Top

blog

Stories

 

Did Mark Walter Overpay For The Dodgers? Forbes Puts Value At Just $1.4 Billion

Categories: Sports
Thumbnail image for dodgers sale magic johnson frank mccourt.jpeg
What's $600 million between friends?
Mark Walter and his investment partners, including Magic Johnson, bought the Dodgers on April 30 for $2 billion. That seemed exorbitant, but Walter said that was the price he had to pay for a life-changing opportunity.

"I don't want to realize a return on investment on buying the Dodgers," he told the New York Times.

If that was his goal, he's off to a brilliant start. Forbes today estimates that the Dodgers are worth just $1.4 billion. That's a return on investment of negative 30 percent in just 11 weeks.

Mission accomplished!

Forbes doesn't explain exactly why they think Walter overpaid Frank McCourt by $600 million.

They do note that the owners expect to cash in big-time when the TV contract comes up for renewal. That's true enough, but even with that factored in, the other bidders were not willing to go much beyond $1.5 billion. So either Walter sees value that nobody else can see, or he overpaid.

Presumably he intends to unlock value by developing the parking lots -- though, being from Chicago, perhaps he underestimates just how difficult it can be to build anything in California. He'll also have to split the proceeds with Frank McCourt, who managed to cling to half-ownership of the parking lots in what has to be the greatest real estate deal since Harry Chandler bought up the San Fernando Valley.

Asked to respond to the Forbes estimate, Dodgers spokesman Joe Jareck said, "We have no comment."

Irwin Raij, who advised the buyers on the transaction, did shed some light on the process in an interview with Forbes last week (posted below). Raij said it took his team several months to sort through the whole thing, and the last month was a dead sprint to meet the closing deadline.

"The last two weeks we were working 22 hours a day in a conference room in Los Angeles, barely eating, and trying to enjoy the moment, but really it's stressful," Raij said. "It was a nonstop event. So it was challenging. I will say at the end it was pretty emotional."

Why emotional? Buyers' remorse?

"To be a part of the largest sports transaction in the history of sports, it's something special," Raij said. "It's something my team is proud of, my firm is proud of. We really were emotional."

If their fee was a percentage of the deal, you can see why they would start to well up.

So why $2 billion?

"For us it was based on facts, information we could gather on the franchise, and what we believed the future of the franchise would be," Raij said.

So that clears that up. Watch:



My Voice Nation Help
2 comments
MikeWasHere
MikeWasHere

Although the high price was unique, the financing behind the purchase was not, which is why it is not so important for news organizations, local or not, to delve into the "looming sports disaster to come". There's no cover up here. Everyone knew that all the potential buyers had limited skin in the game and that all of them were bidding largely with other people's money. It's how most professional sports franchises are purchased these days. It's asset buying with leverage, like using margin borrowing at a brokerage bank to purchase additional securities beyond what is bought with one's own limited funds. The principals make some good money if the team fails to generate revenue and the "sports disaster" happens, and they make a lot more if it doesn't. Even if the sales price were lower, it would have been a leveraged purchase of an expensive and iconic asset that doesn't go on sale very often. Thus the premium paid.

Rsandler
Rsandler

Mark Walter does not 'own' the Dodgers.  It is owned by Guggenheim Partners and financed by the insurance premiums of people like you and me.  If you thought McCourt was sketchy... well at least his name was on the owner's box.  Walter, Kasten, Magic, all these assholes are ready to cut and run when this goes south - and it will.  None have enough skin in the game that they can't parachute with hefty salary payouts and a smile. The LA Times won't run a story about what is going on.  The NYT dealbook did the only thing resembling a news story on the purchase of "our beloved hometown franchise."  http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2012/04/09/a-costly-toy-subsidized-by-others/ You can thank Sam Zell for paying off Plaschke, Simers and the rest of those stooges and keeping in LA in the dark about the looming sports business disaster to come. 

From the Vault

 

General

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city