Top

blog

Stories

 

Jorge Mario Bergoglio: Is The New Pope Latino?

Categories: Religion

pope francis wiki.JPG
Updated at the bottom: A UCLA professor weighs in on the question and says yes. First posted at 12:18 p.m.

Perhaps in a nod to its Spanish speaking majority, the Catholic Church today announced that Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina is its new pope.

He will apparently go by the name of Pope Francis I.

So is this guy the church's first Latino pope?

Tough question:


That's like asking if L.A. mayoral candidate Eric Garcetti is Latino (he insists he is, pointing to his family's time in Mexico).

Argentinians are often of pure Italian blood, and Bergoglio's name certainly points to that.

The question is, how do you define Latino? Does a Latino have to have indigenous blood?

time pope francis.JPG
Time

Anyway, the guy speaks Spanish, Italian and German and is, at the least, the first pope from Latin America and the New World.

Orale.

[Update at 12:58 p.m.]: Raul Hinojosa-Ojeda, associate professor at UCLA's Cesar E. Chavez Department of Chicana/o Studies, votes no doubt when it comes to the question of whether Bergoglio should be considered the church's first Latino pope.

"Yes," he says. "We can consider him Latino in various respects."

He says using a test of indigenous blood -- the pope's parents are from Italy -- "would eliminate a large part of Latin America and a lot of Latinos." (Salma Hayek and world's-richest-guy Carlos Slim of Mexico might not be considered Latino if indigenous blood were used as the litmus test).

"More important," Hinojosa-Ojeda says, "is the experience, not the genetic background."

He said the conclave was clearly conscious of Bergoglio's Latin American roots when it elevated him today:

It's part of a zeitgeist. I definitely think that the Vatican and Latin Americans and Latinos in the United States are considering this absolutely a move toward recognizing the importance of Latino Americans and Latinos in the global church.

[@dennisjromero / djromero@laweekly.com / @LAWeeklyNews]


My Voice Nation Help
25 comments
bxutka
bxutka

Latins are spaniards, italians, portuguese, french, romanians and their DIRECT DESCENDANTS ALL OVER THE WORLD... the amerindians, mestizos, and mulatos that get to be latinos in the USA are not only confused about their own roots, but just affected by the typical American ignorance that surrounds them!!! yes americans in general are pretty stupid and ignorant!


I am latin american (not to be mistaken with a chicano from la or a puerto rican from ny or a miami cuban, i am a REAL LATIN AMERICA FROM LATIN AMERICA) and no one even talks about this, neither they do in europe, nor IN asia.... it's only in backwards racial places like america where a topic THIS STUPID would even be discussed!


STUPID TOPICS FOR A STUPID NATION

DISOBEY
DISOBEY

Latin has become a generic term.

Fact: Latins are a tribe at least from 900 bc from Italy they are one of a few tribes who eventually became  The Romans .It is indeed a blood line and  I suppose somewhat of a culture.

In ancient times there was a country or state of some sort called Latium there is today a city called Latina in Italy. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latins_(Italic_tribe) read for yourself

In this day and age if anyone can be called Latin it would be the Italian.

Where you are born does not make you "Latin"  in a literal sense




Groups within the Italian peninsula. Ligures Veneti Etruscans Piceni Umbrians Latins Osci Messapii Greeks

Jersey
Jersey

Hey Bariloche: what you wrote now make alot of sense: "Latino" is such a made-up word, trying to group such diverse people under one US-label is a farce. I visited Buenos Aires last year, and was surprised (though now makes perfect sense) to see Scandinavian-like blond-blue-eyed people everywhere speaking Spanish. Argentina strikes me as a white European country of Spaniards, Northern Europeans, and not the brown native-American faces you see on US television when they talk about Latinos or Hispanics (guess they mean Mexican-Americans?). Guess American TV news will now "have to get with the program" since clearly we've been fed a ton of BS here in the States, and with just a little awareness and research, that concocted "Latino" label doesn't hold up when faced with the reality of Argentina's white European population. And I am guessing that US Mexican-Americans sadly don't know they are mistakenly self-using a label that does not mean anything and in the end does not connect them with anyone or nicely bundle them under a real group. I read that Argentines don't use and don't see merit in such a made-up "Latino" label as they in the end are white Europeans. Quite funny that news outlets aren't reporting on this, kind of scary.

Bariloche
Bariloche like.author.displayName 1 Like

Interesting exchange. Perhaps if the US Educational system and the US Media were a bit more earnest, robust and intellectually comprehensive, the artifice of the "Latino" term now widely and improperly used (solely in the US without any real reflection for what one is actually saying/meaning) likely would cease to exist as it is vapid and meaningless. Recall that said Latino term was invented primarily in the context of the then-discriminated Mexican-American indigent and very AMERI-INDIAN/brown-complexion farmers toiling in US fields; an entirely contrived term that subsequently was quickly adopted by said Mexican-American farmers' nascent academic liberal representatives in the US who attempted to lasso the US political system to somehow gain improved traction for their deplorable farm-hand living conditions. Next: fast-forward 40-to-50 years to the present and a term that was created back then without much thought is today mislabeled by the US Media and moronic politicians on network TV to falsely cover anyone "apparently connected" to the Spanish language and originating from "Latin America"; who today lives with very little real cultural ties to European Spanish heritage. It's a fantastical joke, no wonder Argentines (white Europeans from Spain/Germany/Italy) themselves don't regard the Pope or their fellow citizens as Latino.

daniel
daniel like.author.displayName 1 Like

Definition of Latino: Person of Latin american origin, regardless of race. Includes Mexicans, Bolivians, Chileans, Argentineans, etc. Don’t include spaniards, italians or portuguese (they are latin people, but not latino or latin american).

The definition according to americans: Brown person who speaks spanish. Includes non-white Mexicans and latin americans and other peoples of spanish origin. Include Spanish people from spain if they are ‘brown’
Ex: Antonio Banderas, Penelope Cruz.

First definition: He is latino!.
Second definition: He is not latino!

Unfortunately, because of American ignorance, the second definition prevails.

Realdeal1
Realdeal1

UNBELIEVEABLE HOW UNEDUCATED OUR COUNTRY IS.   HISPANICS SPEAK SPANISH, NOT LATIN.  THE LATIN LANGUAGE ORIGINATED IN ROME, WHICH IS LOCATED IN ITAY.  THE ITALIAN LANGUAGE DERIVED FROM LATIN AS DID SPANISH.  ITALIANS ARE THE ORIGINAL LATINOS.  THEY WERE SPEAKING LATIN LONG BEFORE THE AMERICAS EXISTED. DE NIRO DECAPRIO and CUOMO are half breeds.  I guess, part Latino.  LATINO is not a race.

AS FOR THE MEXICANS, RAZA, and CHICANOS, they are the world's most jealous people.  They can't accept the fact that there are other countries with older and stronger traditions than they have.

Realdeal1
Realdeal1

GET  YOUR HISTORY AND

FACTS STRAIGHT. 

franksangil
franksangil like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

There is NO such thing as a latino or Hispanic RACE!

Fabius
Fabius like.author.displayName 1 Like

The issue is how americans define "Latinos"

I mean if you have an Italian father and a German mother and was born in Iowa, you should be considered "pure American".....

If you  have an Italian father and a German mother and was born in Bolivia, you would be considered a "cucaracha" of course....kkkkk

j_s_marsh
j_s_marsh like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

I'm not quite sure how he is being considered the first Latino pope?  

I guess the real question is what is the definition of "Latino"?  

His parents were Italian immigrants to Argentina, a country that is populated mainly by descendents of European immigrants (Italy, Spain, Germany, etc.) where there are almost no people of Asian or African heritage.

If his parents had immigrated to New York from Italy rather than Buenos Aires, he wouldn't be considered any more Latino than Governor Andrew Cuomo, Leonardo DiCaprio,  or Robert De Niro.

What exactly is the definition of Latino?  Someone who speaks a Latin language (Spanish, Portuguese, French, Romanian)?  Someone of "color" who speaks Spanish? Is is it simply the act of being born in a country from Mexico south?  

Some well known Argentines come from decidedly non "latin" roots such as the last President of Argentina Néstor Kirchner who descended from Swiss and Croatian roots, William Brown the Irish founder of the Argentine Navy, and many of Italian ancestry such as well known athletes Gabriela Sabatini, Lionel Messi, Manu Ginobili.  In fact it is estimated that about 60% of the population of Argentina is primarily of Italian extraction.

I'm actually in Argentina right now and the people here are justifiably proud of his nationality, but nobody here is calling him the first Latino Pope.

What qualifies one to be a "Latino" when in reality, he is an old white guy that DNA-wise is no different than Lee Iacocca.

malaena11
malaena11

@j_s_marsh Hope this helps.  The simplified answer to your question is that it's the cultural upbringing that makes him Latino. Perhaps - considering what you're hearing in Argentina - it would be more suitable to refer to him as the first Latin American pope.  As you've said DNA-wise he may be no different than Lee Iacocca but in his cultural sensibilities he most definately is.  And your example illustrates this point, if his parents had immigrated to the U.S. rather than Argentina then he would be an American of Italian heritage.  We would then be talking about the first American pope vs the first Latin American pope yes?  

orlando.dv8
orlando.dv8 like.author.displayName 1 Like

He is definitely Latin American.

Latino - heh, what does that even mean? If you are Dominican and of pure African ancestry, are you Latino? If you Are Mexican of Zapotec roots are you Latino? Does Latino only imply a Spanish heritage? 

To be honest, the whole question is absurd and insulting. He is Argentinean. Just the same, it would be like someone questioning my Americaness because both my parents are Mexican immigrants. What matters is your culture and experience, not your blood.

superbunny208
superbunny208 like.author.displayName 1 Like

Maybe you should do one of those racial purity tests like hitler did

-paulc-
-paulc- topcommenter

This guy is the furthest thing from being Latino...

luisfern63
luisfern63 like.author.displayName 1 Like

@-paulc- I guess you,like the rest of the Americans,don't  know the concept of being Latino.And  what is a Latino?? a Latino is a person,whose first language is Spanish, A LATIN LANGUAGE,that's the ONLY reason Hispanics are called Latinos,in other words,IT IS A CULTURE,NOT A RACE.IT IS ABOUT TIME AMERICANS OPEN AN ENCYCLOPEDIA AN READ A LITTLE MORE ABOUT THE HISPANIC CULTURE,THANKS!!

chriswiseowl
chriswiseowl like.author.displayName 1 Like

@luisfern63 @-paulc- True, except that Spanish being the OTHER white, Euro-language doesn't really clear things up either....no offense, but there is no indigenous "Latino" language. Those from Spain are from Espana and are Hispanic. 

skullfaceflamenco
skullfaceflamenco

@luisfern63 @-paulc- Italian, French, German, Portuguese, ALL Latin languages. A person whose first language is Spanish, is HISPANIC, not Latin. 

luisfern63
luisfern63

@skullfaceflamenco @-paulc- 

A person whose first language is Spanish is called SPANISH SPEAKING,the only SPANISH PEOPLE ARE THE SPANIARDS THAT IS ANOTHER AMERICAN MISTAKE IT IS THE SAME WAY WE CAN NOT CALLED AN ENGLISH SPEAKING PERSON ''ENGLISH'',THAT TERM IS USED FOR PEOPLE FROM ENGLAND!

luisfern63
luisfern63

@skullfaceflamenco @-paulc- 

Also remember that many Latinos do NOT  speak Spanish.like Cameron Diaz or Emilio Estevez,but their  roots are Latin ( or Latino in Spanish).

luisfern63
luisfern63

@skullfaceflamenco@-paulc-

Sorry,but German is NOT a Latin language,the Latin languages are SPANISH,FRENCH,PORTUGUESE,ITALIAN AND ROMANIAN. A person who is connected to Spain (the original Hispanic country) is called Latin or Hispanic.Remember,the word Hispanic comes from Hispania which is the ORIGINAL name of Spain after the ROMANS  conquered it!

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

General

©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city