Top

blog

Stories

 

Women Drivers Are Worse Than Men, According to Study

Categories: Women

Thumbnail image for sexy driver sean dreilinger.JPG
Sean Dreilinger
In the battle of the sexes, nothing gets women riled up like the words, "You can't drive! (And neither can your mother)."

The proper response to that jab, of course, is, "Well you drive too fast. (And your father's a jerk)."

So, in the war between a deliberate female driver and a testosterone-fueled road warrior in this car capital of L.A., which one is, in fact, the safer motorist? Don't blame the messenger, but ...

... lady drivers suck! Ahh. We knew it. In this case is the messenger is a University of Michigan study that's been sitting on the shelf this summer but which is getting a lot of play this week for some reason.

According to Michael Sivak and Brandon Schoettle of the University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute men and women actually get into pretty much the same number of accidents in six crash scenarios they looked at.

But: Men drive more -- about 60 percent of the time versus women's 40 percent.

So women, in turn, have more of these crashes compared to the time they spend behind the wheel.

U of M:

But the researchers found that crashes involving two female drivers were overrepresented in five of the six crash scenarios, including two by at least 50 percent more and two others by more than 25 percent greater than what was expected.

On the other hand, crashes involving two male drivers were underrepresented in four of the six scenarios ...

So what is it with girls and cars? Well, that's a question for another study, maybe. Sivak:

This pattern of results could be due to either differential gender exposure to the different scenarios, differential gender capabilities to handle specific scenarios or differential expectations of actions by other drivers based on their gender.

So next time you crane your neck to see who that idiot is making that annoying move, now you know what to look for. Not just Mexicans/Koreans/Jews/old people/debutantes/whipper-snappers/yuppies. But female ones.

Comment away.

[@dennisjromero/djromero@laweekly.com]

My Voice Nation Help
26 comments
Fempower
Fempower

I totally agree, I would say just based on a cars body language (something i dont even think most women are perceptive to) i can immediately tell if a woman is behind the wheel before i see the driver. They cant make decisions. They might be okay at directing themselves on the road but have no consideration or awareness of drivers next to them, behind them, or in front of them. They lack road curtisy because they arent paying attention. I am generalizing, when i say they, i mean most women, i know some good ones but most make me nautious when im in the car with them. Men get into accidents because they expect women to drive better and then end up having to avoid the women when they cant make up their minds. Dont bother responding im not going to look back at this thread ever.

OneBdGolfr
OneBdGolfr

I believe it was George Carlin who said something like this: "Did you ever notice that anyone driving faster than you is a maniac, and that anyone driving slower than you is an idiot?  Well then, how are any of us supposed to get anywhere safely with all these maniacs and idiots on the road?"

MrGreenJeans
MrGreenJeans

I don't know if it is true that women are worse drivers than men, but I do know that many young people drive like crap. They are, besides being inexperienced drivers, generally rude, reckless, and impatient. there are of course exceptions to this, but when some dingbat almost gets me killed, they're usually young people, often on the cell or smart phone and too busy to be paying attention to driving.

Stack Of Hearts
Stack Of Hearts

Damn y'all, its simple as this. Men drive more (i assume due to the want to be in control, to be head of the pack yah know) and thus get much more practice. THey also tend to drive more aggressively (for much the same reason) which gets u into less car accidents but worse ones when it happens (a few commentators have already stated this). It seems the best driving style is a merge of both the fast and assertive style & the safe and steady used at the right times.

However, a lot of y'all just seem happy for the chance to jump on a college backed reason to get give back some pain. Its not if ur a dude or a chick, it's if you pay attention to the thousands of other crappy drivers out there and take the side road around 'um. Trust me, I know there's some damn sh*tty drivers out there! But most of um are just doing something stupid like txting.

Perfectharmony724
Perfectharmony724

Can't say I agree with this. I have been in 2 major accidents and both were caused by a male. One I was rearended because he admitedly was not paying attention and the other was a head on with a kid going 45 in a 15 mph zone in the rain in his daddy's sabb. I myself have not had a single ticket or accident. In over 10 years, and for 6 of those years was an out of district bus driver so I was on the road a lot. Typically they say women are better than men because we are better multi-taskers, usually juggling kids, errands, apointments, etc. Also don't forget to look at one fact, the location where this study was done, if they had expanded their study they may have had different results...

Playing devils advocate
Playing devils advocate

Women are well known to have more accidents, but they tend to be minorcollisions which are small and inexpensive for insurance companies, mentend to have much worse collisions.

For example I have been driving 5 years and have pranged the car twice,both were simple new driver mistakes done while parking once with abarrier and once with another empty car - stupid and easily avoidableyes, dangerous no. My brother on the other hand has been driving a yearand a half he has had one car accident, but it was a collision withanother car (though luckily no one was hurt) and was £50 short of aninsurance write off, much more expensive (for both us and the insurancecompany) then both of my prangs combined.

Men are also statisically responsible for a much higher preportion ofserious injuries and deaths caused by traffic accidents then women dueto the nature of the accidents they tend to have.

ipaycheaperinsurance
ipaycheaperinsurance

Well, I may be a worse driver, given this study of only 6 crashes in one city, but I pay a lot less in insurance than men for a lot longer. And that is a fact. U mad now ladies?

Cristian
Cristian

Tell us something that we already don't know please...

Leader Dear
Leader Dear

I love my wife and keep my Asian drive jokes to myself. Mostly.

Zack Walker
Zack Walker

not biased at all actually.  what is biased however is the fucking 20% increase in insurance premiums MALES have to pay.  Illegal discrimination if you ask me.  Time to turn the tables on the females now insurance companies!

homerjay
homerjay

Please cite sources. U of M (University of Michigan) is vague. Is the study published? Is it peer-reviewed. Was it just a group of undergrad students?

pesci
pesci

jews whaaaa since when are jews stereotyped as bad drivers women i agreelol

drall
drall

You needed a study to prove this?

Drive down any average road in America and you will see this.

Zero
Zero

I've noticed that men tend to be faster drivers, but women tend to follow closer where I live

Modestgirll
Modestgirll

I smell the tint of bias a mile away and the study is by NO MEANS comprehensive. Its a small sampling by two stupid racist woman haters, not even close to being reliable. Lame.

xsxsf
xsxsf

How about hand-eye coordination. Males tend to play more sports/video games which leads to better hand-eye coordination.

Saul
Saul

we are not racist...dumb ass we are sexists, which has merit lol! which you just proved to us all yet again, as if we need more proof

rationalthought
rationalthought

Why the fuck are you so pissed? Is generalizing women in the sense that they can't drive horrible and offensive? No. Is it going to stunt the growth your social equality or hold back the feminist movement? No. Stop being so Goddamn sensitive about fucking everything. Nothing makes men hate feminism like feminism. Men also don't set out to perform driving studies with secret ulterior agendas to discredit women by proving that they can't drive. So shut the fuck up. Do you just go around the internet leaving poorly thoughtout feminist comment on shit?

He-man Woman Hater
He-man Woman Hater

bahahahaha, racist woman haters? what a 'comprehensive' backlash... 

John
John

>I smell the tint of bias a mile away ...

It's common knowledge that women have more accidents per mile driven, however, when men have accidents it tends to be more expensive for insurers. This is where the media get their chance to propagate the myth that women are better drivers - perhaps that's one "tint of bias" you refuse to smell.

Jeffm
Jeffm

What you don't realize is that men are born with much higher motor skills and while women catch up, they never meet the same motor skills. When a boy is 2 years old he has the motor skills of a 5-6 year old girl. 

You're lame.

From the Vault

 

General

Music

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city