Top

blog

Stories

 

Parent Trigger: State Lawmakers Ask Attorney General, D.A. to Look Into Possible Fraud at Adelanto School District

Categories: Education

kamala harris underfire.jpg
Can Kamala save the Parent Trigger?
The Adelanto Unified Elementary School District, located a couple hours east of L.A. in tumbleweed country, has a huge and historic decision to make tomorrow.

Either they verify a "Parent Trigger" petition signed by over 50 percent of parents at Desert Trails Elementary, the district's most poorly performing school, to restart the campus under new management -- or they deny it.

If they go for the latter, they might have some angry politicians to deal with:

Gloria Romero, former Senate Majority Leader for the Democrats and co-author of the Parent Trigger law, just announced on a conference call that she has joined in-office Republican senators Bob Huff and Sharon Runner in a plea to both the San Bernardino County District Attorney and the California Attorney General.

Romero says the group of politicians is urging D.A. Michael Ramos to "conduct a swift investigation" into a signature-rescission campaign at Desert Trails that has threatened the success of the radical reform effort.

The Weekly has contacted Senator Runner, who represents the Adelanto area, for confirmation. [Updated at the bottom with her letter to the D.A.]

Senator Huff's office, however, is happy to confirm. Spokesman Bill Bird says the senator has called on both the D.A. and the A.G. to investigate "possible fraudulent activities involved in the petition rescission campaign" in Adelanto.

holly parent trigger tailgate.jpg
LA Weekly
Moms on the Desert Trails Parent Union went door-to-door for months this winter, gathering hundreds of parent signatures.
The Trigger law, authored by Romero and Huff, was "written to empower and protect those who need protection" -- and should not remain vulnerable to "special vested interests" who consistently challenge it, says Romero.

As we learned in the first-ever Trigger attempt in Compton last year, opponents are often backed by district officials (who have a financial stake in each of their campuses) and teachers unions (whose members stand to lose their jobs if new management finds they don't meet higher educational standards).

Parent Revolution, the non-profit organization that has helped guide parents at Desert Trails, again suspects that the California Teachers Association and its local union chapter is behind the drive to unravel this second-ever Trigger petition.

Pat DeTemple -- a director for Parent Revolution -- says parents and lawyers have examined the rescission documents, and has found them "riddled with forgery and fraud."

The ironic part is that the Desert Trails Parent Union, as organizers call themselves, is trying to collaborate with district officials to create a "partnership school." Its board would consist of representatives from the district, parents, outside educational experts and teachers. They'd work together to structure a more successful model for Desert Trails.

Yet opponents are using the same old argument: that Parent Revolution and the Trigger are merely a front for private charter-school operators trying to seize educational capital from the public sector.

"If [district officials] choose to make a decision against us ... they're just in complete violation of our constitutional rights," says Doreen Diaz, a mom on the parent union. "And if our rights can be so blatantly violated, what chance do our children have for their future?"

No one with an interest in turning these kids' lives around as soon as possible wants this to turn into a messy, drawn-out court battle, like it did in Compton.

But there's a large possibility, if history repeats itself, that Adelanto Unified will find another reason to reject the Trigger tomorrow evening.

That's where Superwoman Harris and the San Bernardino D.A. come in.

Rescission campaigns that misinform parents are illegal under the recently passed Trigger regulations -- and the shadiness of this one in particular, including the district's undiscerning OK of apparently fraudulent documents, will hopefully make it a slam-dunk for state regulators, should they choose to accept the challenge.

Update: Here is Senator Runner's letter to the D.A., in full.

Dear District Attorney Ramos:
It has been brought to my attention that there may be due process violations and possible fraudulent behavior with respect to a petition rescission drive targeting parents of students at Desert Trails Elementary School in Adelanto. In January, parents signed a petition to "trigger" changes at Desert Trails. This is their right under Senate Bill X5 4 (Romero, Huff, Alquist, and Wyland, 2009), the bipartisan law that allows parents of a low performing school to petition their local school board to implement specific reform and requiring the school board to do so.
Unfortunately, Desert Trails meets the profile of a low performing school set forth by the Legislature. From all accounts, it appears the petition process followed the law and was presumptively valid; if so, the school board is required by law to implement specific reform.
The law does not by its own terms authorize a revocation process so it would appear that the group hoping to rescind the petitions is operating on a "self-help" basis. While Californians are famous for finding creative solutions to problems, the state operates under the rule of law. I would hope that those who challenge the law would do so in court or through the legislative process. Most disturbing are allegations of coercion.
As the former Assemblywoman representing Adelanto for 8 years, the current Senator representing the 17th Senate District, and the vice chair of the Senate Education Committee, it is my sincere hope that you will give consideration to investigating these charges. Allegations of impropriety and possible criminal conduct should not be ignored. I realize that this is not a typical investigation and may be an appropriate subject for your grand jury.
If you feel your office does not have the means at this time to investigate, please advise. Perhaps, the Secretary of State or the Attorney General would have the resources necessary.

[@simone_electra / swilson@laweekly.com / @LAWeeklyNews]

My Voice Nation Help
4 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
rdsathene
rdsathene

Parent Revolution can deny their ties to ALEC and other reactionaries all they want, but they can't hide the fact that they have had deep and long-standing partnerships with ALEC members, including fringe right-wing The Heartland Institute. In addition to constant collaboration with Heartland, Parent Revolution hosts forums with them. See the following flyer from one of their events and an article discussing it:

http://www.scribd.com/doc/7707...http://rdsathene.blogspot.com/...

The evidence is damning, and their claims that they don't represent right-wing interests ring hollow. Bear in mind Parent Revolution was originally the Los Angeles Parents Union, which was a wholly owned subsidiary of the Green Dot Charter School Corporation. Parent Revolution's sole reason for existence is to build market share for the lucrative charter school sector. This is born out both by the comments of their funders, and by the privatization policies of their funders.

See this piece for a statement by Eli Broad on why he funds Parent Revolution:

http://www.schoolsmatter.info/...

See these documents to see the names right-wing plutocrats who fund Parent Revolution and the staggering amounts they contribute. Tops on the list, the privatization reactionaries at the Walton Family Foundation. 

http://bitly.com/Azv5Bv

For the actual ALEC legislation crafted from Governor Schwartzenegger, Ben Austin, Gloria Romero's original bill, see:

http://www.scribd.com/doc/8361...

To be sure, "school choice" was the clarion call of segregationists. It still is.

http://www.alternet.org/story/...

Carlos Mendoza III
Carlos Mendoza III

Parent Revolution, the nonprofit organization backing the parent trigger petition, needs to apply some common sense here. They had parents sign two different petitions and submitted the least favored one to the board. State Senator Gloria Romero, author of the parent trigger law, initially called their two petition strategy a dubious strategic choice. No wonder parents rescinded their signatures. You only need one petition at the ready to threaten a district to negotiate under the parent trigger law - not two. How does having parents sign two different petitions and submit the least favorite choice a strategy to convince a district to negotiate? I'm in favor of parent empowerment and that argument sounds dubious to me too.http://educatormusing.blogspot.com/20...

George Buzzetti
George Buzzetti

Originally I was against the Parent Trigger Law.  However, considering how obstinate and uncaring many districts are concerning the  welfare of their students, their parents and society in general I support this law as a tool to force educrats to actually do their job.  It is my understanding that the district and CTA have broken the law.  If so, they should pay the price.  If the vote to Trigger that school is proper the parents and community should be allowed to move forward with a proper plan to save the future of their children.  If districts do not care about their children someone must. 

I can guarantee you as a researcher for over 20 years on fraud in schools that it is widespread.  My best friend, Richard Arthur, turned around the most criminal school in the U.S., Castlemont High School in Richmond, California.  That school had gun fights everyday and finally the principal was shot and killed in their office.  After he took over there were no more fights and it went from 5-65% to college in only 4 years.  Do not let anyone tell you it cannot happen.

Caroline Grannan
Caroline Grannan

Speaking of deja vu -- this is just like what Parent Revolution did in Compton, winning big headlines. First they filed charges with the state Board of Ed, accusing teachers of harassment -- big headlines. Then they filed charges with the US Dept of Ed, accusing teachers of civil rights violations -- more big headlines. Then all those charges dropped off the radar and were never heard from again.

How many times do they get to do this stuff and win big headlines?

From the Vault

 

General

Music

Home

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city