Time to Do Away With the Word "Jazz"?

Categories: #BAM, Jazz

payton.jpg
Michael Wilson
In person, the bearded and bald-headed Nicholas Payton does not look like one of the most polarizing figures in modern jazz. The 39-year-old trumpeter is a calm and quiet presence. Whether he intended to or not, however, after posting a blog entry in late 2011 entitled "On Why Jazz Isn't Cool Anymore," a blizzard of controversy descended upon him, inciting late night, off-the-record conversations that prompted twice as many questions as answers.

The rub? Payton's determination to do away with the term "jazz" in favor of the phrase "Black American Music" or as his tweets have fashionably reduced it, "#BAM."

Payton is the New Orleans-born son of bassist Walter Payton, and appeared on the scene in the early 1990s as a brash young lion, releasing a string of records on Verve and winning a Grammy at the age of 23. Right now he's in town teaching private lessons at the Monk Institute at UCLA, and hosts a master class (a lecture and discussion) this Thursday at Schoenberg Hall.

"I wasn't trying to start anything," Payton says of the incendiary post. "It wasn't even fully conceived. I was tweeting off the dome and after a certain amount of time I took all the tweets and put them in order."

Here are some examples from the piece:

Playing Jazz is like using the rear-view mirror to drive your car on the freeway.

People are too afraid to let go of a name that is killing the spirit of the music.

Payton followed by responding to detractors with open letters, addressing fellow musicians like saxophonist Marcus Strickland, trumpeter Jeremy Pelt, bassist Christian McBride and saxophonist Branford Marsalis. Through them he outlined his disappointment, and strengthened his argument.

"People always try to use European ideology to tear down Black music, to try and make the claim that Black people appropriated European harmony," says Payton. "Europeans didn't create harmony. It exists first of all in nature. We are all harmonic beings. Blacks haven't appropriated European harmony as much as those rules that govern Western thought have been used as a way of legitimatizing or discrediting the Black American aesthetic."

Location Info

Venue

Map

UCLA Royce Hall

340 Royce Drive, Westwood, CA

Category: Music

2 user reviews
Write A Review
Save to foursquare
Powered by Voice Places
My Voice Nation Help
43 comments
progress.hornsby
progress.hornsby

When it comes to the origin of the word “jazz,” it seems that each person simply believes what she or he wants to. Some people would like the word to come from Africa, so they firmly believe the stories that support that. Others want it to be an African American word, so they look for that. But professional linguists have been on the case for decades, and the real story is a lot less black and white.

The BOTTOM LINES in this discussion are:

1. Nobody knows for sure the etymology of the word “jazz”!! (Even the professionals have not found an earlier word or words, from English or any other language, that “morphed” into the word “jazz.”)

2. The word does not appear to have been invented by African Americans and is not from New Orleans. It seems to have originated among white people (European Americans), and the earliest printed uses of it are in California baseball writing, where it means “lively, energetic.”(Note: The word still has this meaning, as in “Let’s jazz this up”!) The earliest one yet found was in the LA Times, April 2, 1912, as you can see below. This text was discovered by researcher George A. Thompson. 

BEN'S JAZZ CURVE.

"I got a new curve this year," softly murmured Henderson yesterday, "and I'm goin' to pitch one or two of them tomorrow.I call it the Jazz ball because it wobbles and you simply can't do anything with it."

Remember, they are talking baseball here. The line "it wobbles and you can't do anything with it" possibly refers to jazz's syncopation and, to the untrained ear, erratic rhythms.

3. Whites started to call the new music “jazz” in Chicago (and possibly California) in 1915. Because it was a new word, and it was slang, spellings varied at first (jazz, jas, jaz, jass, jasz), but since 1918 it has been “jazz.”

4. Whites meant the word “jazz” as a compliment (meaning that the music was lively and exciting), not an insult!


larryrthomas
larryrthomas

 WHAT IS JAZZ? by LARRY RENI THOMAS

  Jazz is a term that was given to American classical music around 1900, by the New Orleans aristocrats who after visiting the whorehouses and hearing the black musicians play the sounds of freedom, sought to deny it its dignity when they realized that they couldn't play it and that their associates could not play it either. It has never belonged to black people nor will it ever. When the aristocrats realized that they could exploit it and make money off of it, the music, which is a reflection of the African-American musical reaction to the modern era, they took it over and have controlled it ever since. The first recorded "j-ass" (short for jack-ass) recording was performed by a group of people who the aristocrats selected. It would have been unthinkable and unprofitable to use black people to record black music.
 

American classical music has always had trouble with its African-American core because it has always been given a negative meaning. I interviewed Art "Buhania" Blakey several years ago after a concert at Duke University and he was highly ticked off because there were almost no black people in attendance. When I asked him was there a conspiracy to keep the music away from black people, he said, "Hell, no!" Buhania went on to say that black people don't particularly like it and have been told by black preachers not to listen to the music because it was "devil's music."
 

I have been a jazz radio announcer/writer for three decades and have heard many blacks tell me that they don't like jazz because it moves too fast or slow, there is not enough soulful singing, or that white folks like it. These are all absurd reasons of course, but that's reality. How do we solve it? How do we reverse decades of fear and ignorance? Good questions. Maybe we should ask the aristocrats--the 10 families or .001% of the world who run things. The answer is to keep on doing what we are doing by promoting it, playing it on the radio and by posing such questions and challenging the status quo when they keep trying to make it something that it isn't. It is BLACK MUSIC and it will continue to be for another 100 years. Just like we know that the Old Dixieland Jass Band was some watered down, mediocre music, we will know that most of the music we hear these days that passes itself off as American classical music is as phony as a three dollar bill.

deelightful14u
deelightful14u

please read the history oif jazz . u will read nick la rocca a dark skined sicialian from new orleans changed the spelling from jass to jazz after jim crow stoped clobes from hiriieing "colords" & the promotion posters were grafeteed by crossing the j off spelling .ass so zz stoped that ;)

progress.hornsby
progress.hornsby

@deelightful14u 

Dee:  I have read quite a few  different histories of jazz and have heard that myth about the promotion posters before.  I think it appeared first in a book written in 1938 and it made a good story so people took to repeating it.  It would be silly to believe that any one person or event put the word 'jazz' into the lexicon.  Even if it was one person I doubt it would have been Nick LaRocca.  And if people really went around crossing one letter off of jazz posters leaving the word "ass" then guitarist Joe Pass would have surely changed his name.

larryrthomas
larryrthomas

Jazz is a term created by those who wanted to deny this majestic, highly-creative art form its dignity.  It was given the name by New Orleans aristocrats who after visiting the whore houses and hearing blacks play sounds of freedom, decided they would call it "jack-ass" music (-j-ass).  The black musicians who created it, didn't call it jazz.  Whites can play it, too, but most of them have respect for and know that it is a black creation.  Red Rodney, Bill Evans, and others actually associated and hung out with black musicians.  As a writer/radio announcer who has been in the business since 1978, I totally agree with Nick. After all, as a musician, he has the right to call it whatever he wants to.  Right on, Nick!

Jose Aguilar
Jose Aguilar

Tell him to suck on it. Jazz will always be jazz. Tryna coin a term.

Kenny Iraheta
Kenny Iraheta

? To many other genres would go under this term: blues, soul, hip hop, etc. If its recognition he wants, he ought to contact Ken Burns and ask him to create a doc on all the genres created by African-Americans. However, though many internationally popular music genres were created by African-Americans, these genres were also expanded by people of other colors.

cultofsoc
cultofsoc

@Kenny Iraheta I wouldn't count on Ken Burns to relay the message.

David Nunes-Childs
David Nunes-Childs

I propose they change the name to jezz. And so you could say, 'ooh, that's jezzy.' aww yea

Ben Childs
Ben Childs

Are you kidding? Jazz might be one of the coolest words ever invented.

Oscar Pascual
Oscar Pascual

That's dumb as Hell. Fishbone, Bad Brains, and Living Colour can be considered Black American Music and is the farthest thing from jazz.

cultofsoc
cultofsoc

@Oscar Pascual Vernon Reid might disagree that his playing is the farthest thing from jazz.

Pauline Angela Adamek
Pauline Angela Adamek

"Black American Music"? That's way too broad a term. WAY too ambiguous and not helpful. Jazz is a subset of music. BAM can mean rap, jazz, soul, gospel, hip-hop, be-bop -- need I go on?!

Erik Walker
Erik Walker

Only if he changes his name to Delusional Egomaniac

Joe Bartone
Joe Bartone

boring. God, do we really have to have this dull debate again? Just another musician who thinks what he does is in service to God Almighty. It's just music. It doesn't save lives. The Postman's job is more important.

cultofsoc
cultofsoc

@Joe Bartone At least musicians will still work on Saturdays.

Jeffrey D Thompson
Jeffrey D Thompson

Idiotic! That's Rap's title right? Just play your horn and shut up

Kevin Lewis
Kevin Lewis

obviously none of you read the article, he needs no publicity.

Walter Delmar
Walter Delmar

no one person can single-handed create anything. its impossible to not be influenced by your environment when creating.

La Dance Mob
La Dance Mob

What about all the other forms of Black American music? He wants everything under one category?

Jordan Melton
Jordan Melton

Considering he single-handedly created jazz, I'd say he's in the right.

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

Clubs

Los Angeles Event Tickets
©2013 LA Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Los Angeles

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city