Top

blog

Stories

 

Proposition 32 Union Campaign Contribution Limits: Hitler Endorsed!

Categories: Election 2012

OK, so the late Adolf Hitler hasn't officially endorsed Proposition 32, the ballot measure designed to stop corporations and unions from deducting political contributions from employee paychecks. But based on the flurry of over-the-top attack mailers arriving in the last two days, it's surely only a matter of a time before he joins the party.

First, we were instructed that a "no" vote on Proposition 32 is a vote against high gas prices.

proposition-32-gas-prices.jpg

Then we learned that voting against Proposition 32 is a way to "Stop Wall Street Gouging on Student Loans."

Proposition-32-loans.jpg


But the mailer that took us from feeling vaguely bemused to seriously patronized to was this gem from a coalition of labor organizations, which was written in text message LOLese:

Proposition32-text.jpg

In case you can't read it, here's the exchange, written as if 25-year-old Maria and her fun mom Lynn paused from a day of shopping and manicures long enough to text their clueless friend Andre about the dangers of voting for a proposition to limit certain campaign contributions:

Andre: Can u tell me about Prop 32? What does it mean 4 me?
Maria: Billionaire businessmen will make bank from us
Lynn: Yeah, the sponsors of Prop 32 exempted themselves.
Andre: U mean, they wouldn't even be affected by this???
Lynn: Nope & if Prop 32 passes, our student loan rates will go up and gas will be more expensive!
Maria: If billionaires get their way, we lose.
Andre: That's it. I'm voting NO on 32. Forwarding www.StopSpecialExemptions.org to my friends. Now everybody knows why they should vote No on 32.

It's an after-school special in text-message form!

Unions have spent more than $70 million fighting Proposition 32 for a reason: It's clearly aimed at them. The measure bans corporations, unions, and government contractors from automatically deducting contributions from employee paychecks. But what kind of business takes contributions in that manner? That's how unions raise money; corporations just write a check from their corporate accounts.

So, yes, unions have good reason to fight back. But the focus on exemptions is spurious. All corporations would be banned from such deductions -- making Chevron, for example, subject to the same ban as unions. And noting that billionaires are exempt is stating the obvious. The Supreme Court would never uphold any proposition banning individuals from speaking freely (and expensively) about causes they believe in -- even if those individuals happen to be those much-hate billionaires.

The problem for unions is that Proposition 32 sounds reasonable on its face. Why should anyone be allowed to take part of your paycheck and use it for political contributions without your permission? So rather than stick to the issue, they've decided to claim "our student loan rates will go up and gas will be more expensive." Apparently, because Proposition 32 won't stop gas prices from rising, or reform the student loan problem, it's a no-go -- even though the same could be said about every other proposition on the ballot.

Upon reading the text of Prop 32 further, we realized that it would also fail to stop serial killers. And it does nothing to keep child molesters out of the priesthood or the Boy Scouts. Clearly, it's a vote for murderers and child molesters. We got a text from Lynn explaining that Charles Manson has endorsed Prop 32 for just that reason. Maria and Andre responded with hearty LOLs.


My Voice Nation Help
16 comments
gre84
gre84

The real joke will be when California's prisons are short staffed, when people like me quit, just as crime is skyrocketing due to AB 109. Have fun Calfornia, and enjoy your genetically engineered foods.

LeeVC
LeeVC

So who are you Voting for?  You gonna Rock The Vote or not ?

Juvenal451
Juvenal451

Hitler was in fact a vegetarian.  It is clear to me that he would have endorsed Prop 37...

HorribleBusinesses
HorribleBusinesses

Once upon a time mean corporations ran the State of California. US Steel, GM and other companies had assembly plants here. Roads were good, taxes low, schools very good. Teachers were not allowed to unionize: neither were state employees.  People worked, made money, bought houses and had kids. Criminals were locked up. Schools were run locally.  The LA Times even employed reporters.

 

Then, thankfully, this terrible state of affairs was reversed.  State employees were given the right to unionize in the 70's. Schools went down, and taxes went up.

 

The horrible businesses, with their disgusting profits, pollution, property tax payments, charitable contributions,  and jobs moved away.

 

Now its all better: few can own a home; jobs are harder to find; schools are controlled from somewhere else; teachers cannot be fired.  

 

Juvenal451
Juvenal451

So called political reform that is baised toward one end of the political spectrum is a cynical joke. No on 32.

cypherpu
cypherpu

By the way, check out "Big Money Talks - Californias Billion Dollar Club" by the California Fair Political Practices Commission. The California Teacher's Association outspends Chevron, ATT, and Philip Morris *COMBINED*.

 

Don't believe me, google the PDF.

Juvenal451
Juvenal451

 @cypherpu How much would you spend to remove a cancer from your vocal cords?

cypherpu
cypherpu

I would be laughing if I wasn't already crying about the gullibility of hoi polloi in believing anti-32 propaganda.

 

I guess a quality education for our children, which would result from muzzling the California Teacher's Association, will have to wait for the next election...

Juvenal451
Juvenal451

 @cypherpu Where in the text of Prop 32 is the "shareholder protection" component?  Assuming that you have an IRA, has ANY Corporation ever asked your permission before converting what could have been dividends to political contributions?

Steph
Steph

The whole point of linking these issues is not about lying, but showing the real possibilities for the 99% if billionaires and large corporations get their way. Most union members do already *choose* to donate money to the political work that their organizations do. This prop would not allow them make that choice to pool their money to have a say in the things that matter to working families. Corporations don't take money from employee's paychecks because they don't need to. I'm all for campaign finance reform, but not for this--it's as if it were a game of football and one team were not able to even get on the field to play. 

allykatty1
allykatty1

@Steph I'm currently independent and undecided myself, but it's inaccurate to say most union members already donate to the same political work. If you look up the stats, about 90% of union political contributions go to Democratic candidates, while 40% of union membership is Republican. Doesn't seem fair to me. In addition, when looking at the Top Ten corporations to donate, their contributions are pretty evenly split between both parties, so I don't see why they are such a concern.

Brandon Silverman
Brandon Silverman

NO ON 32. Corporations already outspend unions in campaign and superPAC donations as it is. If we don't allow the workers' voice in politics, we are even more screwed.

Kata Kimbe
Kata Kimbe

So ridiculous. They are clearly afraid to lose their ability to spend union members money on campaigns from here on out... how many millions have they spent this season?

simondelao
simondelao

Hey, Good people need to fight lies with even bigger lies. Fuck the Koch Brothers. I am beginning to realize that YES the ends do justify the means.

inverness46
inverness46

 @simondelao Why, Simon? What have the Koch bros. done to you? Be specific. Unlike Democrat kingpin contributors such as George Soros, who made billions speculating on global financial markets - i.e., creating nothing and getting filthy rich doing it - the Kochs actually make things. They produce energy, minerals, and manufactured goods. They compete on global markets with products that people voluntarily purchase because owning and consuming those products make their lives better.

 

Before you suggest the ends justify the means, as if they ever do, you ought to at least examine your premises. Do you actually have any real beef with the Kochs, other than the fact that they're wealthy and you've been instructed to hate them?

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

General

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city