Top

blog

Stories

 

'Stop SB 48' Doesn't Want California Students to Know About Cole Porter?


cole_porter.jpg
Cole Porter
​​​​In the history of the world, gays and lesbians have always made important contributions to many different societies. One such person is Cole Porter, the brilliant composer and songwriter.

"Few people realize how architecturally excellent his music is," said Richard Rodgers, another major composer, about Porter. "There's a foundation, a structure, and an embellishment. Then you add the emotion he's put in and the result is Cole Porter."

In California, a group called "Stop SB 48" wants to repeal a state law that allows students to learn about Porter and other important people in history who were gay.

Porter, who was born in Indiana in 1891, wrote songs for stage and screen, including the highly-acclaimed musical comedy Anything Goes, which won the 2011 Tony Award for Best Musical Revival and features classics "I Get a Kick Out of You," "You're the Top," and "All Through the Night."

Other songs of his include "I've Got You Under My Skin," "In the Still of the Night," "Friendship," "Don't Fence Me In," and many others.

Porter, admirers often say, transformed American songwriting with his clever lyrics and sophisticated, but accessible melodies.

"With his late-19th-century harmonies and letter-perfect rhymes, which were even more refined than those of Gilbert and Sullivan operettas, Porter was a rigid pop traditionalist," the New York Times music critic Stephen Holden once wrote. "But he was also an unblinking realist about life, love, pleasure and the transience of it all. For his time, he was even a touch subversive."

Porter's songs have been covered by artists ranging from Ella Fitzgerald to Frank Sinatra to Elvis Costello, and have consoled, inspired, or cheered up millions of people throughout the world. He died in Santa Monica, California, in 1964.

In July, Governor Jerry Brown signed SB 48, also known as the Fair, Accurate, Inclusive, and Respectful (FAIR) Education Act, into law.

It revised an existing law that adds the LGBT community to a list of under-represented cultural and ethnic groups that are covered in textbooks and other instructional materials in schools.

Stop SB 48 wants to repeal FAIR through a ballot measure, and the group has now started a petition drive to get the initiative on the June, 2012, ballot.

In seeking the repeal of FAIR, Stop SB 48 is creating the same kind of coalition of religious groups and conservative think tanks that worked to get California voters to approve anti-gay marriage Proposition 8 in 2008.

Courage Campaign, Equality California, and other gay rights and social justice groups are undertaking a "decline to sign" effort to keep California voters from signing Stop SB 48's petition.

"They want kids to grow up thinking gay people have never contributed to society at all," Courage Campaign founder Rick Jacobs wrote in an email to his members.

Every Wednesday, L.A. Weekly is highlighting those important gays and lesbians in history -- the same people Stop SB 48 doesn't want California students to know about.

Reilly T. Bates contributed to this post.

Contact Patrick Range McDonald at pmcdonald@laweekly.com.

My Voice Nation Help
18 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Handtotheplow
Handtotheplow

And we all know who Cole Porter was despite his sexuality.  So tell me what difference it makes to know he was gay?  None.  Zero.  Zilch.  So sign "stop SB 48" becasue it is sexist; basically saying that a persons sexuality should go down in history.  

Thomasquay
Thomasquay

By mentioning that a celebrity was gay or is gay, it makes anyone think that sexuality has a part of their talent and success.  If I was devoted to pedophilia besides my amazing and successful  talent in music, I don't it necessary to bring up into the open what I do in the privacy of my home.   Unless you gay people think that your inteligence comes from your deviant lifestyle.   Instead, it should blur your thinking.Flag

ReFlex76
ReFlex76

It's moments like this that I'm proud to be a Californian, and proud to have Jerry Brown as my Governor.  Here's to common sense prevailing.

mitch young
mitch young

But Cole Porter was 'closeted', in fact, he went so far as to marry his 'beard'. Will it be taught that he thought his sexual 'identity' wasn't something to be particularly proud of?

Fact is that the pushers of SB48 are going to have to look long and hard to find any historical figures before, say, 1970 that were 'gay' in the modern sense of an 'out and proud' homosexual. In fact, homosexuality as a reified identity is a concept that didn't exist before the late 19th century and other than Oscar Wilde, I can't thing of anyone who actively 'owned' that identity.

ReFlex76
ReFlex76

"But Cole Porter was 'closeted', in fact, he went so far as to marry his 'beard'. Will it be taught that he thought his sexual 'identity' wasn't something to be particularly proud of?"

Yes, it should be taught that societal pressure force many an LGBT person to hide their true personalities is ridiculous ways. 

"Fact is that the pushers of SB48 are going to have to look long and hard to find any historical figures before, say, 1970 that were 'gay' in the modern sense of an 'out and proud' homosexual. In fact, homosexuality as a reified identity is a concept that didn't exist before the late 19th century and other than Oscar Wilde, I can't thing of anyone who actively 'owned' that identit"

Off the top of my head:

GoetheFredrich Wilhelm Von SteubenFedrerick the GreatAlexander the GreatPlatoJulius CeasarLeonardo Da Vinci

Imagine the list I could get if I put more effort into this (little forum disputes just aren't worth it)

I do love my History degree!

mitch young
mitch young

Who are you to say what someone's 'true' identity is? 

As for your list, I know for a fact that some of those are just plain false, and others are deeply ambiguous. Plato, well he invented the concept of 'Platonic love' didn't he. At any rate it is impossible to force modern conceptions of 'gay' and 'homosexual' on the Hellenistic world. Old men, younger boy sexual pairings were approved of, but men were also expected to marry, establish a home, and produce children. They weren't 'gay' in the modern sense. Julius Ceasar was *slandered* as being in male-male relationship(s) -- the Romans could not abide by such things -- and he denied all such rumours (hence, he didn't own it). Von Steuben kept his bedroom activities private (oh for the days where homosexuals were just 'stay out of our bedrooms!). Leonardo wrote love poetry to men and women. Alexander the Great married Roxanne and two other women, and produced an heir with Roxanne.

I have no doubt when this law in pushed into our classrooms, lies, distortions and inaccuracies like your list will be shoved into the minds of our children.

ReFlex76
ReFlex76

"Who are you to say what someone's 'true' identity is? "

No one, it's up to the person involved.

ReFlex76
ReFlex76

" Alexander the Great married Roxanne and two other women, and produced an heir with Roxanne."

Hephaestion might have a thing or two to say about that.

ReFlex76
ReFlex76

 ". Von Steuben kept his bedroom activities private (oh for the days where homosexuals were just 'stay out of our bedrooms!)."

Tank you for accidentally revealing the homophobic ultimate goal: wiping gay existence off the map.  Whether by "putting them back in the closet," or worse, it's all about making it like they don't exist.  Gays in the closet, blacks in the back of the bus, women in the kitchen . . . the "good old days."

"I have no doubt when this law in pushed into our classrooms, lies, distortions and inaccuracies like your list will be shoved into the minds of our children"

Nothing "shoved," just kids finally getting the truth.  Yes, so long as there are people, there were and always will be gay people.

Ablaize14
Ablaize14

I think what sb 48 is all about is not making homosexuality so readily available for our young kids to learn about... If someone in history did something incredible let the kids learn about it but is it really nesecary for them to know they were GAY... But I will say this I would not like to see in the future history books with a chapter called "The Homosexuals of the Past and to Come." I am strongly against homosexuality in my house and my family knows this... I do understand and so do they that they are people and should not be made fun of and such... But what I dislike is there decision to live there life... I do not dislike them as a person... Bit anyways I will be signing this document stop SB 48 and I encourage anyone out there with kids or some young ones you care for to do the same... Once again I'm not against homosexuals and whatever they have accomplished... I just don't think its necessary to emphasize that they are GAY...

David
David

How sad.  "But what I dislike is there (sic) decision to live there (sic) life."There it is.Thank you LA Weekly for this series.

Richie
Richie

Stop SB 48 perhaps has not given much thought to Cole Porter.  What the referendum does not want, however, is that teachers are forced by law to indoctrinate of children with regard to controversial moral issues.

ReFlex76
ReFlex76

"Stop SB 48 perhaps has not given much thought to Cole Porter.  What the referendum does not want, however, is that teachers are forced by law to indoctrinate of children with regard to controversial moral issues. "

No "indoctrination," just facts.  A simple 'oh, and Cole Porter was gay" will do.

Onapodium
Onapodium

I teach music, and Cole Porter is one of many influential artists and composers we talk about in Music History and Fine Arts classes. (4th-8th grades)  I don't however say oh, and by the way, the reason we are talking about him is to showcase him as a Prominent homosexual.  He was prominent not because he was homosexual, but because he was talented, hard working, and lucky enough to be able to be successful with those talents, and his music is a part of our rich and diverse cultural heritage today.  The fact that he was homosexual may or may not come up in the course of studying about him, but it if does, I deal with it truthfully and respectfully.  I do not make it the focus of why he is important. The idea that the supporters of Stop48 want to hide anyone who was gay is ludicrous, and designed purely and simply to play on emotions.  Stop48 proponents do not want to erase mention of historical figures who were gay, they simply do not want to make their sexual proclivities the focus of their importance to history, or to promote individuals simply by reason of their sexuality.  I will never allow rudeness, bullying, or defamation of anyone in my classrooms, whether it be due to race, religion, gender, or sexuality, and I do my best to be supportive to all students and their needs, but I will not promote one particular party's agenda, or indoctrination policies either.  I believe SB48 is a dangerous precedent for such activity, and will not only be signing the Stop48 petition, but will be encouraging everyone I know to do the same.  

ReFlex76
ReFlex76

"I teach music, and Cole Porter is one of many influential artists and composers we talk about in Music History and Fine Arts classes. (4th-8th grades)  I don't however say oh, and by the way, the reason we are talking about him is to showcase him as a Prominent homosexual."

It doesn't change the fact that he was.  A simple "he was gay" is all that's needed.

 "He was prominent not because he was homosexual, but because he was talented, hard working, and lucky enough to be able to be successful with those talents, and his music is a part of our rich and diverse cultural heritage today.  The fact that he was homosexual may or may not come up in the course of studying about him, but it if does, I deal with it truthfully and respectfully."

That's all SB48 asks.  A simple "he was gay."  I would have no problem saying this.

 " I do not make it the focus of why he is important. The idea that the supporters of Stop48 want to hide anyone who was gay is ludicrous, and designed purely and simply to play on emotions.  Stop48 proponents do not want to erase mention of historical figures who were gay, they simply do not want to make their sexual proclivities the focus of their importance to history, or to promote individuals simply by reason of their sexuality."

Then you should have no problem with "oh, and Cole Porter happened to be gay."

 " I will never allow rudeness, bullying, or defamation of anyone in my classrooms, whether it be due to race, religion, gender, or sexuality, and I do my best to be supportive to all students and their needs, but I will not promote one particular party's agenda, or indoctrination policies either.  I believe SB48 is a dangerous precedent for such activity, and will not only be signing the Stop48 petition, but will be encouraging everyone I know to do the same. "

Well, i will not only not be signing any Stop48 petition, I will be voting against any referendum that somehow makes it through.  Stop48 is another backwards abomination that should itself be stopped.

mitch young
mitch young

""oh, and Cole Porter happened to be gay."

But he married -- a woman. 

Sign supplies
Sign supplies

I found this informative and interesting blog, so I think so it’s very useful and knowledgeable. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me. I really thought that blog is spreading its wings rapidly... 

Sign supplies

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

General

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city