Organic Foodies Are Jerks, Study Finds

radishes_opt.jpg
Flickr/ilovebutter
Organic baby radishes from the farmers market
Could organic food give you good health but a bad attitude? A study published May 15 in the journal of Social Psychology and Personality Science says that people who are exposed to organic foods are more likely to have judgmental thoughts and feelings, Fox News reports. (And they should know.)

"There's a line of research showing that when people can pat themselves on the back for their moral behavior, they can become self-righteous," study author Kendall Eskine, assistant psychology professor at Loyola University in New Orleans, told NBC's Today.

"I've noticed a lot of organic foods are marketed with moral terminology, like Honest Tea, and wondered if you exposed people to organic food, if it would make them pat themselves on the back for their moral and environmental choices. I wondered if they would be more altruistic or not," he continued.

The study's 60 participants were split into three groups. One looked at photos of clearly labeled organic foods, such as apples and spinach; another was shown pictures of "comfort" foods like brownies and cookies; and the third group eyeballed photos of non-organic, non-fatty blah foods like rice and oatmeal.

After looking at the photos, the participants were asked how much time they would be willing to give up out of their schedule to help a stranger. They also were presented with vignettes of various scenarios and asked to make a moral judgment.

Those who looked at the organic foods would give up only 13 minutes of their time to help someone in need. The non-organic group gave 19 minutes, and the fatty food group gave up 24 minutes -- almost twice as much time as the organic group. The organic food group also judged moral transgressions significantly more harshly than those who viewed non-organic foods.

Eskine said the results can be attributed to what's called "moral licensing." "That they have permission, or license, to act unethically later on," he told Today. "It's like when you go to the gym and run a few miles and you feel good about yourself, so you eat a candy bar... There's something about being exposed to organic food that made them feel better about themselves. And that made them kind of jerks a little bit, I guess."

Eskine says he was surprised by the findings: "You'd think eating organic would make you feel elevated and want to pay it forward."

So the next time you go to the farmers market, remember to be nice to the little people.


Want more Squid Ink? Follow us on Twitter or like us on Facebook, and follow Samantha Bonar at @samanthabonar.

My Voice Nation Help
21 comments
anakrony
anakrony

And where is the control group?

Carly DeFilippo
Carly DeFilippo

I'm sorry, but this is ridiculous. Maybe show people pictures of an organic brownie vs. a non-organic brownie and then get back to us. An apple does not give someone the same warm, fuzzy feeling as chocolate - regardless of how it was grown.

Wayfaring Pilgrim
Wayfaring Pilgrim

You were probably wearing some item of clothing (shoes, belt) made of leather.  Had you ridden up on your hipster fixie bicycle wearing your hemp t-shirt and sisal sandals, they would have acknowledged your royal presence.

Del Martinis
Del Martinis

LOL!  Just walking in tennies.. shorts and t-shirts!  Maybe it was the McDonald's logo on my shirt! 

Del
Del

Maybe our experience was isolated, but since we're on the topic...after spending a day in the park, we happened upon an organic farmer's market set up in the parking lot.  We checked it out but apparently it wasn't open yet.  Not one of the hipster looking workers behind the counters, who were talking among themselves, even stopped once to acknowledge us. Made me wonder how is it possible to be so rude among all this "honest" produce!

LouisL.
LouisL.

Are you people writing this with a straight face?  Does this matter in the scheme of existence, and what we need to focus on to create a better quality of life on this planet.  All that matters is the well-documented science that pesticides are destroying us and the Earth itself.  Who's editing you?

John Kenny
John Kenny

MANY, MANY "organic, bike-lane, Prius assholes" are indeed arrogant as HELL, just because they eat some damn food, or ride a bike, or drive their stupid hybrid (which will require dumping their horrific batteries at some point, btw).  They are also some of the most stingy bastages on earth, too.  Just look at the charity giving of Republicans vs. DemonCraps.  Republicans beat their ASSES hands down.  Liberal scum, you make me sick.

Womanphoenix
Womanphoenix

Wow, some jerkishness coming from a nice polite Republican, eh?

Stan
Stan

Other studies also show that organic food doesn't necessarily have a higher nutritional value than similar non-organic products.  You know, feces came from an organism.  If I poop on a bowl of salad, it must be "organic."  E-Coli is technically "organic," too.

emberglance
emberglance

The point is, Stan, that it's not sprayed with chemical fertilizers or, in the case of animals, pumped full of hormones and antibiotics.  The nutritional value of a fruit or vegetable depends on the quality of the soil and organic farmers do try to restore the nutrients in the soil and this should give the food higher nutritional value in the long run (and make the soil more naturally fertile).

drem
drem

60 people in New Orleans makes a "study?" 

Stan
Stan

60 people who all live within 1.5 miles of a Whole Foods.  Sounds like a /beginsarcasm great study with a broad sampling of the population transcending all socio-economic barriers /endsarcasm.  

myrtlebrown
myrtlebrown

Very true that major brands do give out samples on their products, search online for "Official Samples" we just got ours today. You wont need CC. 

Sea Horse
Sea Horse

This is too stupid to be republished by anyone.  Assistant professor trying to gain points and tenure.  Shows how bad the educational system has become.  You thought you'd have to worry about Elementary but this is College; poor kids just don't have a chance.  Wait a minute  he probably works for Monsanto

JordanvonTrapp
JordanvonTrapp

Oh dear... What about the subgroup to which I belong; the organic foodie whose mission it is to encourage everybody that going organic doesn't have to put you into a self-righteous clique, rather it can be attainable and extremely fulfilling for most...even if you are a self-proclaimed tomato killer and have only but a window box-worth of space! www.saucyvermont.com

Justinvanleeuwen
Justinvanleeuwen

Dumb...No surprise this would come from Fox News...What about people who eat organic food because 'conventional' food is full of harmful shit. I'm not looking to pat myself on the back - I just want ACTUAL FOOD!! Imagine that...

ivorytowervertigo
ivorytowervertigo

This is the exact response i'd(and also the study this article sites) expect from an "organic food" consumer.

Postingmodern
Postingmodern

No where are they saying that correlation equals causality, nor do I think they'd want to, but it sure is an interesting study which deserves to be expanded upon. 

emberglance
emberglance

This is a cretinous article.  When I see an organic product labelled "Honest Tea" - beyond the bad pun - I understand that the product is claiming not to have hidden ingredients which I wouldn't want to ingest.  Not that it's saying I'm an honest person if I buy it!  And how can looking at a picture of some organic spinach affect my moral decisions afterwards?  I haven't bought it or chosen to eat it.  I haven't made any kind of lifestyle decision.  

This is what you get when you go to Fox News for stories to crib.

From the Vault

 

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city