Top

blog

Stories

 

Beverly Hills School District Wants Metro to Prove Why Westside Subway Needs to go Under B.H. High School: So Far Metro is Mum

Categories: Transportation

Thumbnail image for subway.jpg
Foes of a proposed Westside Subway extension route that would tunnel under Beverly Hills High School are calling on Metro this week to show them the data that proves it should head that way instead of along Santa Monica Boulevard, as had been originally intended.

Those foes comprise the leadership of the Beverly Hills Unified School District, which notes that the transportation agency is blaming the possible move on a "Santa Monica fault zone" that would be bad for a more northerly route.

But so far, Metro is mum when it comes to showing the seismic data. School board prez Lisa Korbatov says in a statement this week:

This is another example of Metro's bait-and-switch tactics as it attempts to steamroll anyone who opposes its profligate plan to spend taxpayer dollars to benefit a handful of politically-connected developers. Metro's own data showed a station at Santa Monica and Avenue of the Stars would benefit more people for less money, but it didn't comport with the plans of private developers. So now Metro claims vague safety issues related to a fault and, voila, a superior station that had been planned for years and supported by the people of Beverly Hills disappears without so much as a public hearing.

As the Weekly's Patrick Range McDonald reported in a July 14 cover story, the more southerly route would provide a stop right near a Century City skyscraper planned by a developer with ties to L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, who happens to have more political influence over the Metro board than any other single person.


View Larger Map

McDonald:

Such a route would take the subway to the foot of a 37-story "Century City Center" skyscraper expected to be built by JMB, a City Hall-connected developer that has showered Villaraigosa with campaign funds.

The original stop at Santa Monica Boulevard would have seen more ridership, according to Metro's own data. So if this is really about seismic data, the B.H. school district says, prove it.

Metro says on its website that the southerly route under Beverly Hills High School "will increase safety by locating the station farther away from the Santa Monica Fault zone."

So far, the school district alleges, Metro is using data to justify a southerly bend in the line while at the same time saying the seismic figures aren't conclusive enough to release to the public.

Korbatov:

The irony is that Metro steadfastly refuses to release any of the seismic data it used to kill the station, saying it's incomplete or inconclusive. Yet the studies were apparently complete and conclusive enough for Metro to decide to eliminate the Santa Monica/Avenue of the Stars location. If Metro has nothing to hide, it should immediately make public the research and reports it used to exclude this station from consideration ... Metro must stop operating in the shadows ...

The final decision on where the subway will stop will be up to the Metro board, where Villaraigosa holds much sway.

[@dennisjromero/djromero@laweekly.com]


My Voice Nation Help
11 comments
Sam
Sam

There is only one problem: The Inglewood Newport Fault. It goes right under the High School. Soon Lisa and her crew are about to find out about the need to retrofit the High School and to come up with another $20 million or so to finish the seismic strengthening. The State Architect will rule that the subway tunnel is just fine with a box, but the High School can not build anything new and must protect the old. 

Look for this to come out around October 20 publicly.  

roylee
roylee

well they can bring the subway up over the santa monica fault line on an elivated rail guide way then onece it away from the fault line back to subway

Evan G.
Evan G.

First there was the Weakley's ad hominem (and ad nauseam) anti-bike posts and articles, and now the anti-subway articles.

Is the Weakley trying to get more advertising dollars from local car dealerships? It's okay to admit it. It won't damage your credibility any further than you've already done yourselves. 

Zuman
Zuman

What is it with this newspaper? It's like the LA Daily News used to be about valley cityhood, except worse. I think the fumes from the 405 have seeped into the new "Offramp Tower" LAW office building at Sepulveda

Joe
Joe

I am amused that BHUSD's Korbatov continually hammers the Constellation station choice as being pushed by Century City big developers as though Bev Hills is some third world country to be pitied.  Bev Hills wants the station closer to the business district they plan to develope on their western border.  It's all about their own developers.The reason Constellation is the best choice is because it is where the most people commute to work. Thousands work at Fox Studios on Pico in addition to the thousands in the center of Century City. Would they have to schlep all the way to SM Blvd. next to a country club to catch the subway?  Looks like the big PR firm hired by BH has paid off our once honorable LA Weekly.  The only thing left that's good is Jonathan Gold's restaurant reviews!

Anti-Bozos
Anti-Bozos

Especially anything written by this biased bozo!

Dan W.
Dan W.

How sad that the once relevant L.A. Weekly has gone from being an alternative paper with a progressive viewpoint to being a showcase for bad journalism.

Alexander the Great
Alexander the Great

Shame on LA Weekly for being an ass-kisser for BHUSD, and for being sooo anti-transit. Oh, well... it doesn't suprise me anymore. Just like Beverly Hills NIMBY's, LA Weekly has proven to be an ignorant, biased newspaper. Which doesn't deserve a single minute of the readers' time!

LAofAnaheim
LAofAnaheim

Metro won a court decision last week that they don't have to release reports prior to the release of the FEIR. Why don't you cite that to combat the BHHS arguement?

ChrisLoos
ChrisLoos

What's up with the LA Weekly's bias against this project? Dennis Romero quotes Korbatov twice, while neglecting to mention that she already got smacked down last Friday by the CA Superior Court. The judge ruled that Metro did NOT violate the California Public Records Act because...(surprise, surprise)...Metro hasn't finished the final EIR yet.  You wouldn't go to a scientist and demand their final results when they're still conducting experiments. An environmental impact report is no different.

Korbatov...and now the LA Weekly, have both shown shown a profound misunderstanding for how the EIR process works. 

ChrisLoos
ChrisLoos

What's up with the LA Weekly's bias against this project? Dennis Romero quotes Korbatov twice, while neglecting to mention that she already got smacked down last Friday by the CA Superior Court. The judge ruled that Metro did NOT violate the California Public Records Act because...(surprise, surprise)...Metro hasn't finished the final EIR yet.  You wouldn't go to a scientist and demand their final results when they're still conducting experiments. An environmental impact report is no different.Korbatov...and now the LA Weekly, have both shown shown a profound misunderstanding for how the EIR process works.http://thesource.metro.net/2011/09/16...

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

General

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city