Why Do Musicians Hate America? The 5 Worst Songs With "American" in the Title

flag.jpg
Oh, United States Of America. We love you, we really do. Hell, we live here, so we kind of have to. We show our love through the composition of endless tributes to the land, the people and the country itself. Clarification: we do this by shamelessly co-opting the entire continental Western Hemisphere for use as our identifying adjective, "American." (So take that, Canada, Latin America and anything written about Amerigo Vespucci!)

Think about it: Americana, American-Made, American Dream. Has there ever been a country so awesome at turning itself into an all-purpose adjective*? If there is, you can bet we'll shove our American boot up its ass. And leading the charge, as always, will be the countless musicians who discovered long ago that nothing makes a song really pop like putting "American" in the title. There's just one catch. A lot of people writing these songs kind of suck. Large.

Why do they hate America? We don't know, but they sure love to show it by writing truly awful songs about it. This weekend, when we're celebrating the nation's birthday, let's take a moment and pour one out for the forgotten victims, the people forced to listen to such awful music. Here are The 5 Worst Songs With "American" in the Title:

5) "American Idiot" by Green Day

Yeah, we said it. This song blows.

You know how infuriating it is when politicians go to Washington and, despite the fact they basically won your vote by pretending to actually understand that the two major political factions are enemies with one another, the second they take office they do stupid crap like playing golf with John Boehner? It's like that in music as well. Which is how Green Day went from Oakland gutter punks to Rock royalty and now make music about as edgy as James Blunt.

Like most bands finding themselves in that position, Green Day realized they needed to keep it real again, and quick, so in 2004 they released their hugely successful concept album American Idiot. And admittedly, it's not a terrible album, in the same way that Pizza Hut's pizza isn't terrible either, so long as you pretend you don't live near Casa Bianca. It also does a fine job of skewering America under Bush. But it has some real clunkers, like "Boulevard of Broken Dreams," a song that basically re-writes "Wonderwall" by Oasis and "Dream On" by Aerosmith.

But it's the title track that really makes you want to die inside. It's supposed to be a return to punk rock rage, but you know what? It just sounds like "What I Like About You."

4) "American Badass" by Kid Rock

Kid Rock sucks. And American Badass is possibly his worst song. A combination of in your face IMMAKICKYERASS jerkassness and swagger so self-conscious it sounds like Drakkar Noir, this song is everything that sucks about American Patriotism and everything that sucks about American Dudebros. It's like being date raped and bombed for your oil at the same time. And that's just during the intro. When he starts listing off the music he likes and you, the listener, realize you like a lot of it, too, it's the final death of the idea that having good taste makes you a cool person. Kid Rock likes Run DMC? Fine, I give up. From now on, I'm a Kid 'n Play fan***.

3) "We're An American Band" by Grand Funk Railroad

This is what an American Band sounds like? God, it all makes sense now. This song is conclusive proof that the terrorists don't hate us for our freedom, they hate us for our music.

2) "American Soldier" by Toby Keith

We're not sure there's anything worse than starting a war based on blatant lies, then sending young men and women to die for the vanity of elderly assholes who would rather bleed this country dry than actually part with a a single dime at tax time. But if there is, it's the songs celebrating the sacrifices of the people sent to die in those wars, written by people who themselves would never join the military.

And coming in at number one (like you'll find this surprising) ...


My Voice Nation Help
6 comments
guest
guest

Yes.....GenXrs and Millenials are SO concerned about others....reflected in the lovely music put out by the likes of Lady Gaga, Katy Perry, Pitbull, Rhianna, etc. etc.   I'd like to see any of them write a song with meaning and depth like American Pie. 

purplepenquin
purplepenquin

While I was appalled that you included "We're an American Band" on this list, the video that you linked to more than makes up for it. 

NM Dog Lover
NM Dog Lover

Wow.  I think you need to get your hearing aid checked, Dad.  Green Day's "American Idiot" is an eloquent and passionate commentary of a nation's frustration with Bush, bigotry, and war.  Comparing it to Pizza Hut?  Yikes.  

And 'The greatest crime of "American Pie" might just be the codification of the baby boom's self-obsession.'     Again, wow.  I bet you stayed up all night to come up with a phrase so full of absolute nonsense.  "Baby boom's self-obsession"?  Of course, boomers are the ONLY generation to be self-obsessed, right?  Moron.

I'm embarrassed to be from L.A. when wanna-be-hipper-than-thou music "commentators" spout such drivel.  I guess you're part of the ignoranti who believe they're edgy by criticizing iconic songs when it really just reveals their sad desire to be fashionable.  But then, as I recall, L.A. always thought it knew everything, when it was actually San Francisco that did.  Get another job -- I think pizza delivery guy is about right -- you sure suck at this one.

Brett Hampton
Brett Hampton

I'll have to disagree on Grand Funk Railroad and Don McLean.  But you're spot on for the other ones.  Oh - and are we just supposed to forget the Big Bopper died in that crash, the way everybody wants to call Ryan Dunn's alcohol-fueled suicide run a "tragedy" while igonring the fact that the same act also made him  a murderer?

Kevin T. Keith
Kevin T. Keith

"Show of hands if you actually think The Big Bopper is actually good enough to be considered in the same category as Holly and Valens."

Well, if the category is "Killed in the Plane Crash That Defined 'The Day the Music Died'", then, yes. Christ, they were all touring together, and they fucking died together. At least mention his name. And a shout-out to the pilot who killed them wouldn't hurt. Oh, and then there's Waylon Jennings and Tommy Allsup, who were supposed to fly on the same plane but gave up their seats to the others, thus earning themselves a place in the category "Were With Buddy Holly, Richie Valens, and the Big Bopper on the Day the Music Died but Didn't All Necessarily Die".

Ross Lincoln
Ross Lincoln

It's true also that TBB was an enormously influential DJ and in that capacity his contributions are immeasurable. I admit I was slightly trolling.

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

Clubs

Los Angeles Event Tickets
©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city