Arne Duncan, U.S. Secretary of Education, Walks Out on 1,000-Plus Parents Who Traveled to His L.A. County Town Hall

arne duncan.jpeg
Arne Duncan has places to be.
Lydia Grant, a big education activist in SoCal, asked us to attend U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan's two-hour-long town hall in Pico Rivera earlier this week. Duncan had promised big things for the Tuesday event:

The town hall is hosted by the U.S. Department of Education and will include space for the public to ask questions and share their thoughts. The event is designed to engage community leaders from across the Los Angeles region in meeting President Barack Obama's challenge to lead the world in college completion by 2020.

Grant also invited about 200 parents -- and says over 1,000 showed up in total, some traveling all the way up from San Diego. But that didn't stop Duncan from walking out after 20 minutes.

"Everybody was just shocked," says Grant, because the town hall had been "pushed as if parents were going to be able to really tell their stories and get help."

And even for the short time Duncan was speaking and answering a couple questions in the brick El Rancho High School basketball court, according to Grant, the audience could barely hear what he was saying. The only words that really came through were "Jobs Act."

Oh, brother. A straightforward news piece from the Whittier Daily News reads like a campaign flyer:

El Ranch High School student John Barrios, 17, asked what could be done to help schools succeed.

Duncan said the passage of the Jobs Act "needs to happen" because the current economic situation has depleted school district budgets.

"It will keep teachers in the classroom, strengthen our schools and improve the local economy in communities across the country," he said.

If Obama's going to plant someone in east L.A. County -- because he's too scared to show his face outside a Hancock Park gala -- he could at least choose someone who's got the patience to pretend to listen to desperate parents for more than 20 minutes.

According to the Whittier newspaper, Duncan also took some time to praise California Governor Jerry Brown for his passage of the DREAM Act, in case everyone and their mother hadn't gotten word already, and let a couple congresswomen traveling with him talk about what a great job Duncan has been doing.

"It was awful," says Grant. "One-third of the audience got up and left."

Good for them. We would have done the same.

[@simone_electra/swilson@laweekly.com]

My Voice Nation Help
7 comments
Francesco M. DiGiovanni
Francesco M. DiGiovanni

     Sounds like a partisan campaign rally was what Arne Duncan was conducting rather than a real discussion with those parents.

PamJBP
PamJBP

It's time for the federal government to relax its death grip on parents, teachers and principals.  What good has the DOE done in its thirty years? 

George Buzzetti
George Buzzetti

I a member of the Congress of racial Equality of California (CORE-CA) called Lydia Grant from the Parent Revolution and Yolande Beckles from the Parent Union to have them contact Secretary Duncan's office for them to bring some into the meeting.  The Department of Education is the one who told them to bring every student, parent, teacher and community member they could find to the Town Hall Meeting in Pico Rivera because the Secretary of Education, Arne Duncan, wanted to hear from them.  We did that.  People from as far away as San Bernadino and San Diego came at the Secretary's request.  

Secretary Duncan also was at the LAUSD Board of Education with Superintendent Deasy and Mayor Villaraigosa earlier to announce the agreement with LAUSD on the civil rights violations of African-American and English as a Second Language (ESL) students.  At the meeting he also said he wanted to talk with students, parents and teachers.  In the press conference room a (CORE-CA) member says to Secretary Duncan and Villaraigosa separately "How can the Federal Government back Mayor Villaraigosa's schools with a Roosevelt High School dropout rate of 66% and scores at one of the seven academies dropping 85 points in one year.  To Secretary Duncan he adds "I hope you want to speak to students, parents and teachers as we have over 200 waiting for you." 

Secretary Duncan arrives there early for a private meeting with the "Big Wigs" and politicians.  He enters the room late and takes only a few questions.  He answers some, not all, questions and says "I am leaving now."  Unacceptable.  I was in the question line and yelled load enough for all to hear "He does not care about students, parents or teachers, he is leaving to go get money."  1/3 of the audience looked at me and were saying to themselves "Why is he talking to the Secretary of Education like that?"  2/3 looked and I could see them thinking "I wish I had said that."  You know he was on his way to a fund raiser where everyone will pat him on the back.  1/2 of the audience left in disgust, I have heard, as I went outside with one  of Secretary Duncan's aides, about 6 police and lots of students. 

 I then laid into the aide with the history of Secretary Duncan in Chicago, a failure, and his lying to the California Legislature for Mayoral Control of LAUSD.  I have the documents.  The police even started laughing about what I was saying.  He had no ability to say anything to rebute me as this is the documented truth.  When he left it was me, my advocate friends who got over 200 people there and the students.  The students were the best part of the whole thing.  They are so smart and have such good questions.  Why is it we wanted to hear from students and the Secretary of Education did not?

Francesca
Francesca

Mr. Buzzetti,

You are a hero for speaking out!  Thank you for proclaiming that Emperor Duncan has no clothes.

George Buzzetti
George Buzzetti

I am the person who yelled to the audience "He has no respect for students, parents or teachers, he is now on his way to get money."  I did not plan that.  It happened as a reaction to his total disrespect, and if not addressed right then and there he would get away with it.  I was not going to allow that to happen as I am the one who originated opening up a closed meeting to all comers through Lydia Grant, Board Member of the Parent Revolution, and Yolande Beckles with the LAUSD Parent District Advisory Council (DAC) and new Parent Union.  I am with the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) of California and requested attendance for three members myself, Celes King IV and Miguel Paredes.  We received that Sunday.  Monday I called Lydia and Yolande to send in requests on their letterhead, they did.  Within several hours both received phone calls, from officials representing Duncan, asking them to bring every student, parent, teacher and community member they can so they can be listened to by the Secretary of Education.  Also, go to the press so we can have as many people there as possible.  This was done.  From San Diego to the edge of L.A. County they came including a bus load paid for by The California Teachers Association (CTA) who helped parents go to this supposedly important event for the public to be heard.  Channel 11 was there and got video of me calling down Duncan and ran on the news he ran from parents.  He was there by helicopter no more than 20 minutes total. 

When I went outside with one of his aides, and a lot of police, I ripped his aide apart so much the police started laughing.  Students were watching all of this intently.  The aide left and I spent the next hour plus with many students who told me and my other friends there what is really happening to them.  I also had my laptop and wireless card and showed them the statistical facts.  I took them to the California Dept. of Education (CDE) website and asked them to give me a school and we went there and I showed them how to use the website to do what I do to learn the truth.  They gave me their emails and I am sending them my spreadsheets and the instructions on how to use the CDE website. 

I must ask you to also ask youselves the same question I asked myself, and that is "Why were they not out there talking with the students?"  Isn't that supposed to be their MISSION!!!!!

Unfortunately, we are seeing the same Arne Duncan as in Chicago.  He helped to ruin the Chicago Public Schools academically and financially.  Please go look at the new University of Chicago study on Chicago Public Schools from 1988 until now.  He did not do good.

Also, while superintendent of Chicago he and Senator Feinstein wrote letters to the California Legislature stating that those before Daley and Vallas took over in 1995 had put the district into $1.8 billion in debt.  I have the financial income and expendatures from 1994 and there was a surplus.  They lied.  Is this who we want for Secretary of Education?  A person with no respect for the public and a liar!

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

General

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city