Giovanni Ramirez's Situation 'Deeply Regrettable' For LAPD Chief Beck, He Says

By Dennis Romero Mon., Aug. 1 2011 at 7:06 AM

Beck and Mayor Villaraigosa.

LAPD Chief Charlie Beck over the weekend said Giovanni Ramirez's erroneous exposure as the main suspect in the opening day beating of San Francisco Giants fan at Dodger Stadium was "deeply regrettable."

But more than anything, Beck, in a Los Angeles Times opinion piece, seemed to blame Ramirez's predicament on the media's incessant desire for information.

Yes, chief, it's our fault that you stood before a bunch of cameras in spring and fingered the wrong guy.

El Jefe writes:

Regrettably, Giovanni Ramirez was caught between the state's right to investigate and arrest and the public's right to know what the police are doing. We support our arrest because we met our burden of proof and the media support their pursuit of the story.

Victim Bryan Stow was put in a coma by his assailants.

Eh, back up there, Chief. While we were all salivating for an arrest -- the media, you, the mayor, and Dodgers' fans alike -- it was you and the mayor who jumped all over Ramirez despite some things that didn't totally add up (his alibi, his reported lie detector tests, the fact that he didn't entirely fit the description ...).

But he was a bad guy, a gang member with a record, and he would have to do.

On May 26 Beck told the world that Ramirez "is, and was, and has been, our primary suspect," and that he was personally "as sure as you need to be" that officers got the right guy.

If anything it was the media's questions, prompted by leaks from those sympathetic to Ramirez's case, that apparently caused you to do a double take and have different detectives take a look-see, a move that ultimately lead to Ramirez exoneration.

Before that, it felt like there was an LAPD/City Hall campaign against Ramirez. (And since the chief isn't elected, we kind of wonder who was running this media show).

In his Times editorial Beck didn't address those May comments or the apparent push against Ramirez.

Fingering the nearest con with a record is as old as any stereotypical, crooked-cop movie, but here we all viewed in live in L.A. Headlines, ready to be ripped.

They don't much more guilty looking than this: Giovanni Ramirez.

So, uh, yeah, the blame lies partly with us, because we wrote stuff down. Beck:

Regrettably, Giovanni Ramirez was caught between the state's right to investigate and arrest and the public's right to know what the police are doing. We support our arrest because we met our burden of proof and the media support their pursuit of the story.
That is the state of the game, but we can do much better. We need to not merely abide by the rules but to recognize their shortfalls. I can be more circumspect in my comments, and the media should be more restrained and cautious.

The chief did admit, however, because Ramirez's "name and picture were released to the general public" ... "this caused the appearance of a rush to judgment."

Just an appearance.

[@dennisjromero/djromero@laweekly.com]

Tags:

Bryan Stow, Charlie Beck, Dodgers, Giovanni Ramirez, LAPD, media

We Recommend

Manny Miles

And not only did Giovanni Ramirez not entirely fit the description of the suspects, but more than anything, he did not match the profile of a person who would ever attend an Opening Day game, let alone any sports event. I am now convinced over this incident/case that chief Beck, and LAPD detectives, aren't so bright. Nothing ever did add up in my opinion, and I am not defending the culprits for beating Stow, but to me, right from the get go, I never believed it was an unprovoked attack, or that 'gang bangers' were involved. It was thuggish Dodger fans 'razzing' a supporter of the game's losing team, and rival, the San Francisco Giants. You'll see at any MLB game, especially rival games and season openers, that home fans will tease visiting fans, and it is stupid to shout or argue back when the sportsman thing to do is take the razzing like a good sport when your team loses. We all now know, based on video of Stow's behavior and taunting of Dodger fans during the game that he doesn't fit the profile of a shy, non-outspspoken guy. It's sad that the fight he likely brought upon himself was so severe it put him in critical, damaging condition, but let's only hope that something valuable is learned from this, and that fighst, attacks, taunting, drunken behavior, and poor sportsmanship, is dealt with better at these events. As for chief Beck, he's a sorry sap for blaming the media, when it was he that decided this case was a gang banger style beating, unprovoked, and then presented only a certain amount of details to the case, giving the world the impression a mob assaulted a man all by himself, when it was more less drunken Dodger and Giants fans exchanging words, and one group losing its cool, and 'jumping' a guy left behind by his 3 other pals. I know a lot of people reading my comment think otherwise, but this is only my opinion based on 35+ years of attending ballgames at the Ravine. I'm sure the gun found in Giovanni's living quarters was planted cos that's the sort of thing cops do when they think they have the 'right' guy.

Nando

Reality set in that if a lawsuit is in store, there goes more money (that the city doesn't already have) toward a potential settlement because of another LAPD debacle. That "apology" didn't sound very sincere from Beck, but no surprise there. Way to go, boys in blue.