Beverly Hills Unified School District Blasts Newest Recommendations for Antonio Villaraigosa's Westside Subway

6921883.28.jpg
L.A. Weekly
Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority staffers have just released final recommendations for L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa's $5.6 billion vanity/legacy project -- variously known as the Westside Subway, the Subway to the Sea, or the Subway to Westwood -- and guess what? Beverly Hills Unified School District attorney Kevin Brogan is throwin' up his dukes and spitting out fightin' words.

"Metro is putting process and politics ahead of substance and safety by recklessly pressing ahead with a so-called 'final' EIR," Brogan said in a press statement today. "Metro's continued reliance on flawed studies and information to justify a more expensive station that benefits politically-connected developers at the expense of everyone else -- including future generations of public schoolchildren -- is unacceptable and will not go unchallenged."

Whoa! Among the recommendations is to place a subway station in Century City at Constellation Boulevard -- or the "center of the center," as L.A. County Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky would term it -- against the wishes of Beverly Hills Unified officials.

So here's the quick back story...

Metro wants to tunnel a subway line under the world famous campus of the Beverly Hills High School, where Brandon and Brenda Walsh of TV's Beverly Hills, 90210 got into all kinds of teenage mischief.

In the real world, Beverly Hills Unified officials are pissed -- they have big plans to modernize the aging school with a multimillion-dollar facelift, and a subway tunnel could possibly put the kibosh on that. Hence, Brogan's fighting words.

L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, however, wants a subway station in the middle of Century City, where the Century City Chamber of Commerce and its deep-pocketed members such as JMB Realty are pushing for a stop.

But you can't have a station at Constellation Boulevard if you don't tunnel underneath Beverly Hills High School.

So now we have a clash of gigantic proportions brewing at the border of Century City and Beverly Hills, which could easily delay Metro's optimistic groundbreaking date of the fall of 2013 and jack up the project's budget.

By the way, along with that pie-in-the-sky start time for construction, you can expect the $5.6 billion price tag to double with cost overruns, transportation experts told L.A. Weekly. A Metro study also cited the eye-popping fact that the subway line would NOT dramatically relieve the Westside's car-packed, gridlocked streets.

Odd, isn't it? And possibly to the tune of $11.2 billion.

"If Metro were really interested in safety and in 'getting it right,'" Brogan added, "it would have waited a few weeks for the results of detailed seismic studies conducted by experts retained by the Beverly Hills Unified School District, which have already identified substantial flaws in Metro's analysis."

The attorney is referring to Metro's controversial study of a fault line near Santa Monica Boulevard in Century City, where Beverly Hills Unified officials want the subway station to be located to avoid tunneling underneath the high school.

It's a big, bloody mess, which L.A. Weekly saw coming months ago in its July 14, 2011, cover story "Beverly Hills Versus the Westside Subway."

Metro's final recommendations, City News Service reports, are now under a 30-day public comment period in which Metro staffers will hold public meetings and get cold, hard stares from Beverly Hills folks.

Villaraigosa, who wants to leave behind some kind of political legacy from his underwhelming eight years as mayor, will stay far and clear of those meet and greets.

But he and his pals on the Metro board, of which the mayor is a member, will review the staff's proposal on April 26. Neither Villaraigosa and the Century City fat cats nor Beverly Hills Unified officials are showing any signs of backing down from a fight.

Contact Patrick Range McDonald at pmcdonald@laweekly.com.

Follow McDonald on Twitter @ https://twitter.com/#!/PRMcDonald and his Facebook page.


My Voice Nation Help
17 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Evan
Evan

We all spend too much time launching opinions back and forth about one another's neighborhoods.  I do not live in Beverly Hills but I work in Century City.  Would I take the Subway to the Sea?  I don't know.  I dothink it's ridiculous to tunnel through methane, oil, and tar to give developers more of an opportunity to sling even more density along an already crowded transit corridor.  Yes, the L.A. Weekly is biased and very Westside-centric, but eventually, even L.A. Weekly makes it to another section of town and reports on something important that is occurring there.

Beverly Hills residents and businesses are taking their opportunity to offer public comments.  It's part of the EIR process that every Angeleno should take part in.  If you are going to ride this subway, even if you do not live in Beverly Hills, you should take part in the dialogue.  If the Rodeo Drive Merchants Association, BHHS, or whoever manages to stop this train -- preferably before breaking ground -- then so be it.  But at the very least have your say.  And, while you are there, leave yourself open to the comments being expressed.

Coco Loco
Coco Loco

Screw Beverly Hills and its stupid high school!They should be begging  for a subway , so all their nannies and housekeepers can make it to work on time ! 

Edward
Edward

It's not a vanity project, Mr. McDonald. It will be a vital piece of our ever expanding mass transportation network. The Weekly's coverage of mass transit is worse than no coverage at all. 

JS310
JS310

Yes, Mr. McDonald, it's "Antonio Villaraigosa's Subway" because ONLY Antonio Villaraigosa is going to ride it. Never mind the 100,000+ other people who will ride it on a daily basis, the countless supporters from all walks of LA life, and the Metro board of directors who have to vote on the project (only 5 of which are nominated by the LA mayor). And never mind that versions of this project have been on the drawing boards for five decades or that, historically, the greatest opposition has come from rich white people with dubious feelings about people of other races and income levels. 

Lovely how the Weekly is taking the side of all those poor, oppressed people in Beverly Hills. As for those "Century City fat cats," what about the secretaries, maintenance people, food service workers, and hospitality workers who will rely on the subway? As for the substance of your post...do LA Weekly writers ever tire of being disingenuous? 

Anonymous
Anonymous

Anyone whohas attended the many community meetings over the last 5 years leading upto the release of the FEIR can tell you that the subway will not prevent BHUSDfrom modernizing its school, including building a multi-level undergroundparking garage.

In acivilized world, BHUSD construction managers would sit down withMetro folks and work out what would go where. And if BHUSD's geologistsand other consultants reports differ from Metro's consultants' reports,they should sit down in a collegial atmosphere, explain their respectiveconcerns, and work it out for the safety of future commuters, students,teachers, parents, etc. Nobody wants to build a subway at the cost of safety;the experts have figured out how to drill through oil, gas, and many othertypes of hazards, both here in LA and around the world in otherearthquake-prone zones. I would like to point out that when there was an8.0 earthquake a few years back in Chile, a day after it hit, the subwaywas ferrying rescue workers throughout Santiago.

Grownupstalk out their issues. It may make for more interesting press orelection fodder to create hysteria instead of learning the facts, but it's atremendous waste of time and energy that could be devoted to dealing with thefact that there will be 3 million more people here in the LA regionover the next 30 years due to internal population growth - and I suspect thatwe will all prefer to ride a subway rather than sitting and stewing in thetraffic above-ground. No, the subway will not 'reduce traffic.' but it willprovide an alternative to the congestion that passes for normal lifein our city.  

Alexander Hollywood-Man
Alexander Hollywood-Man

First off, I'm not surprised to see such a negative article from the anti-transit, biased newspaper called "LA Weekly". The LA Weekly has lost their credibility years ago, due to their leftist, ultra-liberal distorted views, and their one-sided, anti-transit propaganda. Second, the Beverly HIlls' NIMBY's and other rich dummies have no idea that it only makes sense to build a subway station where there's lots of pedestrian traffic, including shopping centers, business districts, and other activity, therefore - guaranteed strong ridership. The Beverly Hills dummies also don't realize that Beverly Hills is not the only city in the world where subway is built under a high-school. And guess what: subways are being built under homes, schools, libraries, and other important buildings in the entire world! So - please, get real, and let's get our city's subway moving forward.

I salute Metro's decision to build the station at Constellation & Ave of the Stars, it's the right place for the subway stop.

Guest
Guest

It's articles like this that explain why L.A.'s mass transit system is so woefully behind every other major city in the world.

jakebraca
jakebraca

LA Weekly, as always, getting its prostate rubbed by Beverly Hills interests instead of what THE PEOPLE want. Compare 8,600 boardings at the Constellation station vs only 5,500 boardings at a Santa Monica station (what BHUSD wants).

Waltarrrrr
Waltarrrrr

I find BHUSD's safety argument completely baffling when you consider they have an active oil well at Beverly Hills High School producing cancer-causing chemicals and contributes to global warming.

Waltarrrrr
Waltarrrrr

Um, the fictional Brandon and Brenda Walsh of TV's Beverly Hills, 90210 went to fictional "WEST Beverly Hills High School." Please make a note of it.

Brent
Brent

Yeah...and BHHS is in 90212, anyway.

JS310
JS310

And why should the fame of a _fictional_ high school have anything to do with the construction of a real subway? (Which will have nearly zero impact on the real BHHS.)

Rich90026
Rich90026

I wonder how many writers for the LA Weekly have ever ridden a bus... maybe if any of them had ever spent time on the 720 they wouldn't be cheerleaders against subways and light rail... 

jack
jack

Agreed.  I used to take the 720 to the westside, like thousands of other Angelenos. (I take the 2 because its more direct from my house to my building).  This line mirrors the subway from Vermont to Westwood.  

This line is PACKED.  Everyday is standing room only.  I then thought, perhaps its my ride, because its a popular time, so when it was packed bus, I waited till the next one.  The next one was also packed.  

Anyone who says "nobody takes public transit in LA" probably doesn't so he/she doesn't so its not a reliable source.  

Ilikethegoodstuff
Ilikethegoodstuff

What are they going to do about the historic tunnels already built underneath the school leading into Century City? We used to ditch school using them...I wonder if they even know those exist! 

drem
drem

what were the tunnels originally used for?and yes they definitely know they exsist

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

General

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city