Top

blog

Stories

 

Million-Dollar City Yacht Is Really More of a Boat, Insists L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa

Categories: City News

Angelena_II.jpg
portoflosangeles.org
The Angelena II.
Awww! L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa says the darndest things when he's caught with his hand in the cookie jar.

Dogged CBS LA investigator David Goldstein asked the mayor why, so deep in a budget hole, the city is spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to maintain a million-dollar touring yacht at the Port of Los Angeles.

Villaraigosa's adorable reply:

"It's not a yacht. It's a boat."

The problem is obviously not a semantic one -- but hey, if he wants to play that game, we'll bite.

After hours of hard-hitting Internet research (Ask.com, Yahoo Answers, the works!), we've determined that the Angelena II is, by all common-sense standards, a yacht. According to the Port's website, the Angelena II is 73 feet long. And according to Front Range Insurance Group: "Generally, 'boats' are considered to be 26' and smaller, and 'yachts' are 27' and larger."

A yacht is also defined, in most cases, as a leisure vessel instead of working vessel. So I guess it's up to the taxpayer to decide if "public-relations tours" are of a leisurely or laborious nature. Here are some of its former passengers, via Goldstein:

• Banning High students • Members of the Morongo Indian Tribe • Screenwriters from Universal Studios • YWCA cruisers • People from the exclusive Jonathan Club • UCLA students • Dozens of the mayor's interns

A press release on the Angelena II's fancy new fuel system paints a more noble portrait of the yacht's ridership:

Purchased by the Port in 1988, the 73-foot Angelena II is used to highlight the capabilities of the Port facilities with customers, constituents, public leaders, foreign dignitaries, media and stakeholders. The Port provides several hundred tours annually on the Angelena II, which takes a maximum of 40 guests for 60- to 90-minute tours that highlight the value of the Port. In 2011, the Port hosted more than 4,000 visitors on Angelena II tours.

However you define it, the costs of maintaining this million-dollar city pet are dizzying.

CBS reports that "Over the next couple of months they will be spending close to three quarters of a million dollars on upgrades." And the Port says, "Installation and repair work is being done by city workers, including electricians, carpenters and others." (Essentially the most expensive labor force that taxes can buy.)

The Port of Los Angeles likes to pretend it's free of responsibility to the taxpayers, as it generates its own profits. But just because it's not directly leeching off the city's general fund doesn't mean it's not a public agency. The now-defunct L.A. Community Redevelopment Agency tried to use the same argument -- until Governor Jerry Brown called BS and buried it alive.

Nope -- it's the people's port, and the money it generates could just as easily go back to the people as to yachts/$200,000 parties.

Much like said party, this appears to be another of Villaraigosa's expensive, delusional outreaches to Asia. He tells CBS:

"[Yacht passengers have] gone to see why the Port is such an important part of this administration's priorities. We have got to promote trade. That's why I was in China, Japan and Korea."

[@simone_electra / swilson@laweekly.com / @LAWeeklyNews]

My Voice Nation Help
45 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Guest
Guest

There are many eye-catching, exciting luxury yacht anchorages. The environment of the Bahamas is subtropical to exotic. The West River considerably moderates the environment particularly during the cold months season. Summer time conditions in the Bahamas average 30 levels Celsius and are just 5 levels Celsius chilly during the cold months season. Summer time and september can bring very tornados in the form of serious weather. The lifestyle of the Bahamas is a mix of Africa and Western impacts.

Will Petra
Will Petra

Need to fire all these scummy overpaid idiots.

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

The Coast Guard registry defines this ship as a "yacht"..period. Well, not quite..this news item comes out as we discover the Los Angeles School Board is about to vote (this coming week) on the proposal to cut ALL Adult Education funding (closing much needed schools like Harbor Occupational Center), Early Development (aka pre-school), after-school programs for K-12 and any number of other programs, like art, music, trade classes, some sports, etc.! This is absolutely unconscionable! These adult schools alone (which also allow high school students to access training outside their regular classes) serve thousands who, in these times especially, need access to affordable training and re-training in employable skills! A considerable staff of excellent, caring teachers and support personnel will also be displaced if this happens! Yet, they can find enough to pay for captain, crew and maintenance (diesel fuel isn't cheap) and a three quarter million upgrade of this yacht! It doesn't make a difference which "pocket" the money comes from..budgets can be re-adjusted! If "visiting firemen" coming to the city need a tour, then take them out on one of the harbor's fireboats or tugs.."boats" that actually do perform other needed services!  Well, what do we expect from a city administration that justified not only paying the previous L.A. School Superintendent $300K a year, but increased it by $50,000, upon the promotion of the former Deputy Superintendent when he assumed that post! That's almost two teachers' salaries! Please..everyone deluge the school board, your councilperson and anyone else you can think of with emails and calls to stop this travesty! Show up at the school board meetings, if you can! We can't let this happen!

Wilmington Native
Wilmington Native

If you, SanPedroGal, know so much about your port, perhaps you also know that money earned/gained there cannot be spent outside of the Tidelands, which is state-entrusted property.  The city cannot transfer money from the port to the school district. The port, however, provides a service to educators by allowing the Angelina to be used for field trips so kids can see what goes on around them.

Your earlier suggestion about using a tug or fireboat for tours really demonstrates your ignorance.  Obviously you've never been on a tug.  And, secondly, if I was one of the port tenants that pays for the fire services via my lease, I'd be outraged that a fireboat was temporarily out of service for fire protection because it was being used for a tour.

Rich Knudsen
Rich Knudsen

Be serious here people, Its L.A. Every Ill thought out, lame brain, hare brained idea in the world has passed through the halls of this local via Hollywood. One question; Does it have its own escorts and greeters from the Hefner mansion too?

HoundOfDoom
HoundOfDoom

He's not a mayor, he's a douche bag. 

Larry
Larry

They can't pay for the schools, cops, or fireman but thay have a damn boat?

Anyone that votes to raise taxes on yurself is a fool!

Mark my words if this was a GOP Mayor this WOULD be a yacht, but since it is a poor little old dem, it's only a boat.

Quack, Quack, Quack, sounds like a duck, but is really a weasel.

BTW it didn't need new engines, they were replaced to be more GREEN! 

NurseSnow
NurseSnow

Sorry...it's a yacht.  Sell it and contract with a yacht owner who could use the extra income for each event.  It would probably be more upscale for all this facy promotion going on.

Censored Again
Censored Again

They got a $500,000 federal grant to fund the repairs. It's easily verifiable. My first comment stating this-- noting the source and providing the entire sentence the author chopped up and quoted got silenced by the moderator-- who is-- and why? I guess one of the rules of LA-Weakly moderating is-- "Don't let facts get in the way of a "bash" story."

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

Actually, the funds came from a federal grant to the city of approximately $1.5 million, to advance port development and the jobs that should come with it! As a port-area resident, that's desperately needed money..and considering that the same services (ferrying "visiting firemen" around the port to encourage investment, student group tours and any other legitimate function) could just as readily be provided by co-opting a harbor fireboat or a tug..I'd say they really made very poor use of an entire third of that grant, here! Considering the retrofit is just part of the cost associated with this yacht (so classified by the Coast Guard) and the city pays the tab on the rest, this is a true extravagance! Given that LAUSD is due to meet next week to vote on terminating ALL adult education, pre-school, K-12 after-school programs, music, art, trades and some sports programs, such an expenditure is an outrage! For that matter, providing funding to keep Harbor Occupational Center running (a well-used educational center across the street from the port, that assists hundreds of economically displaced adults and high schoolers, through training in skills and trades that can qualify them for jobs at the port and elsewhere), would be a far more productive use of port development funds than new engines for this yacht! No..in these times, this "boat" is a luxury item, not a business development "need". The city needs to take it's own advice..and "sacrifice", themselves!               

I Aim to Misbehave
I Aim to Misbehave

The fact that federal taxpayer dollars may have been spent makes this ok?  That's worse if it's true!

Jim
Jim

Hi Tcurry2, and others, The Port of Los Angeles is not your stereotypical city government entity.  This is a WORLD PORT. If you would like the port to do-away with the Marketing Department, overseas business building missions, and the Angelena II "Yacht", then welcome the Port and City into 3rd World status. The Port and it's marketing activities is geared for making money, and insuring trade and commerce flow through this area now and forever!  Get on the boat!

Janaharley
Janaharley

This is an unjustifiable expense in light of current economic conditions! Every time teachers are laid off or programs cut, we are reminded that we "must all sacrifice"! Well..back at ya! There is absolutely no reason why this YACHT (so classified in the Coast Guard Registry) should not be sold off and the "visiting firemen" taken out on a fireboat or tug! That is..unless the real purpose of such tours is NOT to give them a view the port, but to enjoy a nice Merlot, some Brie and the ocean breeze!  Give me a break!  

Tcurry2
Tcurry2

This stinks.  I am sure this is used for political gain by our Los Angeles Politicians.They could rent a yacht for a day much cheaper to tour people if it was truly to promote trade.  Another abuse of the taxpayers money.  The Port Authority spent $489,000 of 1.5 million dollar stimulus money given to Los Angeles in 2009 to retrofit this yacht with a "hydro-electric propulsion system".  Villaraigosa says it is not taxpayers money; I have news for him, stimulus money is taxpayers money; cost of maintaining this yacht comes from taxpayers money.  Disgusting. Trudy Curry  

notalib
notalib

This is so typical of a liberal and politicians of both parties.  They love spending OUR money.  Then they try to justify the expense even when the city, county state and country is broke.  I don't know why the people continue to vote these corrupt clowns to positions of responsibility then hands them the check book.

justplainRick
justplainRick

You can put lipstick on a yacht but it's still a yacht. California is broke and there's a good chance they'll come looking for a bailout. They will cry how they have to layoff police and firefighters.  My response would be: sell your frigging yacht first then we'll talk.

Jim
Jim

One last thing.  The Angelena II is tied up on a secured dock, right next to Port Police patrol boats.  There is no slip fee.

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

..And no fuel or maintenance costs..or pay to captains and crew? Ah..but there are..and we're paying for that. 

Sandybunz1
Sandybunz1

Sell that old bucket. It is not worth the money they are spending on it. I had a friend buy one, an old wood boat just like it for $30,000.

Jim
Jim

This whole "yacht" controversy is rediculous.  Here's why:1. David Goldstein initiated this story with the sole intent of boosing ratings for his news show.  Isn't February "sweeps"?  Goldstein is a fabricator and performer.  Not a journalist. 2. The City of LA is lucky to have the Port of Los Angeles and gleen the benefits of being the landlord for the largest most important port in the United States.  You figure the amount of revenue and jobs generated by that.3. Every major port in the world has a boat of its own with which to conduct tours of the harbor.  The Port of LA's is probably the oldest, least expensive to operate, and modest, of any you will find.  Yes, it's 70+ feet long.  So what?  The "free" tours have included business owners and shippers from around the world in the midst of deciding where to conduct their business, as well as students from the LA area, some of whom had never seen the ocean! The "Angelena II" has served thousands of visitors over the years, for a fraction of what it would have cost to send folks to the local tour boat at Ports O' Call Village.  4. Goldstein forgot to mention that the diesel engines are being replaced with brand new electric technology.  The Angelena II will be the first "yacht" of it's kind to be propelled by electric motors!  The new diesel engines operate solely to charge the batteries when needed. This equals "Zero Emissions" most of the time. Federal grants are being used to fund this part.  Geez Goldstein! 5. The Angelena II is a Port of Los Angeles success story, not a black eye.  Everyone wake up, go down to to San Pedro, or Wilmington, see for your selves the size and scale of the Port of Los Angeles.  Be proud!  This is your port!

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

Jim..I live in San Pedro, so don't you dare hand me that! After seeing all your posts, I'm beginning to think you're either the captain of this YACHT or one of the administrative flunkies who regularly goes out for a little trip with these "visiting firemen"! Since you're so "concerned" about the students, then tell me how your rationale isn't full of holes, given that the LAUSD board..for lack of funds..is voting next week to terminate ALL Adult Education and pre-school funding, along with terminating many current programs for K-12 students, including after-school classes, art, music, trade classes and some sports! Those of us who live in this area know perfectly well how important the port is to the economic survival of the entire state! Sorry..no sale! There is NO satisfactory excuse as to why the port can't be viewed from the deck of a fireboat or even a tug! One can certainly be tidied up to provide comfortable accommodations to legitimate guests..and kids can just as readily enjoy the ocean from a fireboat..probably even more fun for them, if they do!

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

By the way, on the whole, I concur that Goldstein is a prat. However, no matter how "creative" his brand of "journalism", the fact remains that the expenditure is there and verifiable..once you know about it. In this economy, one third of the federal grant could have been spent in a more far-reaching and productive way, and the approximately one third of a million the city annually coughs up to maintain this "boat"..emissions-free or not..is, at this time, completely unjustifiable. There are other ways to accomplish their mission..and far greater priorities up the list!

Edwina
Edwina

Politicians are all the same.  If everything was on the up and up, the people of L.A. would never have though that anything was awry, but we seem to have politicians that turn from pumpkins and real people in to Kings and Gods and actually believe that they deserve it all.  And the easiest thing that a politician does is to spend taxpayer money without the slightest hesitation.  This major loves "nice" things that is just the way he is and he will never stop spending outrageously while he's in office and he will always have an excuse!  So, lets see how long he lasts.  If it goes another round and he runs another term.  I think all of the people who vote him in "again" should have counseling, because they really are not well.

Duke Chesnut
Duke Chesnut

Politicians mixed with Yachts equal a storied yacht named "Monkey Business", as former Senator Gary Hart learned so bitterly. Senator John Kerry berthed his Yacht in Rhode Island to avoid Taxes in his home state. Rep. Russ Canahan had similar problems with his old yacht on the Illinois side from Missouri. I wonder if Mayor Villaraigosa has a private plane that taxpayers subsidize, like Air Claire McCaskill?

not as smart as Houston
not as smart as Houston

why not sell it and sign an agreement with a tax paying tour operator to be available when needed.never mind, that makes too much sense.

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

Not a bad idea, but unnecessary. The city and the port authority, itself, already own plenty of craft in the harbor..boats and ships that also serve other purposes. The functions performed by this boat, particularly ferrying business and foreign luminaries around the harbor, along with student groups, etc., could just as readily be done by taking them out on a fireboat or a tug. 

Pprpja
Pprpja

Our mayor is Menino of Massachusetts

Pprpja
Pprpja

Jeeeeze....I thought we were the ones with an idiot for a mayor. Seperated at birth maybe???

Barry Waite
Barry Waite

I've been on that boat twice with business groups and twice with school groups. Calling that thing a yacht is a real stretch. It's very utilitarian and not the least bit the fancy kind of vessel you'd call a yacht. The tour is fascinating by the way and gives an excellent understanding of how the port works and shows the amazing scale of the harbor. This article does not do the educational and public relations value of the boat justice at all. I strongly suggest taking that tour if you ever get the chance.

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

Good..then it won't be a "come-down" if they get rid of this white elephant and tidy up a fireboat or tug when 'visiting firemen" come to town!  This yacht may have been a great idea, WHEN the city had the extra cash to afford it!  Now, when the LAUSD is about to vote next week to terminate all adult education and pre-school programs, along with after-school activites for K-12, and eliminate programs like art, music, trades and some sports, it seems that this is not JUST an extravagance, it's downright criminal!  The city needs to take its own advice..we must ALL "sacrifice" in this tight economy..and it's THEIR turn!

notalib
notalib

 Why not sell it and let private enterprise contract to hire these "important" people around.  The government would not have to pay the upkeep, the insurance, the repairs and on and on.  Private enterprise would pay the huge taxes, upkeep, and then charge for tours---that are needed.  I betcha the number of tours would go way down.  Privatize the operation.  Government can't do anything efficiently. 

Marg224
Marg224

They could have just bought a new yact for a mill 2. But since there broke they shoulf have gotten nothing. Once again the dems and unions rippoff the people. I take the rich repubs at least they buy the boats themselves. Also not stupid enoughto but 1.2 mill in a boat worth at best 100000.

Michaelm
Michaelm

Maybe they can rent it out and Shoot & PROMOTE porn movies made with Mandatory  RUBBERS !

guest
guest

Port "generate its own profits".  Public relations are necessary to generate those profits.

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

..And that can be done from the deck of a fireboat or tug, just as easily as this white elephant "boat"..classified, by the way, as a "yacht" by the Coast Guard.

C. Houston
C. Houston

I'm aghast to see a comment like "And the port says 'installation and repair work is being done by city workers, including electricians, carpenters and others.' (Essentially the most expensive labor force that taxes can buy.)"

Are we going to see Newt Gingrich campaign ads next?  What's wrong with this author and the editors?

I work for a different city and assure you that city workers are hardly the most expensive labor force that taxes can buy.  When we consider the tax-funded bail out money "rewarded" to the criminals who broke Wall Street, we might say they're a far better example of the "most expensive labor force that taxes can buy."

Cities across the county lost millions of reserve dollars in a stock market that took risks that were so unsupportable that they had to hedge against themselves.  As a result, city workers everywhere have paid a much higher share of their benefits.

I am college educated and have the expertise that allows me to help my city avoid millions of dollars in fines every year.  My salary has been stagnant for the past nine years.  I work hard to keep my job because the job market is competitive.  And I get a measure of fulfillment in doing an excellent job for a city I live in.

None of the sensational articles, not the original scoop or the piggy backers like this one, mention how much it costs to operate this vessel each year.  I imagine that's because the numbers will show that it's less expensive to own than rent.

SanPedroGal
SanPedroGal

They pay for a full-time captain and crew..and that and the regular "maintenance" costs the city close to a half million a year. You can bet that the "guests" aren't just eating chips and drinking soda, either..especially those "visiting firemen" from companies and other countries!

Mike
Mike

You are dillusional!! UNION LABOR is the MOST EXPENSIVE LABOR on the planet, pound for pound, trade for trade. What a waste of $$!!

ILIVEINTHEEVILSQUIRREL
ILIVEINTHEEVILSQUIRREL

Mayor can't even join up Kore a Town in the redistricting joke that is currently afoot

Ahoy Mate-y
Ahoy Mate-y

From Shipbuilding Tribune.com  02-07-12

"Since its construction in 1970, the Angelena II had been powered by two 350-horsepower diesel engines that, as of September 2011, no longer met California emissions requirements. While the Port is spending approximately $200,000 for the cost to replace the existing diesel engines (required by the Coast Guard, for back-up power), the Port applied for and received an approximately $500,000 U.S. Department of Energy Efficiency and Conservation Block Grant to upgrade the vessel power system to cleaner technology. Installation and repair work is being done by city workers, including electricians, carpenters and others."

The actual truth of the matter is much clearer.

Marc Reeve
Marc Reeve

the boat (yacht, whatever, it's a tour boat) is older than I am, so no surprise it needs new engines. People are having a cow over the coast of those engines, but a large part of the expense is having to cut a hole into the engine room, take out the old engines, and put in the new engine/motor system (I understand they're making it a biodiesel/electric hybrid drive).You couldn't replace a boat that size for twice what they're paying for the new engines, so I figure they're getting a good deal.

Steven Goodwin
Steven Goodwin

IF it's used properly, this is a great asset and a moneymaker.Otherwise, just a toy

BF
BF

are u an idiot?  the cost sooooo out weighs the value.  a toy for city gov nothing else.

Christopher Neal
Christopher Neal

I'm sure the slip fee for a 73 foot yacht is a pretty penny also. Keeping it clean is expensive, and it probably uses about $300 worth of fuel each time it cruises the harbor. 

Time to send the city council in the footsteps of redevelopment agencies. 

Brian Cromer
Brian Cromer

A couple of comments/suggestions for you: 

Don't refer to Ask.com or Yahoo!Answers as research.  It make you look like an amateur.

If you want to see the difference between yachts and boats compare Angelena II to photos of yachts at www.deltamarine.com or www.lurssen.com.

Stop trying to make a name for yourself by digging up dirt or creating sensationalism out of nothing.  Try doing something productive with your time.  It is easy to be a critic - much harder to have a positive influence on the world.

From the Vault

 

Music

Fashion

General

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city