Why This Song Sucks: Gotye's "Somebody That I Used To Know," featuring Kimbra

[Editor's note: Why This Song Sucks determines why particular tracks blow using science. It appears on West Coast Sound every Wednesday.]

See also:
*Gotye Tells Us His Life Story
*The Worst of Coachella: Weekend One

Song: Gotye's "Somebody That I Used To Know," featuring Kimbra

History: "Somebody That I Used To Know" is a song that people LOVE. Like, I mean A LOT. It's mostly White people. I think Gotye might be White Tupac, but I'm not certain. Also, I think we're all just supposed to pretend that Damien Rice wasn't doing this bit about 40X better already. It's probably because Gotye is from Australia and Rice is from Ireland and Australia is considerably more hipster-chic than Ireland. I mean, did you even see Crocodile Dundee? It's the most post-meta movie ever made. LULZ. ALT. <3 <3 #LOOKATMYJORTS MEME meme meme MEME

Gotye8.jpg
It's warm in Hipster Australia but whatevs, bro, that scarf is eco-friendly and really breathable.
Atmospherics: Slo-mo brooding; itchy bass; narcoleptic-turned-WAHWAHAH vocals. It starts out okay enough, then turns into four minutes of Gotye making sad faces and saying that his ex-girlfriend hurt his feelings because she didn't want to lay in the flowers at the park with him anymore or something.

Scientific Analysis: Look, Gotye, I get it: Breaking up sucks. But, dude, you're sounding like a real super vagina here. And super vaginas aren't scientifically accurate. Honestly, I'm not even sure what a super vagina is. I guess it might maybe be, like, a superhero that does a lot of Kegel exercises or whatever? I don't know. I know I looked through a science book for 45 minutes and the closest thing I could find was this regular vagina.

Gotye6.jpg
Regarding traditional, non-super vaginas, there is no mention of Gotye.
Incidentally, I also read about valence electrons because it was what came immediately after "vagina" in the book's index and when you're a scientist you just read about science shit for fun. I was surprised to find this:

Gotye3.jpg
It seems like an otherwise innocuous example of a chemical equation; that is, until you focus on the solely on the chemical formulas. Check it, yo:

My Voice Nation Help
58 comments
Nobody
Nobody

I wish them nothing but the worse.

robinbsmith
robinbsmith

I think this may have been the largest pile of hipster shit I've ever seen.

douchefag
douchefag

HES A SUPER VAGINA, BUT YOUR A TRY HARD FAGGOT WHO FAILS AT TRYING TO BE OVER THE TOP FUNNY.

Chezmamere
Chezmamere

you got the reactants and products mixed up dude, but that's the least of your problems. 

patschican
patschican

I found this comment because I came across the video of the little kids singing this song and thought, awww, isn't that just the cutest...I wonder what the original song sounds like? Cut to two minutes later - me watching the original music video and BLEEDING FROM THE EARS. Are people kidding with this shit? Have we lost all sense of musical integrity, tone, melody...etc? HOW is this song so popular? Anyway, after I recovered, I immediately googled "somebody I used to know sucks", and you were the first hit. Thank you for this blog, if for no other reason than to allow me to know I am not alone in my utter hatred of this song.

Caseyquinn
Caseyquinn

This is genius and exactly what i was looking for

Johnson Von Trapp
Johnson Von Trapp

Bro???? Er, you are a Geographically and Culturally challenged Wanker.Lazy Crocodile Dundee references from a Smartarse who doesn't do enough research."Why this Critic sucks".

ben
ben

well the song really is bad. The lyrics and melody are very banal.  This just goes to show the crap the industry pushes. The formula vagina coefficient  was symbolic of the what ever it takes to  push trends formulas and marketing to the masses by the bean counters in the tanking music industry,   The song is ultra predictable. the background music does nothing. The only reason why this is popular is how he opens up on the second part of the song with some Sting mannerisms. Kids who ,missed the 80's can feel like they have something to. Men without hats was a million times better

god
god

writer is obviously a moron looking for some attention.  do the society a favor, go kill yourself.  the world will be better without you around.  you are a waste of sperm.  now you a somebody the world  never knew, woot!

Jodie Leanne
Jodie Leanne

Looks like the song had hit more than a nerve for this author. But I'm sorry, my heart doesn't bleed for you.

CriticalBeatdown
CriticalBeatdown

music snobbery ... 2 pages of why a song sucks.  but oh so witty ... try applying those writing skills to actually creating something.   

Sheilamonique2
Sheilamonique2

Is this not considered bullying?? If you dont like it, change the channel. Why hate on someone trying to make money as a musician...ridonk!

Pee Bee
Pee Bee

You got paid to write this shit?

Vanzilla
Vanzilla

I'm all for you hating Gotye; you're entitled to your opinion after all. ... but if you're going to write for LA Weekly, please at least say something worth reading.

You're like the unfunny, econo-bastard sibling of Hyperboleandahalf. Please stop writing. It hurts us.

Mike
Mike

Shea Serrano used to write equally crap articles for the Houston version of this blog

B20di3
B20di3

I would suggest finding something more constructive to do Shea

CM
CM

How did my 12-year old cousin manage to hack into the LA Weekly computers and cobble together this shyte?

Oaza
Oaza

Stupid article of stupid American....

Whahuh?
Whahuh?

I'm sorry, lol. I was just looking at the "female" diagram and forgot what I was reading.

stylevegas
stylevegas

Goyte is from Belgium - lives in AustraliaLimbra is from New Zealand - just so you know Author

sgallo
sgallo

My vagina is more intelligent  than Shea Serrano's critique. 

La weeklame
La weeklame

This article is junk. I've just lost all respect for the LA Weekly.

MusicMaker
MusicMaker

Shea Serrano your article sucks..because you have no concept of music and for that matter writing as well.  

Cptfez
Cptfez

By pointing out that the made up equation spells out Gotye Super Vagine (are you 12?) is one of those 'explain your own joke' scenarios, which make the joke unfunny. Unfortunately in this case, the 'joke' was shit anyway. Congratulations on reaching new levels of terrible.

person
person

Why This Article Sucks: there are not enough hours in existence to explain. I wish the writer would stop thinking forever, and by the way LA Weekly... this article really sucks.

sub-addict
sub-addict

I have heard so many songs that suck in the last few years,,, I've heard sh*t like - Ke$ha, beiber, the last 7years of the Black Eyed Peas, MDNA/Nickie Manaj/MIA superbowl crap get called "good music" This song is not bad. It's so good it's getting overplayed and losing it's shine cause the 'media' squeezes every ounce of life it can from stuff that genuinely does not suck cause it's so rare these days. Doesn't the author know anything about the music business?

Rageaholic
Rageaholic

I hate this song, but I hate this article even more.  Was it just an excuse to say vagina a lot?

Pee Bee
Pee Bee

I'm thinking writing vagina is the closest this author ever gets to one.

Benny
Benny

Shea Serrano: Somebody that I used to read... But not anymore. The "science" is increasingly iffy, analysis is always inane, and besides - I'd rather hear a thousand more songs like this on the radio than one more POS by the likes of One Direction, Katy Perry, Chris Brown, et al.

e.a.
e.a.

I always imagine it is Ozzy singing this song at the chorus part.

Daniel
Daniel

Shea Serrano... You are proof of why this publication is digging itself deeper into an already enormous trench as the days roll by. Keep the intelligence coming, you are embarrassing no one except for yourself. 

Beautyrepublik
Beautyrepublik

What are you talking about? Do you even know what you are saying? Let's all agree that you should stop writing and just not talk. Thank You.

Blum
Blum

What the heck is this really about?  Atmopsherics? Scientific analysis in LA Weekly?  What a waste of time and space!

Lp104
Lp104

It's funny to see someone put so much time and effort into hating something for no real good reason.

And this Shea person gets paid for crap like this?

What a waste.

Ndu2
Ndu2

And nobody pays you for your two cents...wah wah.

Daniel
Daniel

Exactly... Thousands of educated individuals are looking for jobs, while people like are Shea are paid to write precious gems such as the one above in LA Weekly.  

Hns
Hns

You lost me at vagina. Wtf is this dudebro article?!

Pee Bee
Pee Bee

My vagina could write a better article than this.

Trevorgreen07
Trevorgreen07

Thank god for this article, I hate this song sooooo much.  It's overplayed and is not that good of a song whatsoever.  If anything it is kind of pretentious, especially after seeing that music video.

Lp104
Lp104

Ok, so why or how is it pretentious? Because he was being creative and bringing a little artistry back into the music video?

Hey listen, just because you have poor taste in music and no one agrees with you, except of course for the boneheaded writer of this remarkably retarded article, doesn't mean you should hate on it.

Guest
Guest

The song is absolute shit and the video is a pile of hipster art trash. You sir are the one with poor taste in music. Congrats on fueling musical mediocrity.

Bowmansbump
Bowmansbump

Each subsequent article I read in the LA Weekly clearly reveals how you are all pretentious hipster haters.  Believe me this song has obviously been played to death, but it's still an extremely well-written song.  I don't know if you guys were going for a tongue-in-cheek thing here and I'm too dense to pick it up, but it sounds more like you're perpetuating the stereotype of snobby LA hipsters only digging random under-the-radar shit until the collective masses pick up on it.

MTkill_a_manJaro
MTkill_a_manJaro

I suppose this would be a great article to me if this treatment was given to a song I knew about and hated enough to read companion articles about

Ndu2
Ndu2

And yet nothing stopped you from wasting your life leaving that dumbass comment???

MTkill_a_manJaro
MTkill_a_manJaro

your comment would be appropriate if i had said something along the lines of reading this article was a waste of my time, but I didnt. I said it'd be great if the writer took the time to write this type of article to a song I hated. 

And about me wasting my life with dumbass comments, the same could be said about you, troll

Poop
Poop

troll boy mad

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

Los Angeles Event Tickets
©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city