Top

blog

Stories

 

Carmen Trutanich A No-Show At District Attorney's Debate, As Six Prosecutors Spar For The Top Job

Categories: Politics
Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Carmen_Trutanich_Los_Angeles_City_Attorney.jpg
Carmen Trutanich: Uninvited?
The race for L.A. County District Attorney has been a quiet affair up to this point.

The leading fundraiser, City Attorney Carmen Trutanich, hasn't even officially declared. Meanwhile, the declared candidates -- half a dozen prosecutors -- are mostly unknown to the general public.

But things are starting to heat up a little. The D.A. candidates held their first debate on Wednesday night, at which they started to flesh out some of the issues that will dominate the campaign.

The only drawback was that Trutanich -- who everybody seems to consider the front-runner -- wasn't there.

Officially, Trutanich has only announced an "exploratory" effort. But most everybody seems to think he's just laying low as long as possible, because the minute he announces he'll start taking fire from all sides.

John Shallman, Trutanich's campaign manager, said that Trutanich did not participate in the debate because "He wasn't invited." But one of the debate organizers, Halim Dhanidina, said he reached out to the Trutanich campaign to ask if the city attorney wanted to participate, and never got a call back.

So that left six prosecutors to debate the issues before a packed room of more than 300 people at the Japanese American National Museum. A seventh prosecutor, Marcus Musante, was not invited to participate, and had to content himself with a front-row seat.

Nobody drew any blood, but some clear distinctions emerged in discussions of prison realignment, medical marijuana and the death penalty. Based on those issues, here's a highly provisional ideological ranking of the announced candidates. It's subject to change, but here's how it looks at the moment, in order from most conservative to most liberal.

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for AlanJackson Headshot.jpg
Alan Jackson
Alan Jackson

Jackson seems to be the most alarmed about prison realignment -- the state's money-saving gambit to transfer non-violent offenders from overcrowded prisons to county jails. "It's going to be devastating," Jackson said. "I'm kept awake at night worrying what this release is going to do to crime rates." He sounds a lot like his boss, Steve Cooley, who has also warned of a crime wave.

On medical marijuana, Jackson said that while he supports the concept, he has a major concern with the proliferation of pot dispensaries. "There are profiteers out there who have turned it into a farce," he said. "It needs to be highly regulated."

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for jackielacey.jpg
Jackie Lacey
Jackie Lacey

Lacey, Cooley's top deputy, doesn't have Alan Jackson's fiery delivery. But on most issues, they seem to basically agree with each other (and with Cooley). On realignment, Lacey was slightly less alarmist than Jackson, but still pretty alarmed: "The change was too fast, too soon, and not well thought out," she said. "That's why it's a disaster."

As for the death penalty, she and Jackson obviously both support it. Lacey argues that the death penalty appeals process is broken, because it takes too long. But she wouldn't change anything about how the L.A. County D.A.'s office pursues it.

And on medical marijuana, she too supports it in concept, but worries that "a criminal enterprise has taken over some of the dispensaries."

Danette_Meyers.jpg
Danette Meyers
Danette Meyers

Now we're outside the Cooley orbit. Meyers would be much more of a break with the current administration. For example, she has vowed to step up environmental prosecutions, which she argues have lapsed on Cooley's watch.

Though she thinks realignment was poorly thought out, Meyers says, "We're stuck with it." She wants to turn attention to how to obtain funding for rehabilitation.

On the death penalty, Meyers supports it, but sees a need for reform at the local level. She said she would limit the types of murders that qualify for death sentences to the worst of the worst. But she also expressed frustration that the D.A.'s capital punishment panel didn't approve one of her own cases for the death penalty.

bobbygrace.jpg
Bobby Grace
Bobby Grace

Bobby Grace seems pretty close to Danette Meyers on the ideological spectrum. Both would represent a shift away from Cooley, but on slightly different terms. Where Meyers would focus on environmental issues, for example, Grace would focus on juvenile justice reform and public corruption.

If Grace seems just a little more "liberal" than Meyers, it's probably more a question of style. Meyers touts her tough-on-crime record, while Grace seems a little more conciliatory. This one's subject to revision.

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Mario Trujillo.jpg
Mario Trujillo
Mario Trujillo

Now we're getting into lefty territory. At Wednesday's debate, Trujillo came the closest of any of the candidates to opposing the death penalty. "Why keep it on the books if it's not working?" he asked. "I support it, but my resources are limited. My loyalty is to my victims, and I feel like we're lying to our victims."

Trujillo also spoke against prosecuting motorists for driving without a license, and said that too many low-level offenders are heading to state prison. And as for marijuana, he predicted that someday soon it will be fully legal.

steveipsen.jpg
Steve Ipsen
Steve Ipsen

Steve Ipsen is best known for waging epic battles with Cooley's office over union issues.

In the debate, he sounded almost like a public defender, repeatedly warning against prosecuting young people for drug possession. "Don't immediately make some kid a felon," he said.

His candidacy is geared around a "Reform First" platform, which emphasizes diverting offenders to community service instead of prison.

Marcus Musante


Musante didn't get to debate, but if he had he'd be the most liberal candidate on the stage. More about his views can be found here.

My Voice Nation Help
31 comments
NY Private Investigator
NY Private Investigator

Attorney Law Firms, to join our Private Investigator & Armed Security Company.   We will work for you and your clients 

Call or Text Us: (732) 637 9111 or E-Mail: info@pvtdets.com

NY Private Investigator
NY Private Investigator

Attorney Law Firms, to join our Private Investigator & Armed Security Company.   We will work for you and your clients 

Call or Text Us: (732) 637 9111 or E-Mail: info@pvtdets.com

Sick of career politicians
Sick of career politicians

Trutanich didn't exactly stay away from the forum, he sent a campaign worker to spy on the other candidates. It's causing quite a scandal on the blogs, turns out the spy is also one of Trutanich's city employees and should not be used for political campaigning. I guess when you are the city attorney you don't have to play by the rules, you can make your own rules. Vote Trutanich for DA? I don't think so.

Daphna
Daphna

Trutanich's latest lame excuse for chick ending out of the forum is that he was not "officially" invited. Seems he realizes that Halim Dhanadina is willing to go on the record stating Trutanich was invited, so his slimy excuse is that the invite wasn't "official" enough for him. WTF did he expect? A calligraphic scroll with his name in gold foil? Trutanich is a coward and his failure to appear shows he knows he's vulnerable. Not surprising the SFV republican club threw him out.

Briana Scalia
Briana Scalia

Gene Maddus received an award fromthe Southern California Journalism Awards/LA Press Club, published December 2,2010  "L.A.'s Light Rail Fiasco", and nowauthor of LA Weekly Blog titled “Carmen Trutanich a no show at the District Attorney’sDebate, as Six Prosecutors Spar for the Top Job, published November 3, 2011.” 

Maddus, you have expressed your opinion of all the six prosecutors whodebated last week at the District Attorneys debate, which I too attended.  However, your blog pointing out the fact thatCarmen Trutanich was a no show was apparent.  You also seem to not be biasedbecause your article is riddled without any facts to support your claimsespecially regarding Ispen or why Trutanich was a no show. 

You stated that “Steve Ispen is best known for wagingepic battles with Cooley's office over union issues.”   Now we all know that we are all entitled to ourFirst Amendment rights.  However, Ichallenge you not to be so vague and ambiguous and to please support yourstatement with facts regarding Ispen.   

Steve Ipsen shouldbe seen as a hero and trend setter. Nearly the entire rest of the optionsindicated they would be nothing other than Cooley clones, following in hisfootsteps.  If you want to bring changeto a community, do you choose between five or so clones of Cooley, or do youchoose the only running DA to actually stand up to Cooley and be vindicated inFederal Court. 

In short, Cooleyhas been found to use retaliation, as well as Union Busting. The last time Ichecked this falls under RICO violations, which if they had occurred to anotherindividual would bring both criminal and civil charges.

Proving the pointis an article written by Betty Pleasant, Contributing Editor, published on June29, 2011, quoting a Federal judge who said the following: “Deputies to LosAngeles County District Attorney Steve Cooley are preparing for a Sept. 20trial date for their lawsuit against him, his chief deputy, Jacquelyn Lacey;the deputy in charge of the Bellflower office, Mario Trujillo; six otherhigh-ranking D.A. officials; and the county of Los Angeles for compensatory andpunitive damages they suffered as the result of a retaliatory, union-bustingcampaign Cooley is said to have directed when his subordinates began organizinga bargaining unit of the Association of Deputy District Attorneys.”

“The lawsuit,filed April 5, 2010 by four individual deputy D.A.s and the association as awhole, comes on the heels of a preliminary injunction granted against Cooley etal. by U.S. District Judge Otis D. Wright II, who used strong words to renderhis decision that Cooley and the gang had, indeed, implemented a retaliatory,discriminatory, intimidating and slanderous campaign to stop L.A. County’sdeputy D.A.s from unionizing. The injunction ordered Cooley and his agents tocease such actions.”

The judge also noted that, among otherthings, “Cooley “punitively transferred several deputy district attorneysassociated with ADDA, demoted them, awarded them undeserved, mediocreperformance reviews and otherwise discriminated against them...”

“According toJudge Wright’s order, Lacey, the D.A. wannabe, was deeply involved in Cooley’sunion-busting reign of terror, starting with her early refusal of a unionrequest that she issue a memorandum to all prosecutors stating the D.A.’soffice would be neutral regarding union organization and would refrain fromretaliating against any prosecutor for exercising his or her right to joinADDA. Then, she admitted in the injunction hearing how veteran unionizedprosecutors were demoted to entry-level positions and how heretofore consistent“outstanding” prosecutors were suddenly issued “needs improvement” ratings.”…

We have the DA as the prosecutorial arm ofthe government. Do we want to have five clones of a corrupt Cooley or do wewant to have the sole challenger, Steve Ipsen, who is not a Cooley clone, leadingthe change of the system.  My bet isSteve Ipsen.

A badge of honorexists when the only real challenger to the system is attacked. You sir, GeneMaddus, have given Steve Ipsen just another one of those honors. What theslight and attack does do, is show that Ispen is a viable candidate, which iswhy you have taken the time to slight and distort Ispen’s message.  Although the badge of honor Steve wears that youbestowed on him is not the only badge of honor he wears, that badge coming fromyou indicates that Steve Ipsen truly is feared as an actual front runner forchange.

 

Maropo
Maropo

Trutanich was a no show because he got frightened by the reaction of the audience at the Republican club on Tuesday night. He was heckled and booed and ordered to leave because people were so angry at him for making fools of them. Trutanich thinks winning an election is like winning a trial where the jury doesn't get to hear all the evidence. But the blogs will take him down, hard. He had it easy winning against Jackass Weiss, but this time around he's the Jackass. 

anonymous
anonymous

Add some more DAs like anyone knows who the hell they are.  Trutanich will win based on his name recognition.

Jerry
Jerry

Trutanich aka Carmen the Clown won't have the kind of name recognition it takes to win as DA. Alan Jackson got international name recognition for winning the Phil Spector case, Trrutanich made headlines for making a fool of himself threatening AEG, student protestors, and Jan Perry - and then doing nothing. He's an empty suit with a schoolyard bully mentality. The fact that he ducked out of facing the music at the forum shows that he is a coward, which is typical of bullies. Trutanich got booed and jeered at a neighborhood meeting two days after he chickened out of the forum, so the word is spreading fast and people are getting to realize who and what he really is.

Truth&Justice
Truth&Justice

Trutanich was booed and shouted at when he started talking at the Republican party meeting on Tuesday night. People who supported him have turned against him because of his horrible record over the past two years. Sure he's got name recognition, so has Mubarak, Gadaffi, and any number of other bully tyrants. Alan Jackson has taken the Republican vote from Trutanich, and Trujillo has the Latino vote. Both communities were vital to Trutanich, so what's he let with? A bunch of high rollers who are buying favors with campaign donations. But the people who vote know who Trutanich is, and they're not voting for him again - unless it's in a recall.

Maropo
Maropo

I would definitely vote for Trutanich - in a recall! 

Lisa K.
Lisa K.

Yeah, like ANY LA County voters who aren't criminal prosecutors or defense attorneys could name the "international" star who prosecuted Phil Spector (who nobody under 50 knows anyway). Trutanich wins in a walk-off. 

Truth&Justice
Truth&Justice

I like Steve Ipsen, one of his closest friends is a three time convicted sex offender, and Steve Ipsen testified as a character witness for his friend, so any friend of a sex offender is just fine with me to be the DA. I also admire the way he committed prosecutorial misconduct in a murder case, just to get both killers convicted. Ipsen rocks!!!

Justiceforcalifornia
Justiceforcalifornia

Truth and Justice is David Beger aka Joe Friday aka Jack Webb aka Monique aka Steve Cooley aka the Met News who has been blogging this same BS for over four years.  It is clearly from within the office who is twisting facts because they are so desparate.  

Truth and Justice is nothing about truth and justice because Steve Ipsen was called to testify after his friend was sentenced.  He stated his friend was guilty and was glad that he was convicted, needed mental counseling and deserved what ever punishment the judge gave him.  He was also not a registered sex offender at the time.  So if you are about truth and justice, then why do you lie this lame little post all the time.  You are creepy. 

There are 3 jokers in Cooley's pocket and they blog in mommies basement.  So sad.  Also, the State Bar found no discipline to the routine complaint on a death penalty case of prosecutorial misconduct.  This old blog is poor David Berger and friends who are so desparate that their lame post shows up every time there is an article about Steve Ipsen.  

Steve Ipsen our victim's rights hero, the writer of Marsy's Law, the 8 term past president of the DA's union and one of the most tenacious, fair and just prosecutors in the DA's office who has won over 100 jury trials without acquital.  What do you do all day long Joe Friday aka David Berger?  Blog on county time with my tax dollars while murderers and rapists await prosecution.  Victim's are on to you and Monique and your little game and we will throw Ipsen's record against yours or Cooley's any day because his is one to be proud of.

You are just pouting that Cooley's corruption is finally catching up to him and you were fired from the City Attorney's office, probably due to your incompetence.  Cooley is corrupt and circling the drain as far as his peers are concerned.  He isn't respected and is so distraught that he has a federal injunction against him that is unheard of.  It is sad that Cooley has to be controlled by the federal courts, and the only thing he has to pet him are his bedroom bloggers!  So read it and weep Joe Friday.  You are nothing like the real Joe Friday and never will be.  Victims will follow you and your stinky little posts and pass the word.

Laney
Laney

Well said! Ipsen is a hero for standing up for his friend who exposed himself to a girl in an elevator. It takes a brave man like Ipsen to defend a three-time sex offender and to argue that his friend should not have to register as a sex offender. It was 'no big deal' for the girl to be trapped in the elevator with Ipsen's friend - she wasn't raped was she? She wasn't a victim, Ipsen's friend was the real victim. Thank goodness Ipsen let him use his car with his DA badge in it so he could drive around town. That's what victims' friends do.

And the stuff about the Supreme Court condemning Ipsen for prosecutorial misconduct in a murder case was just stupid. Who cares if Ipsen bends the rules to get murderers convicted? That's what victims' friends do. Yeah, I'm sick of prosecutors who follow the law. They need to use the same sick dirty tricks that the criminals use to get justice. Vote Ipsen.  

CorruptCooley
CorruptCooley

Let's bend the rules to cover up Brady Evidence too Laney (Monique).  Let's tell Cooley it is okay to cover up Brady while Curt Hazel is sleeping with a key witness while he is prosecuting a death penalty case.  According to Cooley covering up Brady is okay as long as it is a manager or a friend of Cooley.  Why do you think he calls the union members misfits?  Because they keep exposing Cooley's corruption.  This is what it is really about isn't it.  Laney, you are probably one of Cooley's managers who has a DUI and are doing Cooley's bidding aren't you.  Well, my friend's son is dead because Cooley's racist friend called a patron a NIGG**.  Cooley is racist and a union buster!  This is about the fact that Cooley can't stand that no one respects him as a person, a leader, a trial attorney and a DA.  He uses his thugary to control people and it is all coming to a head.  That is what this is about.  The corruption Ipsen and the union have uncovered.  Isn't it Berger, I mean Laney, I mean Monique.

Trevor
Trevor

Truth & Justice is a tool for the thugs who run the DA's office. Ipsen had every right to stand up for his friend who was persecuted for a minor indiscretion for the third time. All he did was expose himself in an elevator to some silly young girl who probably was flirting with him anyway. It was wrong, as Ipsen pointed out, but it was not as if this girl was raped or forced to do anything. Most women are used to seeing men without their clothes on, so it was no big deal.

The law was being unfairly harsh in this case, and Ipsen rightly argued that his friend should not have register as a so-called 'sex offender.' His friend was going through a hard time and was living with Ipsen while he worked out his problems. At the time of this overblown offense, he was using Ipsen's car and had Ipsen's DA badge. That's the kind of guy Ipsen is, someone who will stand up for a friend who is being railroaded by the system.

Using criminal law to destroy the lives of people who make mistakes is wrong, and Ipsen's reform first movement is based on stopping the insanity of making criminals out of people with problems. I think Ipsen will shock his critics by producing the girl (who is now happily married with children) and his friend, and have them both agree that his was a very minor matter that should never have been prosecuted.

LAinjustice
LAinjustice

Maybe this is all being brought out by Trevor (aka Monique aka Berger aka Cooley) after 10 years where Cooley did nothing and prosecuted it as a misdemeanor because Cooley hates Ipsen and the union that has exposed all of his corruption. 

Maybe it is because Cooley has to be controlled by the federal courts. 

Maybe it is because a union member exposed Cooley's best friend Curt Hazell and college roommate who was second in charge of the DAs office for years after he slept with a stripper and key witness in a death penalty case causing the case to be over turned and costing the tax payers millions.  "Cooley's Blind Eye" - the LA weekly even reported on it.  

Maybe it is because Ipsen exposed Cooley's soft on sex offender secret deal that he made with the judges to give 2 years to rapists, forced sex upon children and sadistic sodomy.  Cooley promotes plenty of his friends who get DUI's.  Some of them are currently managers.  I bet the public would love to know that Cooley protects any manager who gets a DUI especially when it is on the way home from his fund raiser. 

Let's not forget the trial I watched where my friend's son was murdered after Bob Foltz intentionally covered up evidence and intentionally prosecuted the wrong person for murder after Cooley's good friend and owner of Schooner's Bar called a patron a NIG**R.  When the patron came back and shot up the place my friend's son died.  But, Cooley and Foltz wanted to protect their drinking buddy and his business and so they didn't show the video tape of the incident in the first trial that caused a hung jury.  Cooley hates Ipsen because Ipsen had to clean up the mess and prosecute the correct person.  And lets not forget this was after, let see, how many times did I see Foltz's name in the paper for DUIs and State Bar discipline, yet he remained in charge in the Antelope Valley.

Hey Trevor (aka Berger aka Monique aka Cooley), lets tit for tat all day long because my family member is dead and Cooley's corruption is at the helm.  I can do this all day long and expose more of Cooley's corruption if you like.

Cooley'sRacketerringCircus
Cooley'sRacketerringCircus

It is so obivous that Steve Cooley is using the Met News and David Berger to do his bidding.  Kevin James is even in on the little three ring circus.  Hey Cooley this is a federal offense to illegally control the media by having them take down articles and posts you don't like when flaws are highlighted about your chosen little suck ups.   Also, who made the call to the Pasadena Star to take down the article about Alan Jackson's violation of Marsy's Law?  Cooley is running the largest racketeering circus I have ever seen.  You wait, tomorrow there will be an article in the Met News (who voted Cooley person of the year) parroting David Bergers little basement blog.  Cooley is a class act and we are on to his illegal use of the media to carry out his agenda.  It is so clear that a blind bat can see throug it.  Are you going to take this one down LA Weekly? 

Joe Friday
Joe Friday

Trutanich not showing up is a major sign of weakness on his part. For sure he does not want to be cross examined by the six experienced prosecutors who were at the table. They would have a field day taking him apart over his "Pledge to serve" as city attorney and not run for DA. Does he really think LA voters are support someone who goes back on his own word at the drop of a hat?

Justiceforcalifornia
Justiceforcalifornia

Stinky Joe the bedroom blogger aka David Berger aka the one who was fired by Trutanich in the city attorney's office.

Mike
Mike

Love the way the Trutnanich people trash Berger and the Dragnet for outing Trutanich's inconvenient truths. The lie about Trutanich not wanting to use the city attorney's office as a springboard to higher office and then the embarrassing business over Trutanich's unpermited billboards (that he had to take down) would never come to light if it were not for someone standing up to this schoolyard bully. 

Sipsen
Sipsen

Why do you highlight someone who has not announced and to persons closely associated to the current DA.? What kind of journalism is this? The reader expects a fair an unbiased reporting of the issues addressed by the persons debating. The article falls far short of this.

anonymous
anonymous

Trutanich supports everything foul & smelly in City Hall like Dennis Zine for City Controller.  He stinks. 

NewDATime
NewDATime

Ipsen and Meyers are the only two with the guts to take on Cooley's calamity.  Good for them.  Meyers said she was going to place DAs in important postions based on merit rather then "what they look like".  She also said that she will end the retaliation to DAs.  Sort of a slam to Cooley and solidifies that the turmoil in the DAs office isn't a farce made up by the union, that it is real.  Trujillo will probably end up running for judge.  There is always a chance most of these guys will back out and Cooley will get back in.  Cooley would do that just to keep Trutanich out and avoid debates.

VotersTakeNote
VotersTakeNote

I like Steve Ipsen's plan to reform the criminal justice system.  As Lacey and Jackson tried to blame the legislature and the Governor.  Ipsen said that it was irresponsible to blame the legislature and the governor when the DA's office has done nothing for the last 10 years despite the law suits pending and that Cooley and Lacey knew this was coming.  Ipsen also wrote Marsy's Law and is a long time friend to victims compared to Jackson who horrifically violated Marsy's Law and failed to notify a victims family when he reduced a death penalty case to manslaughter and gave a murderer 6 years less than 6 months ago.  Schwarzenneger is being sued for the same thing.  Jackson is clearly not a friend to victims that is for sure.  Danette Meyers did a great job and Trujillo also made some good points about Cooley's waste of tax payers money on the medical marajuana efforts.  Ipsen, Meyers and Trujillo are the best candidates.  Jackson and Lacey are basically going to do the same thing Cooley has been doing forever.  So, if you like Cooley and the prison overcrowding crisis that is what you will get if you vote for them.

Mr. Alpe
Mr. Alpe

From what I saw and heard from Ipsen at the forum, I do not think he has the right attitude towards the job. If he wanted to be a public defender or ACLU leader, then maybe he has the right qualities. Jackson, Lacey and Grace all presented a more realistic and fair approach to law enforcement. I am also glad Trutanich had the sense to back out of the DA race, he should fulfill his promise to voters and finish the job he said he would do, even if it is harder than he thought it would be.

Maropo
Maropo

Ipsen is utterly irrelevant, almost as much of a joke as Musante. Jackson and Meyers are the best of this bunch. Trutanich hasn't got a chance with either of them in the race - they are not afraid to take him apart piece by piece like a crook on the stand. Trutanich's no-show was more like him taking the 5th, the moment he allows himself to be cross examined, he will implode.

From the Vault

 

Fashion

General

Loading...