Top

blog

Stories

 

Bicyclist Killed By Car Door In Hollywood

Categories: Accidents

blue bike StyleSpotting law flickr.JPG
StyleSpotting / Flickr
Bicyclists call it getting doored.

And in this case, it was deadly. Los Angeles police last night said a 49-year-old bicyclist died after a BMW driver opened her door as he rode in a bike lane, striking the rider and ending his two-wheeled journey forever.

It happened ...


... about 6:30 p.m. March 3 on Vine Street near Banner Avenue in Hollywood, according to the LAPD.


View Larger Map

Cops appear to blame the 26-year-old driver of a BMW 328i for the "opening of a car door when unsafe," according to the department's statement:

... A 49-year-old male resident of Los Angeles was riding his bicycle southbound on Vine Street in the bicycle lane and collided with the motorist's door. The collision caused the bicyclist to be thrown from the bicycle and land in the roadway.

The victim was hospitalized and held on until March 8 when he died, cops said.

Detectives are still looking for possible witnesses: 213-473-0234.

[@dennisjromero / djromero@laweekly.com / @LAWeeklyNews]

My Voice Nation Help
82 comments
esthetic1
esthetic1

@Cris Paul Tsch  "The League of American Wheelmen was formed in 1880, as a powerful voice for bicycling. The League was successful in lobbying to improve and pave roads to make them passable and smooth in all weather. The League of American Wheelmen exists today, now called The League of American Bicyclists. 

Bicycling became the rage in Europe and in the US in the 1890s. There are estimates of 10 million bicycles in use in the US by the 1890s, this in a population of 75 million. A new vehicle known as the horseless carriage began appearing on the paved roads that bicyclists had lobbied to create. In another twist of fate, bicycle mechanics J. Frank and Charles E. Duryea of Springfield, Massachusetts, had designed the first successful American gasoline automobile in 1893. They went on to make the first sale of an American-made gasoline car in 1896. The car really emerged as America's vehicle of choice when Henry Ford introduced the Model T in 1908."

In summary: The paved roads was 1st created and lobbied by BICYCLISTS in 1880. Then automobiles was invented in 1896 and along come Ford model 1908, which then took over the roads that belong originally to bicyclists. So who came first, the chicken or the eggs? Under the vehicle code law, cars are supposed to share the roads with bicyclists. LAPD watch videos on biking laws & rules of the road while in training to become a cop. They know that bikes are allowed on the road and when there is insufficient road, the bicyclists can take the whole lane to themselves.

SOURCE: http://www.history-magazine.com/bicycles.html

explo1ted
explo1ted

Holy excuses.  What happened to just plain paying attention when you are responsible for an automobile on the road, and looking before you do something?

LAPhoto
LAPhoto

I won't ride in bike lanes for that very reason, too narrow. Sharrows are a better, cheaper, and safer alternative. Driver education is the cheapest and most effective way to stop this from happening. In Amsterdam, drivers are trained to use their right hands to open their car doors. This automatically tuns the driver's head and allows them to see if a cyclist is riding next to them on the street. It works.

andreihp42
andreihp42 topcommenter like.author.displayName 1 Like

In Europe cars give bicyclists a wide berth. 

If she was the one who caused the tragedy because of her carelessness, she should pay dearly. 

bike_rider
bike_rider

that "bike lane" is such a joke on vine. its just the road where cars travel except every quarter mile has a bike logo painted on the pavement. drivers dont know its a bike lane. so stupid and such a waste of money.

that being said, this situation is the result of a dumb bitch not checking her mirror before opening her door, she is at fault and should pay one way or another. what a shitty way to go out.

abramsrl
abramsrl like.author.displayName 1 Like

In 1915, Los Angeles conducted a traffic study and one of its main conclusions was that different modes of transportation were incompatible and needed to be separated from each other.  The most lethal danger was street car system which had an unacceptable high injury and death rate and seriously interfered with the flow of traffic.

Bicycles are also incompatible with autos, and Bike Lane make the streets more dangerous for Bikers. Bike Lane do not separate bikes from cars and trucks, but instead mandates they they occupy essentially the same space. Los Angeles has had almost 100 years to address this problem, but it has not.  The main obstacle is that developers felt that the room to create truly separate bike lanes would require City right of way easements that would encroach too much on their property and besides dead cyclists were not their problem.

Psychologists have established that drivers can look directly at both motorcycles and at bicycles and NOT see them.  The mind tends to screen out irrelevant information and people who are looking for cars often do not receive a motorcycle or bike.  Fortunately, bikes make a noise, but bicycles do not.

The personal injury and deaths claims should be brought against The City as it created the unreasonably dangerous situation of Bike Lane and lured cyclists to use Bike Lane.

The facts of this case are not presented in sufficient detail.  Since the bicyclist died, it is likely there was a lot of momentum which means the cyclist was traveling at a high rate of speed.  From this we may conclude, that the bicyclist was a considerable distance behind the motorist.  Thus, when the driver turned around to see if anything was approaching, the bicycle was too far back for him to see, (assuming he took the time to look).  This raises the likelihood that the bicyclists was exceeding the Basic Speed Law VC 22350 and the cyclist may be solely liable for his own death.


andreihp42
andreihp42 topcommenter

@abramsrl your siting a 100 year old study? awesome. not practical, but awesome

abramsrl
abramsrl

@andreihp42@abramsrl@andreihp42 @abramsrl Math has not changed in 100 years.  The 1915 Study researched the mathematics of subways as to size, speed, passenger capacity, the distance that pedestrians will walk to use a subway.  The math will be the same in 2215. 

The geography of a city is crucial to its roadways and its subways.  The geography of LA has not changed.  We are still a huge circular area which cannot mathematically be served by a fix-rail transit system whether it is below ground (subway), on the surface (trolleys) or in the sky (mon-rail).

Nor have the finances changed.  All transportation systems have costs associated with their operation.

However, America has become a nation of ignorant KnowNothings, Americans do not want to learn basic math, geography or finances since mindless slogans are easier.


abramsrl
abramsrl

@andreihp42Rather than glibly shooting from the hip, why not take the time to actually do some studying and see that the basic research from 1915 is valid today.  http://bit.ly/cJh5BP


andreihp42
andreihp42 topcommenter

@abramsrl @andreihp42 lol, you're kidding right? EVERYTHING has changed in 100 years. population, size of subway cars, locations of where people live and work. all of that changes the equations. Not sure how you missed that. But your post seems kind of angry so maybe it's hard to see past all that red? ;)  btw, i'm just teasing you, you go ahead an quote studies from 100 years ago, it's quaint.

Anema91
Anema91

@abramsrl don't over analyze it, the cyclist just happened to be an old man. Regardless of speed, the trauma he received on his head would have been fatal either way.


abramsrl
abramsrl like.author.displayName 1 Like

@Anema91 @abramsrl Don't over analyze it?  I see another member of the KnowNothing klan has spoken up.  "Old man"  The article said he was 49.  Old at 49?  

"Regardless of speed"?  Really. So an accident at 1 mph has the same impact as an accident at 35 mph?  You probably never heard of Momentum.

Cris Paul Tsch
Cris Paul Tsch

I totally agree Larry! I cant tell you how many times bicyclist have flipped back my passenger side mirrors while i was at a red light for no god damn reason and they would never fix it but have the audacity to get pissy. Sometimes even bang on my car! Additionally, some people dont know how to drive that well and get stuck behind someone riding their bike then creating a bottle neck of slow moving traffic. It's ridiculous!

Cris Paul Tsch
Cris Paul Tsch

Roads were made for vehicles!!

dogtown1971
dogtown1971

@Cris Paul Tsch Actually roads were here before cars, as were bikes

esthetic1
esthetic1

@Cris Paul Tsch "The League of American Wheelmen was formed in 1880, as a powerful voice for bicycling. The League was successful in lobbying to improve and pave roads to make them passable and smooth in all weather. The League of American Wheelmen exists today, now called The League of American Bicyclists. 


Bicycling became the rage in Europe and in the US in the 1890s. There are estimates of 10 million bicycles in use in the US by the 1890s, this in a population of 75 million. A new vehicle known as the horseless carriage began appearing on the paved roads that bicyclists had lobbied to create. In another twist of fate, bicycle mechanics J. Frank and Charles E. Duryea of Springfield, Massachusetts, had designed the first successful American gasoline automobile in 1893. They went on to make the first sale of an American-made gasoline car in 1896. The car really emerged as America's vehicle of choice when Henry Ford introduced the Model T in 1908."

In summary: The paved roads was 1st created and lobbied by BICYCLISTS in 1880. Then automobiles was invented in 1896 and along come Ford model 1908, which then took over the roads that belong originally to bicyclists. So who came first, the chicken or the eggs? Under the vehicle code law, cars are supposed to share the roads with bicyclists. LAPD watch videos on biking laws & rules of the road while in training to become a cop. They know that bikes are allowed on the road and when there is insufficient road, the bicyclists can take the whole lane to themselves.


SOURCE: http://www.history-magazine.com/bicycles.html

princesscowboy
princesscowboy

@Cris Paul Tsch and a bicycle is clearly not a vehicle. Right? Wtf?

andreihp42
andreihp42 topcommenter like.author.displayName 1 Like

@Cris Paul Tsch selfish much?

Larry
Larry like.author.displayName 1 Like

'Opening a car door when unsafe'?  Ever notice how there's a law that can fuck you for basically any thing you do on the road, and that you only hear about once someone wants to splash some blame around?  If they charged the driver with that it means, what, he's going to get a fucking manslaughter charge?  Because that is some complete fucking bullshit.  Cyclists are welcome to do what they want, but the fact is that this city does not have an infrastructure that was designed for their presence in any way.  Hell, this city's infrastructure doesn't accomodate the cars, let alone bikes.  

daydayb
daydayb

@Larry actually a friend impeded the road way with his car door and someone ran into it and tore it off -- and my friend was cited for impeding the right of way -- it was his fault and his insurance paid off the damage to the vehicle that turned into the roadway and struck his door.

roy2k
roy2k like.author.displayName 1 Like

The problem is... most drivers in LA have they head up they ass while driving.

Sean Derrick
Sean Derrick

the problem and responsibilty is the drivers if the bicyclist was traveling within reason. Its scary wether you drive a bicycle or motorcycle. I commuted daily by both and would not been seen constantly and I made the efforts to be as visible as possible.

Bill Truesdell
Bill Truesdell

Happened to me too in LA around '88. I flipped over the handlebars and landed on my back. Just bruised ribs though. Haven't ridden a bike there since.

Larry Larson
Larry Larson

It's true. Bust in my way daring me to hit them. Inferiority complexes.

Lisa Buckland
Lisa Buckland like.author.displayName 1 Like

Cyclists bully cars? That's like saying mice bully elephants.

Larry Larson
Larry Larson

I don't know about this situation, but cyclists try and bully cars like they have some sort of right a way.

andreihp42
andreihp42 topcommenter like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

@Larry Larson they do have the right away, dingaling. you're surrounded by metal!

erudite_ej
erudite_ej like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

This article is written in a really insensitive fashion.  I'm sorry, "striking the rider and ending his two-wheeled journey forever"?  Really?  The author needs to remember that someone had to die for him to be able to write this.  Have a little bit of respect, Dennis.  Cut the cheesiness.  

This is a tragic event and just more proof that LA needs to improve its roadways to keep bicyclists safe and increase awareness of drivers about watching for cyclists.  I'm a bicycle commuter and this has almost happened to me numerous times.  Drivers just don't look.

Chris Allen
Chris Allen like.author.displayName 1 Like

I've had some close calls. When I do have to ride next to parked cars I'm instinctively looking for any passengers inside or someone that looks like they are about to get out. I'm also very wary of cars with someone just sitting there with the lights on and engine running. Never know if they will just suddenly pull out. Be careful out there folks!

dogtown1971
dogtown1971

@Chris Allen I do the same thing on my board, LA drivers are selfish, and disrespectful. I've had people cut me off while looking dead at me, laugh and drive off. I even had a guy cut me off in a crosswalk while I was walking with the signal, get out of his car and try to start a fight with me for pointing out that I was in a crosswalk and had the right of way. LA drivers are just assholes, especially in Hollywood.

Miguel Medina
Miguel Medina

Dan Mar 'danimal' Aguilera becareful out there

Wåřďēll Jåčkśöñ
Wåřďēll Jåčkśöñ

....on the subject of sidewalks.....I was just thinking that you CAN'T ride your bike on the precious sidewalks of Hollywood....maybe now they will change this....sad though

discarted
discarted

@Wåřďēll Jåčkśöñ Actually you can. Look at LAMC 56.16.  My friend's ticket was tossed because of this code.

abramsrl
abramsrl

@Wåřďēll Jåčkśöñ You can ride on the sidewalks in Hollywood except for a few heavy tourist areas.  I know some cops ignore the law and will ticket you and lie about the law -- how else will the city make money unless it preys upon the weak and defenseless?

Martin Pagh Ludvigsen
Martin Pagh Ludvigsen

We need more bike lanes and bikes on the streets of LA. That way car drivers will over time be educated to watch out for common dangers with cars vs bikes, such as opening your car door or doing a right turn. Until then, can everyone reading this please learn to check your mirrors and use your damn turn lights? I've never been anywhere in the world where drivers are so bad at using their turn lights.

dogtown1971
dogtown1971

@Martin Pagh Ludvigsen They just need to stop being self centered assholes, like that will ever happen.


Wåřďēll Jåčkśöñ
Wåřďēll Jåčkśöñ

....Kelsey Rose....SLOW DOWN THEN....i "dislike" it when drivers speed up around me just to slam on the brakes to STOP

Lisa Buckland
Lisa Buckland

Thanks LA Weekly...for putting this out there.

Amandasaurus Rex
Amandasaurus Rex like.author.displayName 1 Like

im sorry but sometimes when i open my door AND check to see if anyone is coming, a bicyclist can still come out of nowhere at a fast speed. IM watching out, they should too if they see a car just parked and the person inside is most likely to exit.

abramsrl
abramsrl

@Amandasaurus Rex  Yes, they can.  Some bikes ride close to the parked cars and that puts them out of the line of sight when a motorist looks backwards.  If the bike is going 25 mph, she can smash into a car door because she could not be seen  when the motorist looked.

Lisa Buckland
Lisa Buckland

@Kelsey...girl, you need a chill pill. Most cities don't allow cyclists to ride on the sidewalk...i.e. it's illegal. Second, we pay taxes for the same infrastructure and governed by the same rights laws that cars are. Is it SOOOO hard to steer your car to the left briefly? Really?

Charles Moses McMahon
Charles Moses McMahon

Tragic. I have been doored before and feel lucky to be alive. Bikers need to be very sharp and aware while biking, but the drivers carry the highest responsibility and need to be in tune with their surroundings. Give bikers a break. While you're sitting in inside your relatively safe crash-tested vehicle with air bags, while your adding smog and carbon emissions to our air, at least have the courtesy of giving these clean riders, who travel without a protective cage, plenty of space. Biking is a wonderful way to get around. I used to commute to school 15 miles each way; it's great exercise, and it's a very clean mode of transportation. I encourage everybody to hop on a bike and be courteous and respectful of bikers while driving.

Víctor Piña
Víctor Piña like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

LA is not equipped for bicyclist and bicyclist need to be educated on their right and responsibilities (Helmet, Lights, Reflective Gear, Rules of the Road like stop at a RED LIGHT ALWAYS)

RichardHorgan
RichardHorgan

@Víctor Piña I'm very late to this story, but shuddering because it is my worst nightmare (as a bicyclist), doubly so because it took place on a street/in an area I frequent all the time. Was the 49-y-o victim wearing a helmet? I'm guessing no.

John Motter
John Motter like.author.displayName 1 Like

It's almost unbearable, adding and extra 10-20 seconds onto a 45 min commute to have to go around a cyclist

Angela Bonilla
Angela Bonilla

My friend's girlfriend died in a biking accident. People need to watch those bike lanes. It only takes a second and you can avoid killing someone.

Joe Varneke
Joe Varneke

Actually Kelsey by law bikes are not suppose to be on the sidewalk.

abramsrl
abramsrl

@Joe Varneke Please identify the law.  The only places where bikes are not supposed to be on the sidewalks are in a few areas of Hollywood which are very heavy with tourists

Destiny Mena
Destiny Mena

its tragic, in this case it was the driver of the cars fault but in many cases byciclist seem to go as fast as they.chose.disregarding surrounding danger. My son was hit by one and ive escaped being hit by a few myself. just the other day i witnesses two bycicles collide into eachother . we have to watch out for cars now.bicycles too.

abramsrl
abramsrl

@Destiny Mena There is too little info to decide who was at fault.  There are sufficient facts to suggest that the bike rider was 100% liable.

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

Home

General

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city