The 20 Greatest Metal Albums in History: The Complete List


220px-Sleep's_Holy_Mountain.jpg

8. Sleep
Holy Mountain (1993)
If you are going to name your record after one of the trippiest films of all time, you have to be prepared to deliver a seriously mind-altering experience. San Jose stoner metal pioneers Sleep rose to the challenge on their 1993 genre masterpiece, Sleep's Holy Mountain. The colossal riffage begins with the deceptively groovy "Dragonaut" and from there on out one's ears are offered only the briefest of respites. When Sleep chooses to turn the volume down, as on the 48 second bluegrass interval titled "Some Grass," it is only to prepare the listener for the next pummeling assault.
-Emmett Shoemaker

220px-Black_Sabbath_-_Master_of_Reality.png

7. Black Sabbath
Master of Reality (1971)
Black Sabbath deliberately down-tuned for their third effort, Master of Reality, which would become the very ore from which all gloomy, doomy and drudgy metal is mined. Crafted for altered mindstates, this is the band at their stoniest. Prickly critics of the time (notably Bangs and Christgau) failed to see this as the one of ghosts of metal future, despite the act's forward-thinking techniques and fiercely honest outsider attitude. And, yes, there is even cowbell. -Paul Bradley

220px-Black_Sabbath_debut_album.jpg

6. Black Sabbath
Black Sabbath (1970)
Fittingly released on Friday the 13th, Black Sabbath's eponymous 1970 debut spawned heavy metal as we know it. Brooding, satanic, and deeply bluesy, Black Sabbath contains some of the group's best and darkest material. The title track in particular, which incorporates a dirging tri-tone interval, church bells, and Ozzy Ozbournes's impassioned, damnable wailing, is frightening even by today's standards. While the Ozzman's harmonica work on "The Wizard" may have aged less gracefully, the album remains unstoppably heavy, an unparalleled classic. -Emmett Shoemaker

My Voice Nation Help
129 comments
fredley
fredley

Complete garbage list. I have read two articles and have already realized LA weekly is clueless about music and the whole publication is a joke to generate "troll buzz". No better than some trash filled gossip magazine you would see in a checkout line at Walmart.

MichaelAlucard
MichaelAlucard

Lists are all personal. You should all shut the fuck up or try and make your way up the ladder to become a published music journalist and write your own. I don't agree with alot of these either, but seriously, quit bitching. 

metoo
metoo

No Black Metal at all ?  What about Doom Metal ? Or Drone ? Get an Update!

sarcasticmann
sarcasticmann

Really?  You put in every damn Black Sabbath Album and totally forget the Metallica Black Album (22 million sold), which means it is a pretty good album and much listened to!  It sounds like your "Journalists" need to go back to school!

kyran.grimm
kyran.grimm

Haha. No way! Master of puppets is number 1 every day of the week. Paranoid, Reign in blood etc just do not have solos like on the master of puppets track. The guitaring, drumming and singing is the ground on which metal stands. I dont care who pioneered what. Class is class 1969 or 2013. Wheres number of the beast??

farrellg505
farrellg505

Death--human, symbolic, itp, and of course the mans last brilliant work which is better than just about all these rekerds combined. And then there was morbid angel, bats and aom or even covenant, of course maybe there I'm pulling at straws.

Tough thing is, so many genres. But no death makes this list not just boring but an automatic fail. Thanks for playing.

thrashard888
thrashard888

indeed you're another regular listener. Listen more mate ;)

deusxmacxdeux
deusxmacxdeux

pffft.  any list of greatest metal bands that includes metallica and NOT led zeppelin is a complete farce.

klesto92
klesto92

@deusxmacxdeux It is not, led zeppelin was NEVER metal but things like blackwater park being higher than Master Of Puppets is what makes it a complete farse. There is not even a death album and there is on from at the gates? Then iron maiden's piece of mind instead of powrslave or the number of the beast. Slayers reign in blood is amazing but it does not deserve the number 1 spot by any means. No kreator either?? This list is pretty bad but not because led zeppelin is not included. Led Zeppelin simply does not belong here.

Jon-o Tron
Jon-o Tron like.author.displayName 1 Like

There needs to be a staff change at LA weekly.

Jon-o Tron
Jon-o Tron

I want to meet this person who wrote this.

Nay Josephine
Nay Josephine

Exactly how many people voted on this? O.o This person sure loves Sabbath.

Davin Singh Alexandre
Davin Singh Alexandre

I'm impressed that you guys put At The Gates. Kudos. I know It's annoying how everyone is a critic and shit, but still, you guys fucked up by not putting a single Death album in there. Chuck Schuldiner is tossing in his grave.

MJS562
MJS562

Where's Ride the Lightning? Seriously! 

Jeffrey D Thompson
Jeffrey D Thompson

Also just read the 20 Worst Bands of All Time list. And to whomever compiled that list, you're a bunch of fucking idiots! The complete pretentious fuckwits that decided upon that list haven't a clue(with the exception of the Eagles and Hootie and the Blowfish

Shawn McGinnis
Shawn McGinnis

Come on. No Number of the Beast, Ride the Lightning, or Holy Diver? wtf?

Esteban Mainzer
Esteban Mainzer

"operation mindcrime" by queensryche should be on there as well.

Esteban Mainzer
Esteban Mainzer

there's like 6 black sabbath albums on there, and "pyromania" by def leppard isn't on there at all? no "shout at the devil" by motley crue?

Greg Weister
Greg Weister

Way too many Sabbath albums. But #1 is pretty accurate.

xxthejackalxx
xxthejackalxx like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Stopped reading at "Baroness."  Gimme a break.

pbonito_
pbonito_

Props for 'Bomber' over 'Ace of Spades' though.

pbonito_
pbonito_

If by 'Greatest' you mean 'Most overrated', then #1 is definitely #1. Otherwise, no.

thuswegrow
thuswegrow like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

WORST FUCKING LIST EVER, THIS LIST WAS CREATED BY SOME DUMB YOUNG A-HOLE

maarten1616
maarten1616 like.author.displayName 1 Like

Here' are some aditional suggestions from a Dutch metal-head:

Carcass - Heartwork.
Death - Symbolic.
Cannibal Corpse - The Bleeding.
Opeth - My arms, your hearse.

Greeting from the Netherlands

andyair
andyair

No EXODUS - Bonded By Blood means you this list is null and void!!!

jeffreyjeff.000
jeffreyjeff.000 like.author.displayName 1 Like

At the same point and time that Metal Historians had Black Sabbath inventing the genre, Deep Purple released their highly underrated album In Rock (June 1970).  Listen to Ritchie Blackmore riffing on Speed King and tell me he didn't invent speed metal.  Listen to Ian Gillian wailing on Child In Time and tell me that this is not the first metal ballad.  Deep Purple should get as much respect as metal pioneers as Sabbath does.  And In Rock should be in the top three.

runningtoalice
runningtoalice like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 4 Like

You should only list ONE ALBUM by each band or solo act.

JimmyRustler
JimmyRustler

except #1 which I can't  argue with. This list fucking sucks cock double time. Not one real fucking death metal band on the whole list. Opeth is ok but melodic DM is not really death metal. Sorry author but 1990 called it wants its taste in metal back.

deyanruggieri
deyanruggieri

@JimmyRustler Maybe there's no death metal albums on this list, because death metal is a terrible genre that can't be taken seriously.

JimmyRustler
JimmyRustler

@deyanruggieri @JimmyRustler well musical tastes are subjective but without the inclusion of such bands as Death and Cannibal Corpse (the current lineup), this list cannot be taken seriously by any real metalhead. Sorry your jimmies were rustled by the truth.

ruggieri_deyan_
ruggieri_deyan_

@JimmyRustler @deyanruggieri Haha. Metal enthusiast? You're an even bigger faggot than I thought. You keep using the phrase "butthurt" and "rustling jimmies" even though I can imagine, based on your crybaby attitude because you didn't get what you wanted, that you're crying behind the computer screen like a little bitch over some list. Get bent. 

MetalMayhem
MetalMayhem like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

How could they forget about Death. Chuck Schuldiner was a genius.

Ballsackss123
Ballsackss123

Wow big surprise not a single glam metal album included. Media bias from the elitist 'true' heavy metal community. Wheres Motley's Shout At The Devil, Quiet Riot's Metal Health, WASP's Self titled debut, Ratt's Out of the Cellar or X japan's Bue Blood.

Oh I forgot, those bands wore makeup, had big hair, and wore crazy clothes. Automatically that makes them 'posers' I guess.


QR broke records and boundaries with Metal Health. Oh no, 14 year old elitists everywhere will cry "poser" if any Glam band makes the list...

Aptenodytes
Aptenodytes

Gahhh.... compilers of these lists can never tell the difference between 'great' and 'famous'. Only one of these albums is in my top 400. Here's a much better Top 20 (I stuck to only one album per band):-

WINDIR - Arntor
ORPHANED LAND - Mabool
DARKESTRAH - Epos
FOREFATHER - Steadfast
SKEPTICISM - Stormcrowfleet
SHAPE OF DESPAIR - Illusion's Play
KALEVALA - Kudel Belosnezhnogo Lna
OPETH - Blackwater Park
MOONSORROW - Viides Luku - Hävitetty
INSOMNIUM - Since The Day It All Came Down
AGALLOCH - Ashes Against the Grain
SUMMONING - Oath Bound
ARKONA - Ot Serdtsa K Nebu
PSILOCYBE LARVAE - Stigmata
FINSTERFORST - ...zum Tode hin
NERTHUS - Black Medieval Art
RUINS OF BEVERAST - Foulest Semen of a Sheltered Elite
INQUISITION - Invoking the Majestic Throne of Satan
INCANTATION - Onward to Golgotha
PESTE NOIRE - La Sanie des siècles - Panégyrique de la dégénérescence

klesto92
klesto92

@Aptenodytes No to everything and I would trade Blackwater Park for Ghost Reveries.

big1dawg
big1dawg like.author.displayName 1 Like

@Aptenodytes This isn't the twenty greatest metal albums that no one's ever heard of.

jerms31177
jerms31177 like.author.displayName 1 Like

All I have to say... the biggest metal band in history is Metallica. Critics may not say they are the best, but the fans have spoken over the years. To only have the biggest metal band ever represented only once is disgraceful

big1dawg
big1dawg

@jerms31177 Metallica's the most successful, but definitely not the greatest, imo.

d.jeffrey39
d.jeffrey39 like.author.displayName 1 Like

\m/ (-_-) \m/  F$%&*%IN SLAYER!!!!!!

Philip J. Fry
Philip J. Fry

Rust In Peace is #14? did u use random numbering or something?? and where's Sepultura?

From the Vault

 

Los Angeles Event Tickets
Loading...