazzy number like that isn't enough for these perfectionists. Huizar uses to opportunity to tell ABC7,

"We used to fill potholes within 48 hours. Now, we do it probably within two to three weeks," said Huizar. "Why is that? Because we put some of our street workers on furloughs. They take less days off and less potholes are getting filled."

In the article, he cites a $630 million pot of federal stimulus money that the L.A. City Council "received to create jobs" as a possible source for paying more Street Services personnel. And how 'bout that CLARTS fund, eh?

My Voice Nation Help
15 comments
Mariscal
Mariscal

The federal money Huizar is talking about was received about March of 2010. We're in January of 2011 and they still have over 70% of that money laying around! That money was intended for infrastructure and was intended to be used quickly. Pothole is the word of the day, but the real problem is the deterioration of the City because of plain old mismanagement. It's not about pensions, or unions. It's about negligence and incompetence....for the last 3 years. Over $400 million dollars in uncollected back-taxes from parking lot contractors....and now the City Council wants to sell more lots? That's all we need is another debt in back-taxes that the City can't or won't collect. Brilliant!!We're voting for the same people that got us into this, right?

Robert
Robert

THANK YOU THANK YOU LA WEEKLY. A newspaper that gets it and has the back of the people. Many friends on the Eastside have been questioning this for years without any response from Huizar. We hope you keep on top of this issue of the CLARTS FUND abuse which is tax payer dollars. I hope your readership is going wayyyyy up cause I know I blast out this story all; over the city.

BHN
BHN

The Eastside will probably have to move either to the State or Federal level to get his response. The Mayor is keeping silent, I wonder why he is not on the news defending Huizar?What is the penalty for misleading the City Council on faulse information? and why it is the people are not sworn to state the facts and the truth in City Council not only the speakers on public comment but everyone else. Other government Offices continue the process of swearing people in before they present at the hearings. .

Yuval Kremer
Yuval Kremer

The Council President chooses/controls who serves on the committees, including the City's PLUM, or Land Use Committee. It always bothered me that the PLUM committee only had three members...it could have more (there are 15 council members...important committees usually have at least 5 members). I don't remember Huizar ever being present when I attended or listened in...it was always Weiss and Reyes, w/ Huizar absent...it was a joke for Residents fighting Overdevelopment...two pro-developer councilmen having a conversation. I always considered the PLUM committee small, pro-developer, without a slow/responsible growth voice or any dissent BECAUSE ERIC WANTED IT THAT WAY. If you hate PLUM, know that Eric bears a LOT of the blame...he's been Council President for many years now.

BHN
BHN

Why does Huizar recuse him self when a PLUM Hearing involves business that have recently contributed to his fund and the mayors. We presented it to have Huizar taken out of the decision, but he was not, and it was only Huizar and Reyes, they refused to let us speak, and than it went to Council as an approved motion because it had already been heard at PLUM, Garcetti would not allow us to present our side against the business, and we had completed the and handed them early. .Huizar only moves wtih money, in Boyle Heights the majority are poor, so he knows he can only support the few businesses that do contribute.

BHNative
BHNative

Why is Huizar so worry about potholes, when we need to restore emergency services in cd14? Oh! maybe this is the way to get the City workers union to back him up for Councilmen. I get now? Now I know how important potholes are for Huizar, one vote for each pothole pay back. I guess the LAFD already gave him a decision, so he does have to restore emergency services, savings people's lives does not get him votes, but potholes do.

Bluecat
Bluecat

The only pothols that Huizar should be looking into is the missing 1.3M from CLART FUND, or is he partnering with Garcetti to help him out with money from CD 14 CLARTS FUND. Is garcetti and Huizar taken over the job that was not completed by the Mayor? It does not look good on the Mayor.The other potholes that need attention is the LAFD brown outs, the money should be utilize first for the emergency services that has been cut in CD-14..Street potholes will always be there, and will come back because of the method they use to repair the streets potholds, that come back within a few months, The last potholes that Huizar need to take care off is the Lorena and 4th Street Bridge needs finishing, he started 2008 now 2011 and is not completed, is a very small historical bridge right infront of his mothers house, doesn't she get fed up looking at an unfinish work everyday in front of her house. Repair the sidewalk on the bridge that was cover with black tar only. It need to be cement. I guess it is easy to start new projects or take over projects from the mayor and .than to finish what you have not done for the last five years.

robert in eagle rock
robert in eagle rock

The PLUM committee guys who sat on their asses and failed to work on Med. Marijuana Dispensary applications and "exemptions" were chair Reyes, and members Jose Huizar and Jack Weiss. Eric sat on his ass all by himself.

The CLARTS fund was also highlighted in Mayor Sam's blog and The Voice among others for nearly a year, too.

You can't beat an election year to wake up the incumbents to get high-visibility service done, regardless of the fact that taxpayers' money is the source of such campaign-serving support.

Robert
Robert

OMG these guys are the biggest clowns. It was Garcetti and Huizar and Reyes who sat on their asses for 4 years in PLUM committee meetings doing nothing and the explosion of marijuana shops hit our cities. Many of thank the LA Weekly for being at the forefront reporting the facts on Huizar's CLARTS FUND scandal and other stories. You are becoming our main source of info

Yuval Kremer
Yuval Kremer

Simone: great coverage, but the Election is March 8, exactly 2 months away. Vote-by-mail starts on February 7, less than 1 month away. City Council President Eric GarSHADY will be termed-out in 2 years b/c it's his 3rd term, made possible by the scam Measure R from 2006, sold to the public as ethics reform (LOL) by Eric himself, which changed the 2-term limit to 3 terms (ask Jill Stewart @ all the other bad stuff Measure R did...she wrote @ it at the time). But he's campaigning, just like Jan Perry and Wendy Cruel, for his next political run...at Mayor (in 2 years) or another high office (the bigger the office, the earlier you need to start campaigning, and career politicians always start campaigning early). He also has a long resume of negatives that he needs the public to forget about by getting photo-ops of himself filling potholes.

PS: I hope LA Weekly covers all the Challengers running in the City Council races for the Even-Numbered Districts, and w/ less than a month before people can start voting by mail, hopefully very soon. The challengers have no money for mailers, the Daily News' Orlov is a suckup to the incumbents, and the LA Times seems to only have Zahniser on the City Beat, w/ editorial favoring the incumbents...LA Weekly would do a great public service by covering these races, plus I think people want help researching their choices, and they would read the coverage.

BTW, here's a link for the "City of Los Angeles Claims for Damages Form"...b/c Eric didn't properly lead the council re: basic services like filling potholes, it will end-up costing the taxpayers even more...and it seems to me that he has publicly admitted that it's the City's fault. In Japan, a man in his position would resign in shame.

http://cityclerk.lacity.org/cp...

Simone Wilson
Simone Wilson

Yuval: Your request is our demand. =) Thanks for the involvement & support

anon
anon

Business of fixing potholes should be privatized. We don't care if city employees are on 10 or 50 days furloughs. Enough of this nonsense. No more grandstanding about something so basic as a pothole.

Bluecat
Bluecat

Thank you anon, but you know that Huizar needs to accomplish something to ask voters to vote for him, and a push for cover potholes is an easy way out, and the News loves taking pictures with politicals wearing yellow/orange vest roll playing as a City Worker. This new site of Garcetti just made me loose respect for him. I guess I gave him more credit

Joseph
Joseph

This just doesn't do wear and tear to cars. I hit a pothole Xmas night, had a flat, couldn't get a tow company to respond, and had to fiddle with the tire myself in the rain. I caught something between bronchitis and pneumonia and was out for ten days. You can bet I'm going to try to bill the city for the tire--which had just been checked and was in perfect condition (It's not often you get compliments on your tires, but I did), and I shudder to think of anyone but an experienced city worker filling these things. Not only that, but when you interview oppositional candidates for City Council, and ask them if anyone's actually doing a good job in the City, they almost always say, "Bill Robertson." When it rains hard in Franklin Hills, everything shifts around quite a bit, and we've lost five trees in the neighborhood too, not to mention the whole approach to the Shakespeare Bridge, which is like a lunar crater now This expenditure is an urgent matter--it's still winter, and when you get a flat in the rain on a non-responsive night, it's a mess.

Jacob Chung
Jacob Chung

Hey Joseph,

I'm working on a story about potholes in Los Angeles becoming an expensive issue. Do you have time to chat? If so, let me know at jacobyschung[at]gmail[dot]com.

Jacob

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

General

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city